This is the thing. It's a league of 31 teams. People seem to think if you're not #1, you have to be at the bottom in order to get there. I disagree.
Personally, I'd be much happier if the Oilers were able to field a competitive team every year without having to maintain a top 10 pick to do it. I would not at all be disappointed in making the post season every year and having a chance at the cup and being knocked out than making the post season once in 12 years. There is plenty of superstar talent drafted in the late first round and beyond every year. People seem to think you have to draft a Crosby, Ovechkin, McDavid or Matthews to put you over the top but I think you'd be delusional to hinge your franchise on the hopes that the next 18 year old kid drafted 1st overall is going to be a Hall of Fame legend.
Well see who's to say you will automatically stay bad if you do a rebuild? And you're making a strawman. Who said anything about those names that you pulled up? Why didn't you bring up Kopitar or Toews? It's not about individual players, it's about the direction of the team. What is the team trying to do?
Staying mediocre for years and relying on hope has a shelf life. Yes it's better to make the playoffs consistently, but again, that has a shelf life if you don't win a cup. And let's make this distinction, we're not talking about a great regular season team here, who gets past the first round consistently. Then it would be stupid to think about a rebuild.
And I'm not saying Philly should rebuild now, but, if they get to a point where there is a chance to clean house a bit, and start a rebuild, they should give it great consideration. And not try to avoid it at all costs.
How long do you go before you say, maybe I should try something different? Especially when you look and see different teams around you go on and when cups in that time span, and they didn't choose your way of team building?
And OT: Matthews doesn't belong with those other three. Even if McDavid hasn't won a cup, I think it's about individual talent here, and Matthews doesn't belong with those other three.