How do you have MacK and RNH in different tiers when they score at about the same rate. Id say both have been decent but underwhelming
I did deliberate a decent amount about those tier rankings. I wanted to have those four tiers, and the two players you mentioned were the trickiest to decide on...ultimately I feel MacKinnon still has room to grow which I factored in, and has shown more ability to be a game breaker. I actually quite like the Nuge as a player (and I'm a Canucks fan), but I think what we are seeing is what we're going to get. I could be wrong and MacKinnon could never trend up again, in which case I agree with you.
Interesting opinions on this so far, seems like no one is anticipating a star player (to be expected). What from I know of Hischier, assuming he is developed well (a lot to ask), I think he will be a very good player. Not in that superstar category, but a 75pt two way player. Maybe even a Kopitar type, if he could bulk up and play more physical.
Just as likely though he is a 50pt 2C his whole career.