Voting Record - Dr John Carlson, TheDevilMadeMe, JoseTheodore2002

Discussion in 'The History of Hockey' started by quoipourquoi, Apr 22, 2019.

  1. It's phishing season. Members should beware of an email informing them their password is about to expire. You should delete it. This is a scam to steal passwords.
    Dismiss Notice
  1. quoipourquoi Goaltender

    Joined:
    Jan 26, 2009
    Messages:
    10,045
    Likes Received:
    3,962
    Trophy Points:
    201
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Location:
    Hockeytown, MI
    VoterRankPlayerPoints12
    Dr John Carlson1Wayne Gretzky1201Wayne Gretzky1Jean Beliveau
    Dr John Carlson2Bobby Orr1192Bobby Orr2Patrick Roy
    Dr John Carlson3Gordie Howe1183Gordie Howe3Bobby Hull
    Dr John Carlson4Mario Lemieux1174Mario Lemieux4Doug Harvey
    Dr John Carlson5Jean Beliveau1165Jean Beliveau5Sidney Crosby
    Dr John Carlson6Bobby Hull1156Bobby Hull6Ray Bourque
    Dr John Carlson7Doug Harvey1147Doug Harvey7Dominik Hasek
    Dr John Carlson8Sidney Crosby1138Patrick Roy8Howie Morenz
    Dr John Carlson9Patrick Roy1129Ray Bourque9Maurice Richard
    Dr John Carlson10Ray Bourque11110Maurice Richard10Eddie Shore
    Dr John Carlson11Maurice Richard11034
    Dr John Carlson12Dominik Hasek1091Sidney Crosby1Jaromir Jagr
    Dr John Carlson13Jaromir Jagr1082Howie Morenz2Red Kelly
    Dr John Carlson14Alex Ovechkin1073Ray Bourque3Frank Nighbor
    Dr John Carlson15Red Kelly1064Jaromir Jagr4Alex Ovechkin
    Dr John Carlson16Howie Morenz1055Dominik Hasek5Nicklas Lidstrom
    Dr John Carlson17Nicklas Lidstrom1046Eddie Shore6Denis Potvin
    Dr John Carlson18Stan Mikita1037Alex Ovechkin7Mark Messier
    Dr John Carlson19Denis Potvin1028Nicklas Lidstrom8Phil Esposito
    Dr John Carlson20Mark Messier1019Denis Potvin9Stan Mikita
    Dr John Carlson21Frank Nighbor10010Stan Mikita10Jacques Plante
    Dr John Carlson22Bobby Clarke9956
    Dr John Carlson23Guy Lafleur981Alex Ovechkin1Martin Brodeur
    Dr John Carlson24Eddie Shore972Frank Nighbor2Glenn Hall
    Dr John Carlson25Glenn Hall963Mark Messier3Sergei Makarov
    Dr John Carlson26Martin Brodeur954Martin Brodeur4Viacheslav Fetisov
    Dr John Carlson27Sergei Makarov945Glenn Hall5Bobby Clarke
    Dr John Carlson28Joe Sakic936Stan Mikita6Phil Esposito
    Dr John Carlson29Phil Esposito927Viacheslav Fetisov7Joe Sakic
    Dr John Carlson30Jacques Plante918Guy Lafleur8Cyclone Taylor
    Dr John Carlson31Viacheslav Fetisov909Bobby Clarke9Bryan Trottier
    Dr John Carlson32Bryan Trottier8910Phil Esposito10Terry Sawchuk
    Dr John Carlson33Steve Yzerman8878
    Dr John Carlson34Cyclone Taylor871Martin Brodeur1Mike Bossy
    Dr John Carlson35Ted Lindsay862Joe Sakic2Chris Chelios
    Dr John Carlson36Terry Sawchuk853Cyclone Taylor3Larry Robinson
