Zach Hyman Or Josh Anderson?

[HarryLime]

idk but it's funny that everyone coming in is saying AINEC for either guy

 

[ViewsFromThe6ix]

Ya the 40 % voting for Hyman is Hilarious considering 90% of that 40% are Leaf fans. Take away the Leaf vote and it would 90% to 10% for Anderson. Now that's too funny.

Again, HF Boards said Benning>Dubas and Laine>Matthews, so why should anyone take polls seriously?

This website is 90% morons and Leaf haters.

 

[All Mod Cons]

Both have been invisible the last couple of weeks.

 

[Canadiens Ghost]

Spezza has more points than Anderson does this season.

And Anderson has only one goal less in three less games with less PP time than Tavares... what's your point?

 

[Namikaze Minato]

And Anderson has only one goal less in three less games with less PP time than Tavares... what's your point?

So he also has less goals and points than Tavares as well as having less points than a 4th line jason spezza. I agree, not a good look.

 

[Canadiens Ghost]

So he also has less goals and points than Tavares as well as having less points than a 4th line jason spezza. I agree, not a good look.

11 million $ for pajama boy and he only has 1 more goal with 3 more games played, more pp time and more ice time per game playing on an offensively loaded team... Agreed. Not a good look on Tavares.

An now reverse the roles. Put Anderson on the Leafs and Hyman on the Habs. Game, set, match in favor of Anderson.

 

[MatthewsAuston]

11 million $ for pajama boy and he only has 1 more goal with 3 more games played, more pp time and more ice time per game playing on an offensively loaded team... Agreed. Not a good look on Tavares.

An now reverse the roles. Put Anderson on the Leafs and Hyman on the Habs. Game, set, match in favor of Anderson.

Tavares has more points than anyone on your roster... really not a good look on tavares

 

[Namikaze Minato]

11 million $ for pajama boy and he only has 1 more goal with 3 more games played, more pp time and more ice time per game playing on an offensively loaded team... Agreed. Not a good look on Tavares.

An now reverse the roles. Put Anderson on the Leafs and Hyman on the Habs. Game, set, match in favor of Anderson.

You have a 10.5 million dollar goalie with a .901 save % so i dont think you should be throwing stones from your glass house.

If you put Anderson on the leafs instead of Hyman he would be playing on our third line and i dont think he suits that role nearly as well as Hyman can. He certainly wouldnt take Nylander or Marners spots in the top 6 RW positions.

 

[1specter]

Pretty easily Hyman. People make the linemates argument but Hyman brings success to every single line he is on; all of the Leafs' best line combos over the last 4 years have had Zach Hyman on them. Even this season we had a 3 game set with the Oilers in which he played alongside Mikheyev and Engvall, he was the main driver on that line and they were matched directly against McDavid who they ate for breakfast. Hyman potted a few goals too just from sheer effort.

 

[Canadiens Ghost]

At 11 million $, I would hope so.

 

[Canadiens Ghost]

You have a 10.5 million dollar goalie with a .901 save % so i dont think you should be throwing stones from your glass house.

At 10.5, Price totally sucks and I have no problems admitting that. That's why my tag line is Mr. Objectivity. Something lacking on these boards.

 

[Namikaze Minato]

At 10.5, Price totally sucks and I have no problems admitting that. That's why my tag line is Mr. Objectivity. Something lacking on these boards.

Then you should know, objectively, that JT is a good player regardless of his current cost. I do have a feeling that you, like me, are mostly just taking the piss but this is a Hyman V Anderson thread anyways so maybe we should get back into that.

 

[Canadiens Ghost]

Then you should know, objectively, that JT is a good player regardless of his current cost. I do have a feeling that you, like me, are mostly just taking the piss but this is a Hyman V Anderson thread anyways so maybe we should get back into that.

Of course Tavares is still a good player and I like him because he's won me a couple fantasy pools.
But you're the one that brought the Spezza comparison in the convo.
But I agree, back to the Anderson > Hyman discussion.


enough smillies for one night

 

[Bouboumaster]

Needless to say, it's Josh Anderson hands down.

Hyman is feisty, gutsy, play hard and play with heart, and I would take him on the Habs too, but Anderson is all that, bigger, tougher, faster and equipped with a lethal wrist shot.

Only downside is the terrible contract but so far so good.

Dude's a f***ing beast. I think he put the nail into the coffin of this thread last night

 

[Hockeyholic]

Needless to say, it's Josh Anderson hands down.

Hyman is feisty, gutsy, play hard and play with heart, and I would take him on the Habs too, but Anderson is all that, bigger, tougher, faster and equipped with a lethal wrist shot.

Only downside is the terrible contract but so far so good.

Dude's a f***ing beast. I think he put the nail into the coffin of this thread last night[/QUOTE]

That's not how it works.

What if Hyman scores a hat trick in game 2. While Anderson is a -3?

 

[Hockeyholic]

Needless to say, it's Josh Anderson hands down.

Hyman is feisty, gutsy, play hard and play with heart, and I would take him on the Habs too, but Anderson is all that, bigger, tougher, faster and equipped with a lethal wrist shot.

Only downside is the terrible contract but so far so good.

Dude's a f***ing beast. I think he put the nail into the coffin of this thread last night

What if Hyman scores a hat trick in game 2. While Anderson is a -3?

Will you be saying the same thing?

 

[Bouboumaster]

What if Hyman scores a hat trick in game 2. While Anderson is a -3?

Will you be saying the same thing?

The point is that Anderson can replicate what Hyman is able to do, but Hyman can't do what Anderson does.

 

[Goomba]

I get a feeling Hyman cant do what he does away from Matthews and co to the level Anderson can away from top talents

Separately I take Anderson but if Im the Devils and am looking for a LW for Hischier and Zacha (and it wasnt Bratt for some reason) id take Hyman over Anderson

 

[Byron Bitz]

Hyman is more consistent and Anderson is better when he’s at his best

 

[WetcoastOrca]

Playoffs I’d take Anderson. He’s just such a force.
Hyman is a good player though and never stops working.

 

[CristianoRonaldo]

Hyman is lucky to play with Auston...

 

[itwasaforwardpass]

lol at someone saying Anderson has great vision and iq.

 

[EscapeGoat]

Josh Anderson brings more when healthy but that's not often. He's injury prone.

 

[TheKrebsCycle]

lol at someone saying Anderson has great vision and iq.

Yah I took Anderson but the above aren't true.

 

[TS Quint]

Anderson at his best is a beast and at his best Hyman can't touch him. Game to game Hyman is better. Voted Hyman.