Channelcat
Unhinged user
If you were coaching the Jets, and they throw 5 thugs out there for the opening faceoff, who would you start?
Thorburn-Wright-Peluso
Buff Stuart
Seriously we could handle Calgary's 5 no problem and I got to say I would not want to be the 3rd toughest guy because you would have to handle Buff and he is no slouch
Thorburn-Wright-Peluso
Buff Stuart
Seriously we could handle Calgary's 5 no problem and I got to say I would not want to be the 3rd toughest guy because you would have to handle Buff and he is no slouch
I agree.
I'm with Torts that I wouldn't risk a player getting jumped. In the other thread I posted the video of sestito fighting Nolan who wanted nothing to do with it. If an idiot is set on fighting someone I'm not going to let it be my studs.
I see the other side of the coin, and in a perfect world I would send out my top line to score. I just don't trust a hit squad to not do something
Edit: I would have Pardy not Buff on the ice. No need to have Buff ejected if a brawl breaks out.
Sestito is a bad example. Nolan cheap shotted a Sedin
So...
People say refuse to fight.
If someone wants to fight you regardless of their motivation you're in a bad spot.
If Heartly throws them out to fight, you don't think they're as motivated to fight as Sestito was? That's their job, if their coach send them out there to fight they better fight. They don't add enough to not listen. What would happen to them if they didn't start something and got scored on? Get waived? Perhaps.
Sestito was sticking up for his captain. Calgary started off the game fighting. There's a huge difference there. Nolan turtled like he always does.
Huh.
I'm not defending Calgarys actions.
I'm defending torts for not putting out the Sedins.
If someone wants to fight bad enough (Sestito example) they'll fight. And you can't put skill players in that position.
Huh.
I'm not defending Calgarys actions.
I'm defending torts for not putting out the Sedins.
If someone wants to fight bad enough (Sestito example) they'll fight. And you can't put skill players in that position.
I would have put the Sedins out there. No one would blame them for turtling, or skating away if they got jumped...no one expects them to fight. The officials would pull them apart soon enough and you probably come out there with a couple of powerplays, and Hartley comes out looking like a fool, and probably the one to get a talking to by the league.
Westgarth proved Hartley's intentions by immediately grappling with Bieksa on the opening faceoff. Tortorella was correct in this matter.
There really isn't any proof that the brawl still would have resulted if the first line was sent out instead. IMHO, it played out the way it did, because Torts took the bait and responded with his own 'role players/goons'. Goons rarely fight stars; goons fight other goons, or at the very least, players who are known to be part-time fighters.
And it takes one punch from McGratten to concuss one of them.
Yeah you have the moral high ground meanwhile the one punch that he lands puts your best player on IR.