    Dr John Carlson37Syl Apps844Bill Cook4Steve Yzerman
    Dr John Carlson38Bill Cook835Larry Robinson5Terry Sawchuk
    Dr John Carlson39Mike Bossy826Bryan Trottier6Newsy Lalonde
    Dr John Carlson40Chris Chelios817Mike Bossy7Brad Park
    Dr John Carlson41Henri Richard808Terry Sawchuk8Ted Lindsay
    Dr John Carlson42Larry Robinson799Steve Yzerman9Paul Coffey
    Dr John Carlson43Evgeni Malkin7810Newsy Lalonde10Ken Dryden
    Dr John Carlson44Valeri Kharlamov77910
    Dr John Carlson45Marcel Dionne761Chris Chelios1Henri Richard
    Dr John Carlson46Brad Park752Frank Boucher2Syl Apps
    Dr John Carlson47Frank Boucher743King Clancy3Brad Park
    Dr John Carlson48Newsy Lalonde734Henri Richard4Peter Forsberg
    Dr John Carlson49Milt Schmidt725Syl Apps5Paul Coffey
    Dr John Carlson50Peter Forsberg716Brad Park6Vladislav Tretiak
    Dr John Carlson51Anatoli Firsov707Valeri Kharlamov7Pierre Pilote
    Dr John Carlson52Andy Bathgate698Paul Coffey8Milt Schmidt
    Dr John Carlson53Pierre Pilote689Vladislav Tretiak9Ken Dryden
    Dr John Carlson54King Clancy6710Pierre Pilote10Charlie Conacher
    Dr John Carlson55Ken Dryden661112
    Dr John Carlson56Paul Coffey651Peter Forsberg1Ted Kennedy
    Dr John Carlson57Sprague Cleghorn642Vladislav Tretiak2Marcel Dionne
    Dr John Carlson58Georges Vezina633Evgeni Malkin3Sprague Cleghorn
    Dr John Carlson59Chris Pronger624Milt Schmidt4Frank Brimsek
    Dr John Carlson60Frank Mahovlich615Pierre Pilote5Tim Horton
    Dr John Carlson61Charlie Conacher606Marcel Dionne6Charlie Conacher
    Dr John Carlson62Ted Kennedy597Frank Brimsek7Chris Pronger
    Dr John Carlson63Vladislav Tretiak588Charlie Conacher8Andy Bathgate
    Dr John Carlson64Teemu Selanne579Earl Seibert9Bernie Geoffrion
    Dr John Carlson65Scott Stevens5610Bernie Geoffrion10Earl Seibert
    Dr John Carlson66Bernie Geoffrion551314
    Dr John Carlson67Aurele Joliat541Andy Bathgate1Tim Horton
    Dr John Carlson68Charlie Gardiner532Marcel Dionne2Al MacInnis
    Dr John Carlson69Tim Horton523Tim Horton3Georges Vezina
    Dr John Carlson70Al MacInnis514Al MacInnis4Teemu Selanne
    Dr John Carlson71Frank Brimsek505Scott Stevens5Frank Mahovlich
    Dr John Carlson72Dit Clapper496Bernie Geoffrion6Dit Clapper
    Dr John Carlson73Jiri Holecek487Georges Vezina7Dickie Moore
    Dr John Carlson74Clint Benedict478Earl Seibert8Joe Malone
    Dr John Carlson75Zdeno Chara469Teemu Selanne9Clint Benedict
    Dr John Carlson76Alexander Maltsev4510Frank Mahovlich10Bill Durnan
    Dr John Carlson77Earl Seibert441516
    Dr John Carlson78Borje Salming431Anatoli Firsov1Aurele Joliat
    Dr John Carlson79Vladimir Martinec422Frank Mahovlich2Brett Hull
    Dr John Carlson80Brett Hull413Brett Hull3Charlie Gardiner
    Dr John Carlson81Joe Thornton404Dit Clapper4Jari Kurri
