Voting Record - ted1971, Dennis Bonvie, pappyline

[MXD]

Wayne Gretzky was on the ice for 3520 GF while Robinson, in 98 less games, was on the ice for 2635 GF. That differential is even more staggering.

What's your take on the new lists?
I mean... We just had an even worse statistical outlier than C1958, yet you kept mysteriously silent about it.

 

[Nick Hansen]

Waiting for the new batch of lists to furiously tear down.

 

[ChiTownPhilly]

Dennis Bonvie:

unrequited (in personal top-100 but omitted from final list)
56. Bowie
65. Krutov
80. Bower
84. McDavid
85. Doughty
87. Karlsson
90. T. Thompson
96. Langway
Cherry Popping Daddies (on final list, but de-listed by contributor)
87. Cowley
90. Gadsby
91. Thornton
100. Abel

pappyline:

unrequited
76. Št'astný
77. Bower
82. Hainsworth
83. Parent
86. Perrault
87. B. Jackson
88. D. Bentley*
90. Delvecchio
91. Ullman
96. Bucyk
97. R. Francis
99. Vasiliev
100. S. Savard
*drive-by trivia... Doug Bentley was elected to the HHoF before Max.
Cherry Popping Daddies
85. Belfour
87. Cowley (our current front-runner for top f***sman)
89. Chara
95. M. Howe

(as always, proofreading/corrections will be welcomed)

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

Dennis Bonvie:

unrequited (in personal top-100 but omitted from final list)
56. Bowie
65. Krutov
80. Bower
84. McDavid
85. Doughty
87. Karlsson
90. T. Thompson
96. Langway
Cherry Popping Daddies (on final list, but de-listed by contributor)
87. Cowley
90. Gadsby
91. Thornton
100. Abel

pappyline:

unrequited
76. Št'astný
77. Bower
82. Hainsworth
83. Parent
86. Perrault
87. B. Jackson
88. D. Bentley*
90. Delvecchio
91. Ullman
96. Bucyk
97. R. Francis
99. Vasiliev
100. S. Savard
*drive-by trivia... Doug Bentley was elected to the HHoF before Max.
Cherry Popping Daddies
85. Belfour
87. Cowley (our current front-runner for top ****sman)
89. Chara
95. M. Howe

(as always, proofreading/corrections will be welcomed)

I stand by making both Cowley & Thornton listless.

 

[ChiTownPhilly]

... aaand- I just noticed another list that was free of Cherry Popping Daddies-- the list of ted1971.
[Came close with Fedorov, who leaked onto his list at position 118.]
The unrequiteds were: 81. Ullman, 86. Bowie, 92. Gerard, 94. Datsyuk, 98. Bure, 99. D. Bentley.

One more thing I noticed- wow, @ted1971 --- you sure did mutely sour on Charlie Conacher! Hard to say who was our biggest Conacher "counter-missionary." I suppose it was MF. He slapped him in slot 91 on his Prelim List.

Of all of the discoveries I made for myself in the Project, I'm proudest of the ones I made concerning Charlie Conacher. I'm grateful to have learned about them, independent of whether or not they proved persuasive to others.