Your All-Time Teams

[sirius67fan]

It is really tough to narrow down a full lineup for the Ottawa 67's because we had so many quality Junior players that went on to have great NHL careers but we also had a lot of great junior players that never went to the NHL. But, here goes:

Forward:
Peter Lee - CHL Player of the year 75-76
Bobby Smith - CHL Player of the Year 77-78
Alyn McCauley - CHL Player of the Year 97-98
Corey Locke - CHL Player of the Year 02-03
Jim Fox - OHL Most Outstanding Player 79-80
Andrew Cassels - OHL Most Outstanding Player 87-88
Logan Couture
Sean Monahan
Michael Peca
Gary Roberts
Randy Cunneyworth
Tyler Toffoli

Defense:
Brian Campbell - CHL Player of the Year 98-99
Dennis Potvin - NHL Hall of Fame
Brad Shaw - OHL Most Outstanding Defenseman 83-84
Doug Wilson - 8 time NHL All Star
Ian Turnbull
Doug Crossman

Goaltender:
Danny Battochio
Levente Szuper
Petr Mrazek

Good list can't really argue on any of them. I would add as honorable mentions Ceci and Shane Prince. Going way back would also mention two great players whose careers in the nhl were cut short by injuries, Bruce Cassidy and Yvan Joly. Both were stellar junior players.

 

[HarrynLloyd]

Burakovsky- Mcdavid- O’Reilly
Pecker- Boyes- Alexeyev
Brown- Connelly- Nash
O’Marra – Strome- Karaulshchuk
McKegg (empty net specialist!)

Campoli- Lee
Colaiacovo- Pelech
Dermott- Hostetter
Liambus (suspension specialist!)

Aceti
Williams
Sadikov (celebratory specialist!)

 

[DD03]

Best effort for the Sudbury Wolves:

Dale Hunter - Paul Di Pietro - Ron Duguay
Rod Schutt - Michael Sgarbossa - Pat Verbeek
Nick Foligno - Mike Foligno - Marcus Foligno
Jason Jaspers - Derek MacKenzie - Mike Fisher

Randy Carlyle - Marc Staal
Jamie Rivers - Alexei Semenov
Adam McQuaid - Mike Gazdic

Don Beaupre
Mike Smith

I only started following the team in the 2000-2001 season, so this is kind of a mix of the recent and a mix of the old. There's obviously a ton of options to choose from.

Take out Jaspers and add in Glen Murray.

 

[PhlyerPhanatic31]

You don't have room for Brendan Shanahan, Tim Taylor or Steve Smith on you team?

Already approached the Shanahan issue...you could easily remove Allison and slot in Shanny..as for the other 2..I don't see who I'd drop in order to insert either.

 

[Whalers Fan]

Burakovsky- Mcdavid- O’Reilly
Pecker- Boyes- Alexeyev
Brown- Connelly- Nash
O’Marra – Strome- Karaulshchuk
McKegg (empty net specialist!)

Campoli- Lee
Colaiacovo- Pelech
Dermott- Hostetter
Liambus (suspension specialist!)

Aceti
Williams
Sadikov (celebratory specialist!)

No Connor Crisp in goal?

 

[Torts]

Burakovsky- Mcdavid- O’Reilly
Pecker- Boyes- Alexeyev
Brown- Connelly- Nash
O’Marra – Strome- Karaulshchuk
McKegg (empty net specialist!)

Campoli- Lee
Colaiacovo- Pelech
Dermott- Hostetter
Liambus (suspension specialist!)

Aceti
Williams
Sadikov (celebratory specialist!)

No Connor Crisp!?

Damn! Whalers fan beat me to it ^^^^

 

[h10*]

No Connor Crisp!?

Damn! Whalers fan beat me to it ^^^^

Connor Crisp was a guy you could always count on to play any role! And let's not forget.. The reason he struggled in net that game was because he forgot his goalie equipment back in Erie and was forced to use Sadikov's equipment which didn't fit him properly.