    Dr John Carlson82Boris Mikhailov395Joe Malone5Max Bentley
    Dr John Carlson83Norm Ullman386Jari Kurri6Boris Mikhailov
    Dr John Carlson84Ed Belfour377Clint Benedict7Turk Broda
    Dr John Carlson85Erik Karlsson368Turk Broda8Sergei Fedorov
    Dr John Carlson86Dickie Moore359Bill Durnan9Bill Durnan
    Dr John Carlson87Valeri Vasiliev3410Cy Denneny10Cy Denneny
    Dr John Carlson88Elmer Lach331718
    Dr John Carlson89Henrik Lundqvist321Brett Hull1Ed Belfour
    Dr John Carlson90Turk Broda312Elmer Lach2Zdeno Chara
    Dr John Carlson91Duncan Keith303Borje Salming3Bill Gadsby
    Dr John Carlson92Eric Lindros294Turk Broda4Bill Cowley
    Dr John Carlson93Patrick Kane285Bill Gadsby5Duncan Keith
    Dr John Carlson94Jarome Iginla276Boris Mikhailov6Boris Mikhailov
    Dr John Carlson95Bill Durnan267Bill Durnan7Sergei Fedorov
    Dr John Carlson96Max Bentley258Sergei Fedorov8Brian Leetch
    Dr John Carlson97Alexei Kasatonov249Brian Leetch9Martin St. Louis
    Dr John Carlson98Tony Esposito2310Nels Stewart10Eric Lindros
    Dr John Carlson99Brian Leetch221920
    Dr John Carlson100Jari Kurri211Joe Thornton1Erik Karlsson
    Dr John Carlson101Pavel Datsyuk202Patrick Kane2Eddie Gerard
    Dr John Carlson102Roberto Luongo193Bill Gadsby3Norm Ullman
    Dr John Carlson103Jan Suchy184Erik Karlsson4Sid Abel
    Dr John Carlson104Bill Cowley175Eddie Gerard5Mark Howe
    Dr John Carlson105Martin St. Louis166Duncan Keith6Brian Leetch
    Dr John Carlson106Tommy Phillips157Norm Ullman7Dave Keon
    Dr John Carlson107Eddie Gerard148Sid Abel8Peter Stastny
    Dr John Carlson108Mark Howe139Mark Howe9Martin St. Louis
    Dr John Carlson109Joe Malone1210Brian Leetch10Jiri Holecek
    Dr John Carlson110Bill Gadsby1121
    Dr John Carlson111Bill Quackenbush101Erik Karlsson
    Dr John Carlson112Vladimir Krutov92Eddie Gerard
    Dr John Carlson113Busher Jackson83Alexander Maltsev
    Dr John Carlson114Scott Niedermayer74Sid Abel
    Dr John Carlson115Vladimir Zabrodsky65Vladimir Martinec
    Dr John Carlson116Drew Doughty56Norm Ullman
    Dr John Carlson117Cy Denneny47Peter Stastny
    Dr John Carlson118Jack Stewart38Jiri Holecek
    Dr John Carlson119Sergei Fedorov29Serge Savard
    Dr John Carlson120Bryan Hextall110Jarome Iginla
    VoterRankPlayerPoints12
    TheDevilMadeMe1Wayne Gretzky1201Wayne Gretzky1Patrick Roy
    TheDevilMadeMe2Bobby Orr1192Gordie Howe2Jean Beliveau
    TheDevilMadeMe3Gordie Howe1183Bobby Orr3Maurice Richard
    TheDevilMadeMe4Mario Lemieux1174Mario Lemieux4Bobby Hull
    TheDevilMadeMe5Patrick Roy1165Patrick Roy5Sidney Crosby
    TheDevilMadeMe6Jean Beliveau1156Maurice Richard6Howie Morenz
    TheDevilMadeMe7Sidney Crosby1147Bobby Hull7Doug Harvey
    TheDevilMadeMe8Howie Morenz1138Jean Beliveau8Ray Bourque
