Prior to the 2010-2011 season, I surveyed all 20 OHL GM's on a variety of things. One of them was "who is the OHL's best defenceman heading into their draft years, taking into account their careers to date and potential?"
11 of 20 GM's gave Scott Harrington a first place vote, 5 for Ryan Murphy and 4 for Dougie Hamilton.
Harrington never lived up to expectations, concussions almost ended Murphy's career and never reached his potential and Dougie is Dougie.
The thing is, that at the time I asked the question, those 11 GM's probably weren't wrong. These things are fluid and change with the wind. Sometimes they get worse, and sometimes they come out of nowhere and bingo, you have the uncertainty of the NHL Draft.
I find the draft process fascinating dom but I have no delusion I have anything better than a monkey and a dartboard chance of scouting these guys myself. some of the greatest performing chl kids of all time had fatal flaws that true scouts identified and wisely avoided. seen it myself time and time again some kid like wes walz or dave pasin could just tear up the chl and they were always doomed to have limited or non-exist nhl careers.
and then... so many all time greats drop into the later rounds because they simply werent finished products at draft age.
I envy your ability to be involved in this world and am impressed by your successful track record. I will always say some posters here are far too harsh on criticizing the bruins record. ultimately I feel success and failure as a draft evaluator has to be measured against your peers. its like hitting in baseball to me. if no one else bats better than .350 then its insane to criticise your guy for batting .345
sometimes failure is the norm... sometimes a below 500 batting average is hall of fame worthy
and ive seen the consensus draft lists for 20 or more years and they tend to suck a lot... I have a collection of hockey news future watch it tends to suck... I have seen the tsn guys do their lists... I got red line a few years. I try my best to educate myself, but ive never seen a list where its much better than our own record
I say again... when you look at real nhl players that the bruins graduated to the NHL who are still playing... NO TEAM IN NHL has a better collection {and remember our draft position usually sucks}
we drafted high end scoring like
seguin
kessel
marchand
Bergeron
debrusk
and identified freeagent wheeler to sign...
hows that for top 6 firepower?
we either drafted or signed as an ufa
McAvoy
Hamilton
carlo
krug
trust me, thats one hell of a top 4 built for the new nhl
and in goal
we identified tuuka rask and plucked him from the maple leaf organization
if that isnt crazy star power to lead the team... we can roll out a 3rd like with thornton/krejci/lucic
and a 4th line with kuraly/Heinen/kuhlman/donato/sobotka
round out our defense with Clifton/miller...
backup goaltender might be the weakest spot on the team... but the other 22 roster spots are filled with star quality options
its really been a golden age of drafting/developing kids into the nhl for our organization over the past 20 years