All time I would say Crisp is in the top 50 goalies has ever had!

 

[cole von cole]

Peterborough Petes\TPT:

Forward:
Tim Trimper Andre Lacroix Mickey Redmond
Bob Gainey Mark Teevans Jason Dawe
Kris King Mike Ricci Wayne Connelly
Danny Grant Eric Staal Cameron Mann

Defence:
Chris Pronger Larry Murphy
Barclay Plager Zac Bogosian
Kevin Bolibruck Greg Therberge

Goal:
Zac Bierk
Kay Whitemore

Not sure if you knew, but this guy named Steve Yzerman played for the Petes.

 

[themightyquinn]

I'll give Oshawa a try:

Ted Lindsay Eric Lindros Alex Delvecchio
John MacLean John Tavares Dave Andreychuk
Joe Cirella Marc Savard Rick Middleton
Tony Tanti Jason Arnott Terry O'Reilly
Wayne Cashman or Rob Pearson

Bobby Orr Charlie Huddy
Michael Del Zotto Calvin De Haan
Gord Murphy Dale DeGray
Bryan Allen

Kirk MacLean
Jeff Hackett
Fred Brathwaite

 

[tjziel]

Rick Nash - Jason Allison - Corey Perry
Robbie Schremp - John Tavares - Dino Cicarelli
Brendan Shanahan - Darryl Sittler - Patrick Kane
Max Domi - Bo Horvat - Mitch Marner
David Bolland

John Carlson - Marc Methot
Olli Maatta - Dennis Wideman
Daniel Girardi - Danny Syvret
John Erskine

Pat Riggin
Steve Mason
Michael Houser/Adam Dennis

 

[EvenSteven]

Here's mine for Kitchener.....

Just naming forwards regardless of position and in no particular order......
Bill Barber, Jeff Larmer, Brian Bellows,
Mike Richards, Skinner, Landeskog,
John Tucker, Steve Rice and Walt Tkachuk
Alternate: Sandy Fitzpatrick, *Paul Reinhart

Mayhem Line: Robbie Nichols, Mike Moher and Doug Sulliman

Defence: *Paul Reinhart, Scott Stevens, Al MacInnis, Dave Shaw, Larry Robinson and Paul Coffey on D

Goalies: Gibson and Don Edwards

Coach: Joe Crozier


* Paul Reinhart was an OHL allstar one year on defence and the next an allstar at forward therefore have him in both postions

Four Hall of Fame Defencemen but I believe it would have been 5 if Reinhart never suffered a back injury in his late twenties.

Solid line up, but other honorable mentions, or maybe a couple who could bump a player or two out of your starting 20:

Red Laurance
Dwight Foster
Shaun Burr
Wendel Young
Boyd Devereaux
Mike Torchia
Derek Roy

Some personnel favorites of mine who were damn good at what they did but may not crack the top roster:

Mark Montanari
Ron Goodall
Shayne Stevenson
Ron Sanko

 

[core33]

It is really tough to narrow down a full lineup for the Ottawa 67's because we had so many quality Junior players that went on to have great NHL careers but we also had a lot of great junior players that never went to the NHL. But, here goes:

Forward:
Peter Lee - CHL Player of the year 75-76
Bobby Smith - CHL Player of the Year 77-78
Alyn McCauley - CHL Player of the Year 97-98

Alyn was on the Leafs in 97-98.

 

[BigHitter67]

Good list can't really argue on any of them. I would add as honorable mentions Ceci and Shane Prince. Going way back would also mention two great players whose careers in the nhl were cut short by injuries, Bruce Cassidy and Yvan Joly. Both were stellar junior players.

IF the true criteria here is an all - OHL team (not taking NHL careers into account) then Cassidy absolutely makes this team! Arguably the purest offensive d-man to ever man the point with the Poles. His jr. numbers -especially before the devastating knee injury- were filthy!!

