who would you rather have

[Jackets16]

jeff carter
thomas vanek
joffrey lupul
ryan getzlaf
corey perry
rostislav olesz
zach parise

Click to read more...

 

[NashisCash]

Vanek
Carter
Getzlaf
Lupul
Perry
Olesz
Parise

All will be very good players though.

 

[badrobot101]

Jeff Carter - he's got fantastic skills, and much as I hate Bob Clarke I think his organization does a great job drafting and developing their young punks. Look for the Flyers to hoist several cups circa 2009.

Now excuse me while I throw up.

 

[NashisCash]

Carter is a good player, and once he puts on some weight he will be a beast. I think the Flyers will definitely have to play him with a playmaker in the future, it's really too bad because Justin Williams would have been the perfect player to dig pucks out of the corner and get them to Carter. He has one of the quickest releases maybe in the league, and he gets his shot off with a lot of power. While I think Carter will be a first line centre, I think his progression will be a lot similar to Patrick Marleau, or his numbers will be similar at the early parts of their careers, good goalscoring totals but not the assists you would expect out of a 1st line centre. I'm not sure Carter has the playmaking or puck skills to be the best of this bunch, but I think he can be a Sundin-type player with a bit worse playmaking skills when he beefs up.

 

[boredmale]

Vanek - harder to find good wingers then good centers

beyond that Carter then parise

 

[gars59]

venek

 

[shealy04]

jeff carter
thomas vanek
joffrey lupul
ryan getzlaf
corey perry
rostislav olesz
zach parise

I'm probably going to have to go with Carter, he is going to be a beast...

But Vanek probably has the highest ceiling...
I can see him being a 50+ goal scorer in the future...