Well.
Our D is worse. Our stars are a year older. We have multiple question marks in terms of wingers. Every team in our division outside of the Canes got better. We lost an elite point producer and replaced him with a equally lame defensive liability who scores less and a 4th liner that had a career season.
Also, we have plenty of threads like this from time to time. You should’ve been around here during 2015..
It’s light hearted. You do realize the salary cap thread is called JR is the worst.
I don't think our D is worse. We didn't have Pettersson. Maatta had a horrendous start to the year. If Gudbranson plays the way he did last year then he's better than Ruhwedel.
Crosby and Letang aren't falling off a cliff physically next year. Not with the way they train. Malkin's coming back highly motivated after a bad year. And for 10 forwards aged 23-27, being a year older and more experienced can prove useful.
What question marks on wings? We're pretty balanced on both sides. The 3rd and 4th lines especially looks so much better.
We did lose Phil and that is a valid argument that we got worse there. Gotta remember however that Jake replaces him on PP1. How many of Phil's 36 PPP's does Jake get? Probably like 25, right? How many of the 13 SHGA prevented without Phil there?
Then looking at ES, how many of Phil's 46 ES points does Galchenyuk get? I see no reason he can't get 35+ with Malkin.
So yeah, we lose that deal short term offensively, but I'm expecting the 2nd line to allow fewer goals against with a fresh look and better attitude. The net loss with losing Phil isn't that tragic.
---
I got no problem with you if you get back to posting more on the level of what you did when I came here last summer. You used to try harder. These kinds of posts are a slippery slope. Threads like these eventually lead to
threads like this:
That's reddit for you, and yes those are actual threads. That's what I'd like to avoid. Light-hearted stuff is fine and we do it need sometimes with how angry people get here. But there should be one master thread for it.