Proposal: What would it take to get Mackinnon to Pittsburgh?

[Bond]

At this rate I would trade Monahan and Gaudreau for MacKinnon haha

 

[SuperSaiyanSTARS]

@bernmeister is this you!?

 

[Wingsfan 4 life]

I-70 will get him most of the way there. But, probably not the best time for Mack to go on a cross country roadtrip.

 

[Hasbro]

If you have to ask, you can’t afford it.

 

[PensRedwings2887]

What a stupid proposal. Give your head a shake for posting this embarrassing nonsense.

What a stupid comment. The OP didn't make any type of offer to where it was unfair for either side, all he/she asked is "what would it take to get MacKinnon to Pittsburgh?" No reason to come off like a jerk.

 

[Bone Breaker]

IF Mack wants out (for whatever reason) and the Pens is on his list of destinations, I'd accept Phil the Thrill + Guentzel + 4 1sts + Straka and Kasparaitis signed sticks.

 

[Kupo]

What a stupid comment. The OP didn't make any type of offer to where it was unfair for either side, all he/she asked is "what would it take to get MacKinnon to Pittsburgh?" No reason to come off like a jerk.

You honestly think the OP’s proposal is fair for Mackinnon...?

Malkin+1st is a ****ing abomination of a proposal. The difference between Malkin + MacKinnon is a lot more than the 23rd~ pick.

Mackinnon is 9 years his junior, and he out produced him for a lot less money. And you think the value isn’t lopsided?

Give your head a shake too.

 

[Kent Nilsson]

Honestly this thread is the trade board in a nutshell, dumbed down. A little.

 

[PensRedwings2887]

You honestly think the OP’s proposal is fair for Mackinnon...?

Malkin+1st is a ****ing abomination of a proposal. The difference between Malkin + MacKinnon is a lot more than the 23rd~ pick.

Mackinnon is 9 years his junior, and he out produced him for a lot less money. And you think the value isn’t lopsided?

Give your head a shake too.

I never said anything about any trade offer being fair pal, stop trying to put words in other people's mouths, stop jumping to conclusions. You make it sound like the OP and I are trying to rip the Avs off, meanwhile I personally hadn't listed any type of offer. All I did was state that you didn't need to jump down the OP's throat for asking a question. If you don't like the OP's offer, thats fine, but again, no need to be a jerk about it. You should be the one giving your head a shake.

 

[Stephen]

What would it take for Colorado to donate it's glorious future so Pittsburgh can have another 15 year run?

 

[Nac Mac Feegle]

Pretty damned arrogant for any Pens fan to even ask for another teams superstar. Like you guys haven't had enough dynasties already in your history.

 

[SnizzNasty88]

Jeeeez I think it’d take both Crosby and Malkin for MacKinnon + and even then if I’m the Avs I don’t do it, he’s the best player in the league considering his contract and term left.

 

[SnizzNasty88]

Nothing, absolutely nothing from Pittsburgh or pretty much any team gets Mack out of Colorado

Matthews and Kadri for MacKinnon

 

[Blake456]

Easy all it would take is a time machine! Malkin for Mackinnon when he was drafted. But can we stop and win me the lottery first. Then make the trade.

 

[780il]

The only asset in the NHL that Mackinnon would be traded for is Mcdavid.

And Edmonton wouldn't bat an eye unless they added Makar...


In other words, not happening.

 

[Hasbro]

The only asset in the NHL that Mackinnon would be traded for is Mcdavid.

And Edmonton wouldn't bat an eye unless they added Makar...


In other words, not happening.

I wouldn't take McDavid for MacKinnon straight up.

 

[Nico Hischier]

It's just something that wouldnt make sence for the pens and even less sence for Avs. There is nobody enticing at all for the Avs on the Pens. Even Crosby wouldn't make sense and that's probably already something that Pens fans would never allow. There is literally not even a starting piece for MacKinnon on the Pens that would make sence.

1 for 4 on the spelling of sense

 

[SEALBound]

No that includes pens fans.

Dont lump us all in with OP

Very much this. Ridiculous.

 

[hockeyviking]

A away game for the avs in pittsburg

 

[DOCHockeyGuy]

Every time I think I have seen the dumbest proposal on this site I am quickly reminded that it can always be worse

 

[trick9]

Crosby + Letang for MacK + Barrie propably. Doesn't make sense for either side still though.

 

[missionAvs]

Just wanted to get in on this epic trade proposal before its inevitable lock. Happy to be a part of it!

 

[jls24]

And I thought seeing the thread asking about D-cat would be the craziest thing I read today.

I'm so glad I can back to the trade board after a couple months break. Pure entertainment.

 

[pockets]

Crosby + Letang for MacK + Barrie propably. Doesn't make sense for either side still though.

No, not probably, not even close for the Avs, why the f*** would the Avs trade away two considerably cheaper, younger and equally as productive players just to help the Pens. As I said before, there is literally nothing the Pens could offer the Avs for MacKinnon, never mind MacK and Barrie...

 

[66-30-33]

Wont happen, will cost Pens more then we can afford. Would pretty much gut the team. Colorado wont want Crosby or Malkin because they are over 30.