The best comps are probably Brouwer and Belesky, guys who put up similar numbers and had similar styles leading into the same summer. One had a bit higher cap hit, the other lower, but both had much shorter terms. Belesky looks bad for entirely bottoming out, but Boston has already moved on from him. And both would be in the next to last year of their deals.
If Gator can play his normal physical game and put up 40 points, I like it. If not, I'm less of a fan. If he starts putting up 20 points regularly, it's just plain bad.