 

[battfan888]

While I am a Storm fan now I feel like being a follower of the team for just a few seasons doesnt qualify me to make an all time team so I'll go with what I know and do one for the departed Brampton Battalion.
I'll just list the top 12 forwards, ignore whether they are actual wingers or centres.

Wolski - Duchene - Hodgson
Torres - Spezza - McClement
Burns - Oulahen - Aquino
Lynes - Henrich - Goodrow

Klesla - Sanguinetti
Vernace - Clark
Harrison - Maleyko

Pitton
Killeen

Couple notes
1: you'll notice I have Brent Burns as a forward, thats what he played in junior so thats where I am putting him
2: McCollum is easily the best goalie Brampton ever had but I didn't want to put in rent-a-players for a run. If I had he would be number 1.

Honourable Mentions (1 per postion)
F: Bateman
D: Oreskovic
G: Machesney

 

[OSMike]

I've only been a fan since 2006-2007 season so I will start my all time team there.

I used there listed roster positions as well. Except for Smith listed as a center but a L shot put him on the left wing. Tried to pick non-rentals, guys who played 2 or more seasons with OS.

G. Wilson - Hishon - B Ryan
Mignardi - Platzer - Palmu
G. Smith - Catenacci - Nastasiuk
Halmo - Shaw - C. Brace

I could have put the Gadjovich - Hancock - Palmu line

Bigras - Centorame
Sharipzyanov - Schemitsch pick 1
Cutting - Petgrave/Blacker

Binnington
McNiven
Stajcer

 

[tjziel]

All-Time Hunter Era London Knights team

Rick Nash - John Tavares - Corey Perry
Robbie Schremp - Dave Bolland - Patrick Kane
Max Domi - Christian Dvorak - Mitch Marner
Dylan Hunter - Nazem Kadri - Sergei Kostitsyn
Sam Gagner

John Carlson - Marc Methot
Olli Maatta - Dennis Wideman
Scott Harrington - Jared Tinordi
Daniel Girardi

Steve Mason
Adam Dennis
Michael Houser

 

[OSAttackFan88]

Here is mine for Owen Sound!

Brad Richardson - Joey Hishon- Bobby Ryan
Josh Bailey- Garrett Wilson- Wayne Simmonds
Andrew Brunette- Kirk Maltby- Wayne Primeau
Adam Mair- Robby Mignardy- Stefan Ruzicka

Mark Giordano- Andrej Sekera
Bobby Sanguinetti- Jesse Blacker
Theo Peckham- Cody Ceci

Curtis Sanford
Jamie Storr
Michael McNiven

Spare forwards if allowed would be Sean Avery and Robin Bigsnake lol

 

[Jack Attack]

Here is mine for Owen Sound!

Brad Richardson - Joey Hishon- Bobby Ryan
Josh Bailey- Garrett Wilson- Wayne Simmonds
Andrew Brunette- Kirk Maltby- Wayne Primeau
Adam Mair- Robby Mignardy- Stefan Ruzicka

Mark Giordano- Andrej Sekera
Bobby Sanguinetti- Jesse Blacker
Theo Peckham- Cody Ceci

Curtis Sanford
Jamie Storr
Michael McNiven

Spare forwards if allowed would be Sean Avery and Robin Bigsnake lol

My All-time Owen Sound Plater/Attack Team

Andrew Brunette - Kirk Maltby - Wayne Primeau
Brad Richardson - Joey Hishon - Bobby Ryan
Adam Mair - Dan Snyder - Wes Goldie
Garrett Wilson - Robby Mignardi - Stefan Ruzicka
Zach Nastasiuk

Mark Giordano - Andrej Sekera
Chris Bigras - Jesse Blacker
Bobby Sanguinetti - Scott Walker
Santino Centorame

Jordan Binnington
Michael McNiven
Curtis Sanford

 

[TheCoach]

You missed 4 complete decades.