    TheDevilMadeMe9Maurice Richard1129Doug Harvey9Eddie Shore
    TheDevilMadeMe10Bobby Hull11110Ray Bourque10Dominik Hasek
    TheDevilMadeMe11Doug Harvey11034
    TheDevilMadeMe12Ray Bourque1091Sidney Crosby1Nicklas Lidstrom
    TheDevilMadeMe13Alex Ovechkin1082Howie Morenz2Red Kelly
    TheDevilMadeMe14Nicklas Lidstrom1073Ray Bourque3Jacques Plante
    TheDevilMadeMe15Eddie Shore1064Jacques Plante4Mark Messier
    TheDevilMadeMe16Jacques Plante1055Nicklas Lidstrom5Alex Ovechkin
    TheDevilMadeMe17Red Kelly1046Eddie Shore6Jaromir Jagr
    TheDevilMadeMe18Mark Messier1037Alex Ovechkin7Guy Lafleur
    TheDevilMadeMe19Jaromir Jagr1028Dominik Hasek8Denis Potvin
    TheDevilMadeMe20Dominik Hasek1019Mark Messier9Stan Mikita
    TheDevilMadeMe21Glenn Hall10010Jaromir Jagr10Frank Nighbor
    TheDevilMadeMe22Denis Potvin9956
    TheDevilMadeMe23Viacheslav Fetisov981Mark Messier1Sergei Makarov
    TheDevilMadeMe24Sergei Makarov972Alex Ovechkin2Viacheslav Fetisov
    TheDevilMadeMe25Guy Lafleur963Glenn Hall3Martin Brodeur
    TheDevilMadeMe26Stan Mikita954Viacheslav Fetisov4Glenn Hall
    TheDevilMadeMe27Martin Brodeur945Frank Nighbor5Bobby Clarke
    TheDevilMadeMe28Phil Esposito936Guy Lafleur6Joe Sakic
    TheDevilMadeMe29Frank Nighbor927Martin Brodeur7Phil Esposito
    TheDevilMadeMe30Bill Cook918Stan Mikita8Cyclone Taylor
    TheDevilMadeMe31Terry Sawchuk909Bobby Clarke9Terry Sawchuk
    TheDevilMadeMe32Joe Sakic8910Phil Esposito10Bryan Trottier
    TheDevilMadeMe33Bobby Clarke8878
    TheDevilMadeMe34Cyclone Taylor871Martin Brodeur1Terry Sawchuk
    TheDevilMadeMe35Bryan Trottier862Bill Cook2Ted Lindsay
    TheDevilMadeMe36Ted Lindsay853Joe Sakic3Mike Bossy
    TheDevilMadeMe37Mike Bossy844Cyclone Taylor4Chris Chelios
    TheDevilMadeMe38Chris Chelios835Terry Sawchuk5Larry Robinson
    TheDevilMadeMe39Larry Robinson826Bryan Trottier6Ken Dryden
    TheDevilMadeMe40Valeri Kharlamov817Ted Lindsay7Steve Yzerman
    TheDevilMadeMe41Ken Dryden808Mike Bossy8Newsy Lalonde
    TheDevilMadeMe42Steve Yzerman799Larry Robinson9Paul Coffey
    TheDevilMadeMe43Syl Apps7810Steve Yzerman10Brad Park
    TheDevilMadeMe44Henri Richard77910
    TheDevilMadeMe45King Clancy761Chris Chelios1Syl Apps
    TheDevilMadeMe46Anatoli Firsov752Valeri Kharlamov2Henri Richard
    TheDevilMadeMe47Brad Park743Ken Dryden3Ken Dryden
    TheDevilMadeMe48Charlie Conacher734King Clancy4Vladislav Tretiak
    TheDevilMadeMe49Paul Coffey725Syl Apps5Peter Forsberg
    TheDevilMadeMe50Frank Boucher716Henri Richard6Paul Coffey
    TheDevilMadeMe51Frank Brimsek707Paul Coffey7Charlie Conacher
    TheDevilMadeMe52Pierre Pilote698Charlie Conacher8Milt Schmidt
    TheDevilMadeMe53Newsy Lalonde689Frank Boucher9Pierre Pilote
    TheDevilMadeMe54Peter Forsberg6710Brad Park10Brad Park
    TheDevilMadeMe55Evgeni Malkin661112
