Who would win Roy or Emery?

[Hero]

If only they played in the same era, against rival teams.

Click to read more...

 

[Iwishihadacup]

I stand by the apocaliptic theory

 

[sabresfan129103]

doesn't emery have a background in boxing? in any event ray whoops his ass. i think a better poll would be emery vs hextall.

 

[justPlay]

Went with Emery.

 

[Bramskii]

Emery

 

[Giroux tha Damaja]

Emery, handily.
Roy got his ass kicked by Vernon and barely beat Osgood. Emery

 

[Opus]

Razor.

I honestly don't think it would close.

 

[Bring Bak Damphousse]

Emery, handily.
Roy got his ass kicked by Vernon and barely beat Osgood. Emery

What? yes they may have gotten the takedowns but Roy won both fights. That being said Emery would destroy Roy.

 

[Giroux tha Damaja]

What? yes they may have gotten the takedowns but Roy won both fights. That being said Emery would destroy Roy.

The video shown wasn't the only time Vernon fought Roy. The other time Vernon split his face open in two places and Roy skated to his bench bloodied up. Osgood is also a much smaller dude, and he more than held his own. But we agree Emery would "give him the business".

 

[danishh]

I'll take emery, mainly because i expect if this were to happen they would both be equally pissed off at each other and emery's boxing training would keep him ahead.

 

[pelts35.com]

i think a better poll would be emery vs hextall.

Completely agree. That would be one heck of a fight.

 

[Mr Bru]

definetley would side with emery in any goalie fight throughout the history of the nhl

 

[NJDEVILS17*]

definetley would side with emery in any goalie fight throughout the history of the nhl

You'd take Emery over a prime Ron Hextall, Billy Smith, Dan Cloutier, Garth Snow and Sean Burke?

 

[Bring Bak Damphousse]

The video shown wasn't the only time Vernon fought Roy. The other time Vernon split his face open in two places and Roy skated to his bench bloodied up. Osgood is also a much smaller dude, and he more than held his own. But we agree Emery would "give him the business".

Your right...my bad. Now that you mention it I remember Roy being badly bloodied in a fight.

 

[kicksave27]

Emery, and it'd be a quick one.

 

[DeadPhish5858]

Went with Emery because of his background in boxing. However Roy did have more experience fighting on the ice.

 

[Don Nachbaur 26]

Emery and it's not even close..

 

[playoffhero]

Emery

and "don't mess with the French" is the craziest thing I've ever read.

 

[John Flyers Fan]

I think Emery vs. Burke would be the best possible match-up.

 

[Brassard Calder]

Emery would destroy Roy. Wouldn't even be close.