Discussion in 'NHL Draft - Prospects' started by The Kingslayer, Jun 23, 2007.
I'll say the Hawks are winners.
Hawks are always winners. I don't know if they even have a scouting staff, or they just grab guys off the NHL CS listings.
Winners: (Ironically these are my 3 favorite teams) Avalanche, Hawks and Penguins
Losers: Edmonton and MontrÃ©al.
I think Montreal is also a winner...they now have a great depht on every position...
Detroit got Brendan Smith, Zack Torquato and Joakim Andersson, all guys who various sources had as, at the most, late 1st rounders.
They just keep doing it and doing it.
Pittsburgh, Chicago and the Rags are up here as well.
Meh, I wouldn't say winners... we did well, but not THAT well.
Well, you have to choose between winner and loser...
I like St-Louis pick. I'm really high on both Eller and Cole. Perron is a bit of a gamble. Hjalmarsson at 39 is somewhat a steal IMO.
Winner: Chicago hands down.
Patrick Kane, Maxim Mayorov, Akim Aliu, Bill Sweatt, Maxime Tanguay
He's a Blue Jacket.
The Jackets got Mayorov.
I think they did well for themselves getting Voracek (many feel is a top 4 talent), Mayorov, and Legein. They also got a project defensemen Weber and high energy wing Hansen.
Not the best draft, but above average.
I would say the Hawks did the best.
Winners - CLB, Voracek/Mayorov
CHI, all picks in the first 3 rounds were solid.
Losers - MTL, two picks in the top 22 (subpar picks)
LA, Hickey at 4??, good second round pick in Moller though
Colorado: Shattenkirk, Cann, Cohen
lol at this worthless win/lose process in the same day as the draft. Could we at LEAST wait for the end of the training camps.(Or the normal 4 years process...)
don't like it, go away! simple as that!
We really can't say until a couple of years from now....
Maybe some of these teams really saw something in some of their picks, most of us haven't even seen most these kids play!
Colorado, San Jose, Chicago.
You are a wise man.
And another one with common sense.
The draft isn't a contest to draft the most players that people have been talking about.
"OMG you got 4 flashy forwards that are highed high!!! You winzzz!!!!!!!!!11"
Winners and losers are based on armchair scouts mock drafts, just search old thread and you will see that past winners are actually losers
Oh well I guess now they are habs McDonagh and Pacioretty are garbage. Same with Suban and Fortier etc.
Yep St.Lou did awesome in that draft!
Dean Lombardi got the guy he wanted. Looking at his OVERALL draft he had a good draft. I am happy with it. Cant call him a loser!
Well he went off the board. Hfers thought he was a 20th pick at best they pick him 16 spots higer then he should and they didnt pick players they were high on so he's a loser.
If he turns out being a great PP specialist they'll say Lombardi is a god if not they'll say he should get fired. It's always been like that and it wont change anytime soon.
Montreal wasn't a loser. They got the players they wanted - that means they won, simple enough. Any team that picked everyone they wanted won on this day. That may change in four-five years, though.
Separate names with a comma.