    TheDevilMadeMe56Georges Vezina651Vladislav Tretiak1Frank Brimsek
    TheDevilMadeMe57Sprague Cleghorn642Peter Forsberg2Sprague Cleghorn
    TheDevilMadeMe58Milt Schmidt633Evgeni Malkin3Charlie Conacher
    TheDevilMadeMe59Scott Stevens624Frank Brimsek4Andy Bathgate
    TheDevilMadeMe60Tim Horton615Charlie Conacher5Ted Kennedy
    TheDevilMadeMe61Al MacInnis606Pierre Pilote6Bernie Geoffrion
    TheDevilMadeMe62Bernie Geoffrion597Milt Schmidt7Tim Horton
    TheDevilMadeMe63Max Bentley588Bernie Geoffrion8Chris Pronger
    TheDevilMadeMe64Earl Seibert579Marcel Dionne9Marcel Dionne
    TheDevilMadeMe65Chris Pronger5610Earl Seibert10Earl Seibert
    TheDevilMadeMe66Charlie Gardiner551314
    TheDevilMadeMe67Andy Bathgate541Scott Stevens1Georges Vezina
    TheDevilMadeMe68Ted Kennedy532Georges Vezina2Tim Horton
    TheDevilMadeMe69Patrick Kane523Bernie Geoffrion3Al MacInnis
    TheDevilMadeMe70Norm Ullman514Andy Bathgate4Teemu Selanne
    TheDevilMadeMe71Elmer Lach505Tim Horton5Joe Malone
    TheDevilMadeMe72Teemu Selanne496Earl Seibert6Dit Clapper
    TheDevilMadeMe73Vladimir Martinec487Al MacInnis7Frank Mahovlich
    TheDevilMadeMe74Bill Cowley478Marcel Dionne8Dickie Moore
    TheDevilMadeMe75Vladislav Tretiak469Teemu Selanne9Clint Benedict
    TheDevilMadeMe76Marcel Dionne4510Frank Mahovlich10Cy Denneny
    TheDevilMadeMe77Turk Broda441516
    TheDevilMadeMe78Jiri Holecek431Anatoli Firsov1Charlie Gardiner
    TheDevilMadeMe79Aurele Joliat422Joe Malone2Max Bentley
    TheDevilMadeMe80Boris Mikhailov413Dit Clapper3Aurele Joliat
    TheDevilMadeMe81Jarome Iginla404Frank Mahovlich4Jari Kurri
    TheDevilMadeMe82Dickie Moore395Jari Kurri5Turk Broda
    TheDevilMadeMe83Nels Stewart386Clint Benedict6Cy Denneny
    TheDevilMadeMe84Brian Leetch377Cy Denneny7Boris Mikhailov
    TheDevilMadeMe85Erik Karlsson368Brett Hull8Brett Hull
    TheDevilMadeMe86Frank Mahovlich359Turk Broda9Bill Durnan
    TheDevilMadeMe87Alexander Maltsev3410Bill Durnan10Sergei Fedorov
    TheDevilMadeMe88Martin St. Louis331718
    TheDevilMadeMe89Joe Thornton321Elmer Lach1Bill Cowley
    TheDevilMadeMe90Zdeno Chara312Turk Broda2Zdeno Chara
    TheDevilMadeMe91Eddie Gerard303Borje Salming3Ed Belfour
    TheDevilMadeMe92Bill Durnan294Brett Hull4Boris Mikhailov
    TheDevilMadeMe93Borje Salming285Boris Mikhailov5Nels Stewart
    TheDevilMadeMe94Bill Gadsby276Bill Durnan6Duncan Keith
    TheDevilMadeMe95Dit Clapper267Nels Stewart7Brian Leetch
    TheDevilMadeMe96Sid Abel258Brian Leetch8Bill Gadsby
    TheDevilMadeMe97Ed Belfour249Bill Gadsby9Martin St. Louis
    TheDevilMadeMe98Duncan Keith2310Sergei Fedorov10Eric Lindros
    TheDevilMadeMe99Henrik Lundqvist221920
    TheDevilMadeMe100Cy Denneny211Patrick Kane1Brian Leetch
    TheDevilMadeMe101Toe Blake202Joe Thornton2Norm Ullman
