Would you make this trade?

[crackdown44]

Keeper league (two players)

Matthews + Morrissey + Saros + 1st

For

Aho + Hedman + Rittich + 16th

Rantanen and Eichel would be my keepers in this scenario, I don’t have a starting goalie. I’ve been cycling backups

Click to read more...

 

[td_ice]

I wouldn't.


There are always better options that will come up imo for less investment. Whether it's 2nd half surprise, like Binnington last season, or more trading options as the season progresses and teams fall out of it.

 

[TropicalFruitGirl2]

Not sure if you would be the one receiving the second group or trading them away, but seems to me the Aho-Hedman-Rittich side is getting the better of it.
Only saving grace for the first group is the 1st rounder...however, that means you are basically giving up on the season.

Surely, Matthews is a good producer for fantasy, but Aho can just as easily match him, and Hedder > Morrissey and Rittich > Saros.
Also, would be based on categories, so without knowing that, tough to make an accurate post on which side is better, but on the surface, all signs point to the second group being better, setting aside the draft pick.

If you are the one receiving that second group, great.
If you are the one trading AWAY that second group, I'd say DON'T do it.