Ugh... these guys are players, not commodities.
Newsflash: If your 'team' has the better of the two players in the end, it does not reflect on you personally in any way.
Try actually watching them play and enjoy their skill... it's silly to waste your time arguing over boxscores. If you had watched them this year, you'd know that they both are playing very well, and at the same time, have entirely different skill sets that make comparisons pointless.
They're both going to be good... one's going to be better. That will depend on so many intagibles (injuries, linemates, car accidents, personal lives, etc.) that one can only say at this time that either of the two could have the greater career.
If stats told the whole story, NHL teams wouldn't employ scouts.