    TheDevilMadeMe102Jari Kurri193Nels Stewart3Jarome Iginla
    TheDevilMadeMe103Brett Hull184Duncan Keith4Martin St. Louis
    TheDevilMadeMe104Russell Bowie175Bill Gadsby5Mark Howe
    TheDevilMadeMe105Valeri Vasiliev166Brian Leetch6Eric Lindros
    TheDevilMadeMe106Clint Benedict157Norm Ullman7Sid Abel
    TheDevilMadeMe107Doug Bentley148Jarome Iginla8Toe Blake
    TheDevilMadeMe108Busher Jackson139Martin St. Louis9Eddie Gerard
    TheDevilMadeMe109Roy Worters1210Mark Howe10Jiri Holecek
    TheDevilMadeMe110Hugh Lehman1121
    TheDevilMadeMe111Tony Esposito101Vladimir Martinec
    TheDevilMadeMe112Marty Barry92Norm Ullman
    TheDevilMadeMe113Dave Keon83Alexander Maltsev
    TheDevilMadeMe114Bernie Parent74Jarome Iginla
    TheDevilMadeMe115Bill Quackenbush65Eddie Gerard
    TheDevilMadeMe116Mark Howe56Erik Karlsson
    TheDevilMadeMe117Sergei Fedorov47Toe Blake
    TheDevilMadeMe118Doug Gilmour38Sid Abel
    TheDevilMadeMe119Peter Stastny29Russell Bowie
    TheDevilMadeMe120Eric Lindros110Jiri Holecek
    VoterRankPlayerPoints
    JoseTheodore20021Bobby Orr120
    JoseTheodore20022Wayne Gretzky119
    JoseTheodore20023Mario Lemieux118
    JoseTheodore20024Gordie Howe117
    JoseTheodore20025Maurice Richard116
    JoseTheodore20026Bobby Hull115
    JoseTheodore20027Jean Beliveau114
    JoseTheodore20028Doug Harvey113
    JoseTheodore20029Howie Morenz112
    JoseTheodore200210Eddie Shore111
    JoseTheodore200211Sidney Crosby110
    JoseTheodore200212Ray Bourque109
    JoseTheodore200213Mike Bossy108
    JoseTheodore200214Jaromir Jagr107
    JoseTheodore200215Nicklas Lidstrom106
    JoseTheodore200216Alex Ovechkin105
    JoseTheodore200217Stan Mikita104
    JoseTheodore200218Guy Lafleur103
    JoseTheodore200219Denis Potvin102
    JoseTheodore200220Dominik Hasek101
    JoseTheodore200221Patrick Roy100
    JoseTheodore200222Phil Esposito99
    JoseTheodore200223Jacques Plante98
    JoseTheodore200224Bobby Clarke97
    JoseTheodore200225Red Kelly96
    JoseTheodore200226Ted Lindsay95
    JoseTheodore200227Terry Sawchuk94
    JoseTheodore200228Martin Brodeur93
    JoseTheodore200229Bryan Trottier92
    JoseTheodore200230Viacheslav Fetisov91
    JoseTheodore200231Valeri Kharlamov90
    JoseTheodore200232Vladislav Tretiak89
    JoseTheodore200233Mark Messier88
    JoseTheodore200234Newsy Lalonde87
    JoseTheodore200235Joe Sakic86
    JoseTheodore200236Steve Yzerman85
    JoseTheodore200237Bernie Geoffrion84
    JoseTheodore200238Glenn Hall83
    JoseTheodore200239Larry Robinson82
    JoseTheodore200240Ken Dryden81
    JoseTheodore200241Chris Chelios80
    JoseTheodore200242Syl Apps79
    JoseTheodore200243Cyclone Taylor78
    JoseTheodore200244Joe Malone77
    JoseTheodore200245Brad Park76
    JoseTheodore200246Earl Seibert75
