The landscape of the league was pretty different in Ballard's time though.. Not saying it wasnt horrible in an epic way, but I have to wonder just how many leaf fans here were actually suffering through his reign back in the 70's and 80's..
I mean Im 32, and I wasnt even born until 85, so clearly I have no idea what Ballard was like or how hard the years were under him. How old are you guys?
I'm 43.
If you want a comparable to this Karlsson situation, we had Sittler and MacDonald. A stud 1d and 1c...I'm sure you've heard of them. They were really close friends and loved playing in Toronto;
The 1980s
If you think it's dark now, just imagine a decade without a winning season. That was the 1980s for the Maple Leafs.
Trading Lanny McDonald to get at Darryl Sittler
As if feuding with one beloved Leafs captain wasn't enough, Ballard was back at it with Keon's successor, Darryl Sittler.
Technically, it was Punch Imlach who made a real mess of the situation, but one of the reasons Ballard hired the former-GM back was that he was vehemently anti-union, and Sittler, among others, were getting a little too ingrained in the NHLPA for Ballard's liking.
The first shot fired was by Imlach, who tried to block both Sittler and goaltender Mike Palmateer from appearing on
Showdown, a program that ran during intermissions on CBC. That stunt began a big feud with Sittler and other prominent players on the Leafs.
It got to the point that Imlach was willing to trade Sittler, the Maple Leafs' best player, anywhere in the league. Unfortunately for him (and fortunately for Toronto fans), Sittler's agent, Allen Eagleson, negotiated a no-trade clause into Sittler's contract and said that it would only be waived for $500,000. Unfortunately for Leafs fans, Lanny McDonald did not have a no-trade clause, and since he was one of Sittler's best friends on the team, Imlach decided to ship him out instead.
Another future Hall of Famer gone.
Well, that pissed off some people, to say the least. Sittler ripped off his captain's "C" in the dressing room, declaring that he couldn't be captain as he no longer could be a go-between the players and management.
By next season, with Imlach in the hospital after suffering his second heart attack, Ballard and Sittler made up publicly, and the "C" was back where it belonged. However, the détente wouldn't last, and the relationship between the two men became so strained that Sittlerwould waive his no-trade clause without receiving compensation.
The Leafs traded Sittler to the Philadelphia Flyers for Rich Costello, a second-round pick, and future considerations, a package that amounted to almost nothing.
A History of Harold Ballard's Villainy | Five Minutes For Fighting
That should help explain the 50 year drought as 30 of those years was spent under the umbrella of Ballard's shitty rein.