Oliver
"Babe" Seibert started his career with the
Montreal Maroons, joining
Hooley Smith & Nels' Stewart on what was then called the
'S' Line, one of hockeys most feared at that time. In his first year, the
Maroons won the
Stanley Cup in large part thanks to his own & linemates play, something they never achieved again. He was eventually traded to the
Rangers, then back to Montreal with the
Canadiens where he was
Captain.
Siebert retired after the 38-39 season and was then appointed
Coach of the
Habs, however, tragedy struck & that summer he drowned in a swimming accident. A benefit game was held to help his widow (& children), who earlier had suffered paralysis below the waist. Though
Siebert clearly wasnt of "
Superstar" caliber, he was extremely well respected & highly regarded in hockey circles, a natural leader, and thus the HHOF will, and certainly did then, induct members who were just plain solid people in addition to being better than average players, taken from the game early for one reason or another.
Reasons for some of the others being inducted can be found at
www.hhof.com following the links to the
Player Search section as your know doubt aware. Many of your "
Why are they inducted" picks I too dont particularly agree with, but Im easy either way about most.
Character is important, explaining some but not all of the questionable player selections. If we look at the
Builders category, plenty of
miscreants still listed beyond
Eagleson that give pause for thought.