    JoseTheodore200247Paul Coffey74
    JoseTheodore200248Marcel Dionne73
    JoseTheodore200249Bill Cook72
    JoseTheodore200250Charlie Conacher71
    JoseTheodore200251Frank Mahovlich70
    JoseTheodore200252Max Bentley69
    JoseTheodore200253Bill Durnan68
    JoseTheodore200254Dit Clapper67
    JoseTheodore200255Tim Horton66
    JoseTheodore200256Pierre Pilote65
    JoseTheodore200257Dickie Moore64
    JoseTheodore200258Henri Richard63
    JoseTheodore200259King Clancy62
    JoseTheodore200260Aurele Joliat61
    JoseTheodore200261Turk Broda60
    JoseTheodore200262Andy Bathgate59
    JoseTheodore200263Sprague Cleghorn58
    JoseTheodore200264Brett Hull57
    JoseTheodore200265Frank Boucher56
    JoseTheodore200266Frank Brimsek55
    JoseTheodore200267Al MacInnis54
    JoseTheodore200268Sergei Makarov53
    JoseTheodore200269Cy Denneny52
    JoseTheodore200270Boris Mikhailov51
    JoseTheodore200271Jari Kurri50
    JoseTheodore200272Nels Stewart49
    JoseTheodore200273Clint Benedict48
    JoseTheodore200274Peter Stastny47
    JoseTheodore200275Ted Kennedy46
    JoseTheodore200276Evgeni Malkin45
    JoseTheodore200277Frank Nighbor44
    JoseTheodore200278Peter Forsberg43
    JoseTheodore200279Eric Lindros42
    JoseTheodore200280Sergei Fedorov41
    JoseTheodore200281Pavel Bure40
    JoseTheodore200282Bill Cowley39
    JoseTheodore200283Elmer Lach38
    JoseTheodore200284Johnny Bower37
    JoseTheodore200285Bernie Parent36
    JoseTheodore200286Anatoli Firsov35
    JoseTheodore200287Toe Blake34
    JoseTheodore200288Pavel Datsyuk33
    JoseTheodore200289Dave Keon32
    JoseTheodore200290George Hainsworth31
    JoseTheodore200291Duncan Keith30
    JoseTheodore200292Zdeno Chara29
    JoseTheodore200293Scott Stevens28
    JoseTheodore200294Chris Pronger27
    JoseTheodore200295Milt Schmidt26
    JoseTheodore200296Gilbert Perreault25
    JoseTheodore200297Jarome Iginla24
    JoseTheodore200298Joe Thornton23
    JoseTheodore200299Doug Bentley22
    JoseTheodore2002100Borje Salming21
    JoseTheodore2002101Martin St. Louis20
    JoseTheodore2002102Teemu Selanne19
    JoseTheodore2002103Paul Kariya18
    JoseTheodore2002104Scott Niedermayer17
    JoseTheodore2002105Bill Quackenbush16
    JoseTheodore2002106Bill Gadsby15
    JoseTheodore2002107Busher Jackson14
    JoseTheodore2002108Patrick Kane13
    JoseTheodore2002109Mike Modano12
    JoseTheodore2002110Connor McDavid11
    JoseTheodore2002111Brian Leetch10
    JoseTheodore2002112Charlie Gardiner9
    JoseTheodore2002113Ed Belfour8
    JoseTheodore2002114Patrice Bergeron7
    JoseTheodore2002115Bob Gainey6
    JoseTheodore2002116Serge Savard5
    JoseTheodore2002117Igor Larionov4
    JoseTheodore2002118Valeri Vasiliev3
    JoseTheodore2002119Grant Fuhr2
    JoseTheodore2002120Brendan Shanahan1
     
