How did your 8 GP 2 A prediction for Colaiacovo work out?
Kronwall dealt with injuries off and on all season which could not have been predicted. Wozniewski was not as much a favorite of Maurice's as I thought he was. So yes Carlo did get to play his version of hockey more often then I thought he would. Despite that it is possible Carlo is now over Kronwall and Woz on the depth chart for good, in fact he probably is.
However he was far from ever becoming the top 4 defenceman Leaf almost all fans like yourself predicted, in fact he was so far from being that it is the difference from that projection and reality is almost too enormous to describe. He ended the season dead last in ice time of the 6 regulars, the only guy under 18 minutes of ATOI, and his spot in the regular lineup is unlikely to last as new people come into the fray next year. White played over Carlo on the PP most of the season, Gill over him on the PK of course, and McCabe, Kaberle, and Kubina over him on both, further cementing him as only a #6, far from the top 4 guy predicted by the Leafs forum.
When it comes to Carlo vs White:
ATOI for 2005-2006 : White>Carlo
ATOI for 2006-2007 : White>Carlo
ATOI for 2007-2008 : White>Carlo
ATOI for 2008-2009 : White>Carlo
ATOI for 2009-2010 : White>Carlo
18 minutes or more in ATOI for a season: White every single season > Carlo never has and never will
Selections for World Championships : White at 22 on the team > Carlo at 24 never once invited, deemed "never good enough" unlike the superior White.
Age making the team out of training camp and staying: White at 22 and 3 months successful making team out of training camp and staying all season > Carlo at 22 and 8 months unsuccessful making team out of training camp, does not get shot with team until end of November/early December of that season due to injuries.
Carlo will have a real battle to just be the 7th "spare" defenceman next season. With White, Stralman, and Pilar all being picked for the world championships for their top countries, while Carlo is passed over, it shows how far his abilities are regarded below all of these. There are 4 veterans and only 2 "other" spots, and with White far over him on the depth chart for years now, Stralman the wonderkid coming over, Pilar who the Leafs are so high on back, the best Carlo can hope is to maybe get the 7th "spare" defenceman spot next season.
White has been over Carlo in every single way for a years now and continues to be. Carlo will never be over White in anyway ever again.