Who would you rather have, prospect/rookies/sophomores edition:

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ajacied

Stay strong Appie! ❤
Apr 6, 2002
25,134
910
Netherlands
Most of you've seen these kind of threads on the NHL board, but I thought it would be fun using strictly prospects, rookies and sophomores. I made a list of who I feel are quite simular in style and potential, though some are not much a like at all and are just being lined up to see who y'all like better. Unlike previous editions, I'd like to ask you to look past your team's needs and just pick the one you feel is better by making that name bold.

Here they come:

Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schrempf

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl

Be free to eloborate on some (or all), or be even free to add some more if you like..
 

BrettNYR

Registered User
Mar 26, 2004
2,567
0
Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schrempf

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl
 

Ajacied

Stay strong Appie! ❤
Apr 6, 2002
25,134
910
Netherlands
Forgot to add me own:

Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schrempf

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl
 

H3ro

Registered User
Apr 24, 2003
535
1
Visit site
Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schrempf
There has been too much hyped about AK before last year draft(Including best skilled player of the 2003 draftees, over Zherdev, Staal and others)to overlook this prospect. I'm hoping a lot from this Andre Savard's pick.
Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej
Jozef Balej is my favorite prospect. I was pissed when I heard Habs traded him to the Rangers, but I was also excited about Kovalev. Since Kovalev days are maybe over with Montreal, I'm sad to see this scoring, speedy winger somewhere else. No disrespect to Marek Svatos here, he had great series, but Balej will become a fantastic player in the NHL. He will impress A LOT next year
Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf
No comparaison here, Grebeshkov's style is miles away from Phaneuf's one. Most agree that Phaneuf is in the top 3 prospects.
Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl
 

montreal

Go Habs Go
Mar 21, 2002
57,253
39,631
www.youtube.com
Andrei Kasistyin

Joseph Balej

Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov

Derek Roy

Ales Hemsky

Jason Chimera

Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov

Jussi Jokinen

Matt Nickerson

Lukas Kraijcek

Mike Komarisek

Alexander Steen

Christian Berglund
 

#2

Registered User
May 1, 2003
1,285
0
Visit site
Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schremp

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl
 

User571

Registered User
Apr 5, 2004
924
0
Between the Pipes
Modano = Dud said:
Most of you've seen these kind of threads on the NHL board, but I thought it would be fun using strictly prospects, rookies and sophomores. I made a list of who I feel are quite simular in style and potential, though some are not much a like at all and are just being lined up to see who y'all like better. Unlike previous editions, I'd like to ask you to look past your team's needs and just pick the one you feel is better by making that name bold.

Here they come:

Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schrempf

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl

Be free to eloborate on some (or all), or be even free to add some more if you like..
Robbie Schremp
Marek Svatos
Dion Phaneuf
Filip Novak
Derek Roy
Stan Chistov
Jani Rita
Scottie Upshall
Ilya Bryzgalov
Antti Miettinen
Mike Egener
Ron Hainsey
Carlo Colaiacovo
Loui Eriksson
Pavol Brendl

Philippe Sauve or Michael Leighton?
 

Ajacied

Stay strong Appie! ❤
Apr 6, 2002
25,134
910
Netherlands
nurminen31 said:
Philippe Sauve or Michael Leighton?

Good one.. I too pick Leighton.

Here's another one, the last two Hobey Baker winners:

Junior Lessard or Petr Sejna?

Also, I'd be curious to see some of you guys eloboration on picking Jokinen above Miettinen, I kinda thought that was one of my obvious matchups. Guess not..
 

Seachd

Registered User
Mar 16, 2002
24,935
8,938
Man, some of these are tough. Good work!

My opinions:

Andrei Kastsitsyn or Robbie Schremp

Marek Svatos or Jozef Balej

Denis Grebeshkov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirill Koltsov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scottie Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Krajicek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komisarek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavel Brendl
 

Burke's Evil Spirit

Registered User
Oct 29, 2002
21,369
7,326
San Francisco
Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schremp

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Krajicek or Ron Hainsey <-- The biggest margin between players in this poll, IMO. Krajicek is awesome.

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl <--- I'd rather slit my wrists.
 

eSabre

Registered User
Dec 14, 2002
6,460
0
Nashville, TN
3rdmanin.wordpress.com
Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schremp

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kiril Koltsov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavel Brendl
 

Prucha73

Guest
I can't believe so many people think Svatos is better than Balej.
 

