It's kind of silly to say it, because of injuries and the whole bit...plus, how incredibly specific it is...but how about 2010 and 2011...
I mean, just all or mostly nonsense players...
Art Ross - Henrik Sedin (probably not a HOFer)
Calder - Tyler Myers
Smythe - Toews (is he on a HOF track, really?)
Hart - Henrik Sedin (a little silly considering his partner in crime, I know, he missed like 15 games or whatever, but that's enough for me to give Henrik Sedin a Hart)
Norris - Keith (now, this aged better than I thought...I didn't think we'd see Keith rise to stardom actually)
Vezina - Ryan Miller (it's like a Cam Ward Conn Smythe, just a rather irrelevant goalie who had a great year after all the good goalies retired or were out of their prime)
1st Team had: Ryan Miller, Mike Green, Henrik Sedin on it
2nd Team had: Ilya Bryzgalov and Daniel Sedin on it
Niclas Bergfors and Michael Del Zotto were on the all-rookie team (as irrelevant as that is)
Patrick Marleau with his lone top-5 goals finish in his career.
Fringe NHLer Jeff Schultz led the league in plus/minus.
Brodeur, even at 37 with a ton of miles on him led the league in GP, wins and shutouts...
Boston's cushy system allows a rookie goalie to lead the league in GAA (by a mile) and save pct.
Ty Conklin (Ty! Conklin!) finished 6th in save pct., Antti Niemi finished 4th (narrowly 2nd) in GAA
The Flyers made the playoffs via a shootout...and go to the Stanley Cup Final with a minor league goaltender and a third pairing that was unable to take the ice without getting dashed...and they lose in the most ridiculous fashion...
Not that this was terribly abnormal, but the powerhouse Caps lost to #8 Montreal, Montreal then eliminates the defending Cup champs only to lose their goalie and give way to Philadelphia easily in the Conference Final. The two shortest series of the playoffs were both Conference Final series...
I mean, that year was a joke haha
The next year, it doesn't get much better...
Now Daniel Sedin wins an Art Ross, Corey Perry (also not a HOFer you have to imagine) wins a Hart by being hot for the last 20 games, Lidstrom gets his career achievement Norris while being a minus for the first time in his life...
A minor league journeyman wins the Vezina...
I mean, look at the 1st team...some years it's a veritable who's who...this year it's a veritable "who's that?"
Tim Thomas, 80-year-old Nicklas Lidstrom, Shea Weber, Henrik Sedin, Daniel Sedin and Corey Perry. I guess the defense are going to the Hall, but the one guy that really, really deserves it doesn't deserve to be there with all due respect...
Second-Team picks up some of the slack: Rinne, Chara, Visnovsky, Stamkos, Ovechkin, St. Louis.
Ryan Kesler finishes 4th in goals, Henrik Zetterberg's 56 assists earn in a top-5 finish...
Not that plus/minus is reliability for the stars but: Kevin Bieksa, Toni Lydman, Matt Carle, Adam McQuaid and Andrej Meszaros just about took the crown...
Jonas Hiller was 4th in save pct. ...the guy who couldn't standup or play butterfly...? Come on...
I don't know, just a couple really weird seasons in terms of who was lauded with awards...the War years definitely take the cake in short order, but with all due respect, there's a lot of dreck here...