Your Team's All Time Lineup!

[RyK15*]

Here's the rules. In order to claim a player for your team, the player in question must have a) played at least 5 seasons with your team, b) won a Stanley Cup with your team, or c) be currently on the team and has played a minimum of 2 seasons with a contract that extends 3 more years. Also, I not a requirement, but I personally am going for a balanced team, with an enforcer and checking line and everything. GO!

Barber - Clarke - Kerr
LeClair - Lindros - Giroux
Poulin - Brind'Amour - Tocchet
Propp - Leach - Brown
MacLeish, Primeau

Desjardins - Pronger
McCrimmon - Howe
Timonen - Watson
Dupont

Parent
Hextall
Lindburgh

Coach - Shero

Holy Toughness!

Click to read more...

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

Why would you separate McCrimmon and Howe?

Something like this has been done before, but since you give specific guidelines as to the players who can count, this thread can stand alone.

Anyway this is my NJ Devils team using your criteria:

Patrik Elias - Kirk Muller - John MacLean
Stephane Richer - Scott Gomez - Claude Lemieux
Zach Parise - Bobby Holik - Jamie Langenbrunner
Jay Pandolfo - John Madden - Randy McKay

Scott Stevens - Brian Rafalski
Ken Daneyko - Scott Niedermayer
Bruce Driver - Paul Martin

Martin Brodeur
Chris Terreri

I could include Mogilny and Niewendyk as they won Cups with NJ, but I think that would be cheesy, as they didn't actually do much with the team. If they are included, the forwards look a lot better:

Patrick Elias - Joe Niewendyk - John MacLean
Zach Parise - Scott Gomez - Alexander Mogilny
Stephane Richer - Kirk Muller - Claude Lemieux
Jay Pandolfo - John Madden - Jamie Langenbrunner

 

[RyK15*]

Why would you separate McCrimmon and Howe?

Ddin't even realzie I did that! Fixed.

 

[EagleBelfour]

c) be currently on the team and has played a minimum of 2 seasons with a contract that extends 3 more years.

It's obvious you created that rule, JUST to put Chris Pronger on your first pairing

 

[kmad]

Vancouver Canucks:

Daniel Sedin - Henrik Sedin - Alexandre Burrows
Markus Naslund - Brendan Morrison - Todd Bertuzzi
Pavel Bure - Thomas Gradin - Tony Tanti
Trevor Linden - Ryan Kesler - Andre Boudrias
Cliff Ronning, Greg Adams

Mattias Ohlund - Ed Jovanovski
Harold Snepsts - Alexander Edler
Sami Salo - Jyrki Lumme
Doug Lidster

Roberto Luongo
Kirk McLean
Richard Brodeur

 

[Andros]

There aren't that many ducks that even qualify using your criteria, so the team ends up looking a lot like the cup winning squad:

Coach: Carlyle

Kariya-Rucchin-Selänne
Ryan-Getzlaf-Perry
Kunitz-McDonald-Penner
Moen-Pahlsson-Niedermayer

Pronger-O'Donnel
Niedermayer-Beauchemin
Salei-Tverdovsky

Giguere
Hebert

 

[David Bruce Banner]

Vancouver Canucks:

Sedin-Sedin-Burrows (obviously)
Naslund-Morrison-Bertuzzi (west coast express)
Bure-Gradin-Tanti (speed and skill)
Linden-Kesler-Boudrias (pretty good shut down line)
Ronning, Adams

Ohlund-Jovanovski
Snepsts-Edler
Salo-Lumme
Lidster

Luongo
McLean
Brodeur

Actually, I don't think we can field a team here, as the Canucks have never "b) won a Stanley Cup..."

Unless the OP meant either A, B or C

 

[kmad]

Actually, I don't think we can field a team here, as the Canucks have never "b) won a Stanley Cup..."

Unless the OP meant either A, B or C

Looking at the roster he posted, the OP almost definitely meant A, B or C.

 

[BubbaBoot]

FORWARDS
Wayne Cashman - Phil Esposito - Cam Neely
Johnny Bucyk - Adam Oates - Rick Middleton
Woody Dumart - Milt Schmidt - Bobby Bauer
Don Marcotte - Patrice Bergeron - Terry O'Reilly
spares: [ Herb Cain - Jean Ratelle - Ken Hodge ]

apologies to: Peter McNab, Johnny McKenzie, Derek Sanderson, Milan Lucic, Leo Labine, Keith Crowder, Eddie Westfall, Bill Cowley, Fleming Mackell, Joe Thornton, Cooney Weilland, Sergei Samsonov, Stan Jonathan, Johnny Peirson, Don McKenney, Barry Pederson, Vic Stasiuk, Randy Burridge, Steve Kasper, PJ Axelsson, Roy Conacher, Bobby Schmautz, Tommy Williams

DEFENSEMEN
Bobby Orr - Eddie Shore
Raymond Bourque - Brad Park
Dit Clapper - Fernie Flaman
spares: [ Zdeno Chara - Flash Hollett ]

apologies to: Jack Crawford, Lionel Hitchman, Dallas Smith, Don Awrey, Glen Wesley, Bill Quakenbush, Pat Egan, Hal Laycoe, Doug Mohns, Teddie Green, Leo Boivin

GOALKEEPERS
Tiny Thompson
Tim Thomas
spare: [Frankie Brimsek]

apologies to: Gerry Cheevers