Cayouche5

Registered User
Mar 9, 2003
1,771
7
Visit site
Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schrempf

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl

Chris Higgins or Alexander Steen ?? ( Long Battle vs Leaf and Habs Fan )

Kelly Gard or Yann Danis ?? ( Best goalie in College vs Best in CHL )

Martin Vagner or 2004 2nd round pick ?
 

thestonedkoala

Guest
Here they come:

Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schremp (I can't believe how many people are gullible in thinking that Schremp has problems and that he'll drop off so far. Same thing with O'Sullivan? PLEASE! His problems were overblown and you guys are overblowing Schremp's problems)

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl
 

IFK

Registered User
Jul 25, 2003
1,321
2
Visit site
Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schrempf

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl
 

Naoned

Registered User
Andrei Kastsitsyn or Robbie Schremp

Marek Svatos or Jozef Balej

Denis Grebeshkov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirill Koltsov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scottie Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Krajicek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komisarek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavel Brendl
 

montreal

Go Habs Go
Mar 21, 2002
57,253
39,631
www.youtube.com
Prucha73 said:
I can't believe so many people think Svatos is better than Balej.


I like both, but I can see why people go with Svatos who looked good in the playoffs. Balej is on fire in the AHL playoffs, with almost triple the amount of goals then anyone else on his team.
 

Big McLargehuge

Fragile Traveler
May 9, 2002
72,188
7,740
S. Pasadena, CA
Robbie Schrempf
Marek Svatos
Dion Phaneuf
Filip Novak
Steve Ott
Ales Hemsky
Jason Chimera
Scotty Upshall
Jason Bacashihua
Antti Miettinen
Don't know enough about either
Lukas Kraijcek
Mike Komarisek
Alexander Steen
Pavel Brendl
 

leafaholix*

Guest
Andrei Kastsitsyn or Robbie Schremp
Marek Svatos or Josef Balej
Denis Grebeshkov or Dion Phaneuf
Kirill Kolstov or Filip Novak
Steve Ott or Derek Roy
Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky
Jani Rita or Jason Chimera
Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier
Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua
Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen
Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener
Lukas Krajicek or Ron Hainsey
Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo
Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson
Christian Berglund or Pavel Brendl
 

Takkie

I Goc ya nose!
Jun 29, 2003
1,105
0
Florida
Visit site
Andrei Kastsitsyn or Robbie Schremp
Marek Svatos or Josef Balej
Denis Grebeshkov or Dion Phaneuf
Kirill Kolstov or Filip Novak
Steve Ott or Derek Roy
Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky
Jani Rita or Jason Chimera
Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier
Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua
Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen
Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener
Lukas Krajicek or Ron Hainsey
Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo
Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson
Christian Berglund or Pavel Brendl
 

Epsilon

#basta
Oct 26, 2002
48,464
369
South Cackalacky
Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schrempf

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavel Brendl
 

Bettman Returnz

Why so serious?
Jul 28, 2003
4,788
2,675
BC
Visit site
Andrei Kasistyin or Robbie Schrempf

Marek Svatos or Joseph Balej

Denis Grebeshov or Dion Phaneuf

Kirril Kolstov or Filip Novak

Steve Ott or Derek Roy

Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky

Jani Rita or Jason Chimera

Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier

Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua

Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen

Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener

Lukas Kraijcek or Ron Hainsey

Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo

Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson

Christian Berglund or Pavol Brendl
 

DJ Spinoza

Registered User
Aug 7, 2003
25,100
3,647
Andrei Kastsitsyn or Robbie Schremp
Marek Svatos or Josef Balej
Denis Grebeshkov or Dion Phaneuf
Kirill Kolstov or Filip Novak
Steve Ott or Derek Roy
Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky
Jani Rita or Jason Chimera
Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier
Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua
Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen
Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener - Not familiar with either at all.
Lukas Krajicek or Ron Hainsey
Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo
Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson
Christian Berglund or Pavel Brendl
 

Jeffrey

Registered User
Feb 2, 2003
12,436
3
Montreal
Visit site
Andrei Kastsitsyn or Robbie Schremp
Marek Svatos or Josef Balej
Denis Grebeshkov or Dion Phaneuf
Kirill Kolstov or Filip Novak ¸
Steve Ott or Derek Roy
Stanislav Chistov or Ales Hemsky
Jani Rita or Jason Chimera
Scotty Upshall or Steve Bernier
Ilya Bryzgalov or Jason Bacashihua
Jussi Jokinen or Antti Miettinen
Matt Nickerson or Mike Egener
Lukas Krajicek or Ron Hainsey
Mike Komarisek or Carlo Colaiacovo
Alexander Steen or Loui Eriksson
Christian Berglund or Pavel Brendl
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->