Who is currently the better defenseman? Weber or Subban?

[895]

Title

Click to read more...

 

[Kunta Kinte]

Subban.


Weber can't play anymore.

 

[MMC]

Subban.


Weber can't play anymore.

Is this a joke? Subban has been awful this season

 

[bigbabybuda]

Subban has been worse so far this year but NJ has been the worst team in the league so far. I expect that to change once their young guns and new players start to get. They're have mi ore talent then lots of teams. Subban has been much better since the trade happened and will again be better than Weber soon enough.

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

Subban has been worse so far this year but NJ has been the worst team in the league so far. I expect that to change once their young guns and new players start to get. They're have mi ore talent then lots of teams. Subban has been much better since the trade happened and will again be better than Weber soon enough.

Ya no, Weber's been better than subban in 2 of the 3 seasons.
The only year Subban was better was when Weber only played 26 games in a season.

 

[Taluss]

I haven't watched weber this year so I'm going off of him last year and saying g him

 

[Mike Hasselhoffman]

I’m gonna say Weber but it’s definitely close. A bounce back season from Subban can certainly shift the balance back to him

 

[bigbabybuda]

Ya no, Weber's been better than subban in 2 of the 3 seasons.
The only year Subban was better was when Weber only played 26 games in a season.

No he really hasn't and yes you lost that trade. You have made the playoffs once since the trade was made. Nashville made it to the finals with Subban and never missed the playoffs. How many times did Montreal miss the playoffs with Subban on their team. Take out his first 2 seasons because he wasnt expected to be a big contributor. Subban statistics are significantly better than Webbers since the trade in 2 of the 3 years. Montreal has been worse since the trade and Nashville was better. Subban is 4 years younger than Weber as well. There is no measurable barometer in which Weber has been better since the trade or that Montreal improved except a bunch of nonsense from haters and dinosaurs about Subban being a bad teammate. The vast, vast majority of his teammates love the guy. A fee dont but he is charismatic and good looking and boring, insecure people tend to not like Alphas. No one is liked by everyone. Yes, Nashville has moved on from Subban but the pieces they got for Subban are worth more than Weber at this point in his career. Nashville is deep in the back end and needed cap space to improve in the middle. So they made a trade for not a great return but still made the team much better overall. Weber is a netnegative now on his team at that salary and the reason he wont be moved is because most people understand he is going to decline fast now and you would need to pay to have him taken off your books.

Reason I bring this all up is I think this trade was made by another Canadians fan trying to justify that trade. The trade was bad then and it remains bad today. It will get worse and worse lol. Theres nothing to back up it was good then or will end up being good. Later!

I won't reply to anymore quotes. The deal has been talked to death and their is really nothing to debate.

 

[Kunta Kinte]

How many of you have seen Weber play this season ?

He isn't any better than Ben Chariot or Brett Kulak at this point.

 

[koyvoo]

How many of you have seen Weber play this season ?

He isn't any better than Ben Chariot or Brett Kulak at this point.

Have you seen Subban play this year? No player has fallen off a cliff so far in the past 12-18 months as much as he has.

 

[Nemesis Prime]

No he really hasn't and yes you lost that trade. You have made the playoffs once since the trade was made. Nashville made it to the finals with Subban and never missed the playoffs. How many times did Montreal miss the playoffs with Subban on their team. Take out his first 2 seasons because he wasnt expected to be a big contributor. Subban statistics are significantly better than Webbers since the trade in 2 of the 3 years. Montreal has been worse since the trade and Nashville was better. Subban is 4 years younger than Weber as well. There is no measurable barometer in which Weber has been better since the trade or that Montreal improved except a bunch of nonsense from haters and dinosaurs about Subban being a bad teammate. The vast, vast majority of his teammates love the guy. A fee dont but he is charismatic and good looking and boring, insecure people tend to not like Alphas. No one is liked by everyone. Yes, Nashville has moved on from Subban but the pieces they got for Subban are worth more than Weber at this point in his career. Nashville is deep in the back end and needed cap space to improve in the middle. So they made a trade for not a great return but still made the team much better overall. Weber is a netnegative now on his team at that salary and the reason he wont be moved is because most people understand he is going to decline fast now and you would need to pay to have him taken off your books.

