Pokey Reddick might be the alltime worst Oilers goalie although several already mentioned are honorable mention. Pokey, it should be mentioned, played on a good team, and only when Fuhr, and Ranford weren't getting the starts and he usually only got starts against teams that were considered a joke yet his GAA was something like .830 and he was comically bad. To the point people joked he would be better without skates on, or conceivably, in any other sport.
The odd thing is Pokey is somewhat revered by Jets fans who liked him, and by Junior hockey fans, who liked him. He was horrible as an Oiler. He spent most of his time here, in Cape Breton.