Which current division would produce the winning all star team?

[Habano]

The question is pretty self explanatory. If each division created an all star team, who would win?

Click to read more...

 

[jonlin]

I take central stricly cause I love their D. The offense is just ok.

Stamkos - Point - Kucherov
Huberdeau - Barkov - Forsberg
Debrincat - Hintz - Kane
Svechnikov - Aho - Necas

Hedman - Ekblad
Josi - Heiskanen
Slavin - Hamilton

Vasilevsky
Saros

 

[tucker3434]

I'll go with the North. Nobody cares about defense in all star games. The North might put up 25 goals.

 

[The Podium]

I take the North, best O and G and pooling the D hides its deficiency

B. Tkachuk - McDavid - Boeser
Gaudreau - Draisaitl - Wheeler
M. Tkachuk - Matthews - Marner
Pettersson - Scheifele - Ehlers
HM: Connor, Tavares

Morrissey - Petry
Hughes - Weber
Nurse - Chabot
HM: Andersson, Rielly, Giordano

Hellebuyck
Price
Markstrom

 

[Spirit of 67]

It will be interesting to see morons justify it not being the North.

 

[Ace of Hades]

I take the North, best O and G and pooling the D hides its deficiency

B. Tkachuk - McDavid - Tavares
Gaudreau - Draisaitl - Wheeler
M. Tkachuk - Matthews - Marner
Connor - Scheifele - Ehlers

Morrissey - Petry
Hughes - Weber
Nurse - Chabot
Andersson, Rielly, Giordano

Hellebuyck
Price
Markstrom

Atleast one or two of Boeser, Pettersson or Miller make it on that team.
At the very least, Schmidt should be on a HM as well.
Demko makes it too over Markstrom and Price.

 

[Team Cozens]

I'll go with the North. Nobody cares about defense in all star games. The North might put up 25 goals.

This. lol

 

[a mangy Meowth]

Considering the all star game is mostly just the players hotdogging it at 60% speed and doing goofy shit because the defenders will let them, I imagine it would be a roll of the dice who wins - whoever pulls off their hotdoggery the most successfully.

 

[Big Empty]

McDavid, Draisaitl, Matthews, Marner, Tavares, Pettersson, Scheifele, Ehlers, Connor, the Tkachuk brothers, and Gaudreau.

The offense is way too stacked.

 

[bobholly39]

McDavid, Draisaitl, Matthews, Marner, Tavares, Pettersson, Scheifele, Ehlers, Connor, the Tkachuk brothers, and Gaudreau.

The offense is way too stacked.

You forgot the second best goal-scorer in the division - sporting a 0.59 goals per game pace - Tyler Toffoli

 

[The Podium]

Atleast one or two of Boeser, Pettersson or Miller make it on that team.
At the very least, Schmidt should be on a HM as well.
Demko makes it too over Markstrom and Price.

Honestly, was trying to do it quick and completely blanked on Vancouver's offence.

 

[McNuge]

Very clearly the worst division in the league /s

 

[Joe McGrath]

If they are trying and playing actual hockey? The central. If it’s just f*** around all-star garbage probably the team who tries the hardest. Whichever is the youngest team with the most 1st time all-stars.

 

[jonlin]

I thought this was like picking an "all-star" team for Stanley cup, not the all-star game? Who cares about an all-star game thats only show with no hits. Doesnt really matter who would win such a shitshow. If its all-star game, then why not ice only dangling forwards. Doesnt matter who the goalies or defensemen are then...

 

[wintersej]

If it’s an all star game my vote is different than if it’s a seven game series where players care about the result. For all star game? The North has a lot of skill. But that D would get exposed if the players were playing hockey.

 

[Crow]

All star games are pretty random.

 

[Gurglesons]

North quite easily. The bad teams are still stacked with elite talent.

 

[Captain97]

I take the North, best O and G and pooling the D hides its deficiency

B. Tkachuk - McDavid - Boeser
Gaudreau - Draisaitl - Wheeler
M. Tkachuk - Matthews - Marner
Pettersson - Scheifele - Ehlers
HM: Connor, Tavares

Morrissey - Petry
Hughes - Weber
Nurse - Chabot
HM: Andersson, Rielly, Giordano

Hellebuyck
Price
Markstrom

Take in your lineup is missing a top goal scorer in the NHL right now who plays for my favourite team and I can't even be upset about it, that forward group is nuts.