Reason I bring this all up is I think this trade was made by another Canadians fan trying to justify that trade. The trade was bad then and it remains bad today. It will get worse and worse lol. Theres nothing to back up it was good then or will end up being good. Later!

I won't reply to anymore quotes. The deal has been talked to death and their is really nothing to debate.

Weber > Subban AINEC.

 

[XXIV97]

No he really hasn't and yes you lost that trade. You have made the playoffs once since the trade was made. Nashville made it to the finals with Subban and never missed the playoffs. How many times did Montreal miss the playoffs with Subban on their team. Take out his first 2 seasons because he wasnt expected to be a big contributor. Subban statistics are significantly better than Webbers since the trade in 2 of the 3 years. Montreal has been worse since the trade and Nashville was better. Subban is 4 years younger than Weber as well. There is no measurable barometer in which Weber has been better since the trade or that Montreal improved except a bunch of nonsense from haters and dinosaurs about Subban being a bad teammate. The vast, vast majority of his teammates love the guy. A fee dont but he is charismatic and good looking and boring, insecure people tend to not like Alphas. No one is liked by everyone. Yes, Nashville has moved on from Subban but the pieces they got for Subban are worth more than Weber at this point in his career. Nashville is deep in the back end and needed cap space to improve in the middle. So they made a trade for not a great return but still made the team much better overall. Weber is a netnegative now on his team at that salary and the reason he wont be moved is because most people understand he is going to decline fast now and you would need to pay to have him taken off your books.

Reason I bring this all up is I think this trade was made by another Canadians fan trying to justify that trade. The trade was bad then and it remains bad today. It will get worse and worse lol. Theres nothing to back up it was good then or will end up being good. Later!

I won't reply to anymore quotes. The deal has been talked to death and their is really nothing to debate.

Weber is a better player than Subban. Both players do not have a good contract.

Nashville still won the trade due to cap space

 

[Green Snow Storm]

Weber. this is coming from a Leafs fan.

Accidentally voted Subban. Opps.

 

[The Crypto Guy]

Subban.


Weber can't play anymore.

This a joke? Subban looks completely washed up

 

[CristianoRonaldo]

Every Habs fan will tell you that Weber is really bad this year.

I did not watch Subban, but I watched every Habs game.

 

[snipes]

This a joke? Subban looks completely washed up

Looks more concerned with being a celebrity with Lindsey than playing hockey.

Having said that, Subban will have a great post playing career in television. He’s a natural in front of a camera.

 

[ijuka]

At this moment, I think Shea Weber is better than Pernell-Karl Subban.

 

[Conspiracy Theorist]

Can't believe how much both have declined.

 

[Halla]

went with Subban because he can at least still hit the net

 

[Bounces R Way]

Can't believe how much both have declined.

Surely I can't be the only one not really that surprised?

Both were overrated to start with, there just wasn't that many great D in the league 5-6 years ago. Weber had already shown signs of a decline, not like he was going to get better at the time of the trade. PK is a player that relied entirely on his legs, which during his peak were definitely elite. Even losing half a step will make him look pretty average, and that's exactly what has happened.

 

[NJ DevLolz]

This a joke? Subban looks completely washed up

He dominated your boys last night

 

[ole ole]

Subban has been worse so far this year but NJ has been the worst team in the league so far. I expect that to change once their young guns and new players start to get. They're have mi ore talent then lots of teams. Subban has been much better since the trade happened and will again be better than Weber soon enough.

No since the trade Weber has been the better of the two.

 

[The Crypto Guy]

He dominated your boys last night

Probably the only time he will be able to keep up this season vs an NHL team when they've only played 1 game in the last week and a half. I guess you have to take the small victories this season for ya.

 

[DaPhazz]

How many of you have seen Weber play this season ?

He isn't any better than Ben Chariot or Brett Kulak at this point.

And Sbisa is better than Subban this season mate, what's the point?

 

[Nick Hansen]

Can't believe how much both have declined.

Weber is 34 in a young man's league where speed is very important. Not sure what is up with Subban, have a feeling he put on too much weight a few years ago cause his decline is a little weird. Perhaps the injuries have just taken their toll, the back is always a tricky place to get injured in.