I'll sit down and compile my own....50 years worth

Forward (slot em anywhere you wish)

Corey Perry
Brian Bradley
Dennis Maruk
Dennis Ververgardt
Dino Ciccarelli
Rick Nash
Dave Bolland
Robbie Schremp
Max Domi
Jason Allison
Gary Unger
Darryl Sittler
Christian Dvorak(honorable mention)

Defense

Rick Green
Rob Ramage
Rick Corriveau
Marc Methot
Brad Marsh
Dennis Wideman
Danny Syvret
Olli Maatta(honorable mention)

Goal

Pat Riggin
Steve Mason
Michael Houser

Bash line: Louie DeBrusk/Sean McMorrow/Zac Rinaldo

Coach: Bill Long


Could quite easily make 2 or 3 all-time teams.

I would have Bo Horvat some were, other wise very solid

 

[WillardJFredricks]

My Petes team, from roughly 1988-present.

Forwards:
Dave Roche-Mike Harding-Jason Dawe
Cameron Mann-Mike Ricci-Jamie Langenbrunner
Daniel Ryder-Eric Staal-Cory Stillman
Mike Williams-Scott Barney-Rob Giffin
Matt Johnson


Defence:
Chris Pronger-Brent Tully
Kevin Bolibruck-Mike Martone
Jassen Cullimore-Geordie Kinnear
Mark Flood

Goalies:
Zac Bierk
Todd Bojcun

So tough to choose two goalies out of Bierk, Bojcun, Andrew Verner and Joey MacDonald.

 

[Petes1987]

My all time Petes team is from 1986 until present.

Forward:

Centre: Mike Ricci
Mark Freer
Mike Harding
Eric Staal

RW: Jason Dawe
Jamie Langenbrunner
Jody Hull
Cameron Mann

Extras: Jordan Staal
Jamie Tardif

LW: Dave Duerden
Kris King
Ross Wilson
Dave Roche

Defence: Brent Tully
Chris Pronger
Zac Bogosian
Bryan Young
Kevin Bolibruck
Lukas Krajicek

Extra: Dallas Eakins

Goal:. Zac Bierk
Todd Bojcun

 

[Fischhaber]

I'll give the Greyhounds a shot, but it will be the toughest list yet. I tried to balance the list between junior and pro success, as the Hounds have several of the top players in both NHL and OHL history.

Wayne Gretzky
Wayne Groulx
Ron Francis
John Goodwin
Jeff Carter
Jack Valiquette
Joe Thornton
Ralph Intranuovo
Rick Tocchet
Charlie Simmer
Bob Probert
Mike Kaszycki

Paul Coffey
Adam Foote
Craig Hartsburg
Jeff Beukeboom
Trevor Daley
Ryan Sproul

Tony Esposito
John Vanbiesbrouck

Coach: Ted Nolan

I left off several guys with 10+ years of NHL experience and a bunch of 2 time Mem cup champions. Steve Sullivan was particularly tough with 290 career goals. Deciding between Nurse, Sproul, Godfrey, Muzzin, and Daley for the last 2 defense spots was a total tossup as well. I'd love to see some input from an older Hounds fan.

 

[PhlyerPhanatic31]

I would have Bo Horvat some were, other wise very solid

I'd update the tenders and throw Parsons on as an honorable mention

 

[Fischhaber]

Anyone watch the NHL top 100? Surely many of those players will show up on the all-time teams. My Greyhounds had 4 players, but Joe Thornton was shockingly not among them. I would have expected him to be a shoe-in.

How many did other teams have?

 

[Flamer12]

I'll give Oshawa a try:

Ted Lindsay Eric Lindros Alex Delvecchio
John MacLean John Tavares Dave Andreychuk
Joe Cirella Marc Savard Rick Middleton
Tony Tanti Jason Arnott Terry O'Reilly
Wayne Cashman or Rob Pearson

Bobby Orr Charlie Huddy
Michael Del Zotto Calvin De Haan
Gord Murphy Dale DeGray
Bryan Allen

Kirk MacLean
Jeff Hac

Joe Cirella was a defenseman so in his forward spot you would have to put Mitch Lameroux for sure.