Who would win?

[Shady Machine]

To be fair, we should only consider how good these players were in their tenure on the Pens vs the prime of their careers. I wouldn't put Iginla on the Pens all time roster.

 

[Don'tcry4mejanhrdina]

To be fair, we should only consider how good these players were in their tenure on the Pens vs the prime of their careers. I wouldn't put Iginla on the Pens all time roster.

Me neither. It's not like there's a shortage of talented Penguins players who played here in their prime anyway.

Would Dave Burrows make the all-time team? He was before my time but from everything I've read he was a very good defensive defenseman. Anybody here who watched the Pens in the 70's?