  2. Canadiens1958 Registered User

    Joined:
    Nov 30, 2007
    Messages:
    20,020
    Likes Received:
    2,661
    Trophy Points:
    196
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Gender:
    Male
    Occupation:
    Retired
    Location:
    Lake Memphremagog, QC.
    JoseTheodore2002. Very interesting, well structured list. Posting during the rounds would have contributed a great deal to the result. No Norm Ullman - well done.

    TDMM. Very obvious after all these years. Predictable.

    Dr.John Carlson. Paradoxical defensively.
     
  3. sr edler whom

    Joined:
    Mar 20, 2010
    Messages:
    9,787
    Likes Received:
    3,845
    Trophy Points:
    171
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Jose Theodore gets a plus from senior edler for ranking Nighbor, Forsberg, Fedorov, Bure in that order, they were too low though. But most importantly they were in front of Selänne/Iginla. Job well done. :thumbu:
     
  4. ChiTownPhilly Not Too Soft

    Joined:
    Feb 23, 2010
    Messages:
    1,564
    Likes Received:
    849
    Trophy Points:
    139
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Occupation:
    Private Sector wk ethic trapped in Govt Mgr career
    Location:
    NOT under a sofa
    Agree- it IS very interesting. Not afraid to stake out unconventional positions. Highest on: Bossy (13), Joliat (60)... and went for a Shanahan singularity at 120 (who, co-incidentally, was the self-admitted last cut of "Sentinel"). Lowest on: Nighbor (77) and Schmidt (95!) [Zero credit for the missing War Years is only one of the components I could see in putting him down there...] That said, The Panel could have used a good Nighbor-skeptic. I wound up placing him in the low-20s, and I'm still not sure if I should feel good about it in the morning---

    Tretiak at 32 brings a smile to my face... but then there's Makarov all the way down at 68.

    The list? Maybe(?) The Voting patterns-- not so much. Guess it could be said that TDMM was demonstrably willing to reconsider his positions post-discussion. @TheDevilMadeMe would be my leading candidate for the exercise of submitting an "after" list- to see how much has been reconsidered in light of the conversations conducted on the boards.

    BTW- my "after" list is still a work-in-progress. I've answered for myself the question of just how much I under-rated Firsov (nearly 20 places)-- and I'm currently paused in the mid-70s as I try to work through my bipolar feelings concerning Holeček.
     
  5. VMBM Touch a mountain... m'kay?

    Joined:
    Sep 24, 2008
    Messages:
    3,298
    Likes Received:
    380
    Trophy Points:
    139
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Gender:
    Male
    Location:
    Helsinki, FInland
    TheDevilMadeMe likes Vladimir Martinec even more than I do! :DD
     
  6. DannyGallivan Your world frightens and confuses me

    Joined:
    Aug 25, 2017
    Messages:
    5,274
    Likes Received:
    4,712
    Trophy Points:
    111
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Location:
    Melonville
    Since we're discussing JoseTheodore2002 right now, I'll give some hot takes:

    Orr at number one - great call. The right call.
    The Rocket is way too high. Like to hear why he's better than Hull and Beliveau.
    Bossy at 13 is a head-scratcher (but then again, I'm one guy who knows all about outside-of-the-box placements).
    I salute Bergeron making the top 120. Of course, if Bergeron makes the list, it makes sense for McDavid to make the list a little higher.
    I double-salute Parent at 85. Gutsy.
    No Mark Howe? Either I missed something, or that's a major hole in your lineup.
     
    Last edited: Apr 23, 2019
  7. sr edler whom

    Joined:
    Mar 20, 2010
    Messages:
    9,787
    Likes Received:
    3,845
    Trophy Points:
    171
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    TDMM did lobby quite successfully for a couple of players who, when they showed up, mysteriously leapfrogged the whole field. So he would be my leading candidate for the exercise of being a successful new-school influencer. :cool:
     
  8. Bear of Bad News HFBoards Escape Goat

    Joined:
    Sep 27, 2005
    Messages:
    7,341
    Likes Received:
    4,829
    Trophy Points:
    201
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Location:
    Windsor
    Awards:
    ???

    Was the goal here to be coy and unpredictable?
     
    ResilientBeast likes this.
  9. MXD Original #4

    Joined:
    Oct 27, 2005
    Messages:
    42,561
    Likes Received:
    6,017
    Trophy Points:
    231
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Occupation:
    Dead
    I really, really didn't had much on any of these three lists. Really liked @Dr John Carlson 's list (had no clue it was him) and @TheDevilMadeMe was one of the possible authors of his list, which I found boring (it's meant to be a compliment). User-MXD didn't agree with @JoseTheodore2002's list, but this one is filed in the "Let's Agree To Disagree, but I like what you've done" moments, so Screener-MXD had absolutely no issue with it. Flagged Vezina and Esposito as missing.
     
  10. Canadiens1958 Registered User

    Joined:
    Nov 30, 2007
    Messages:
    20,020
    Likes Received:
    2,661
    Trophy Points:
    196
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Gender:
    Male
    Occupation:
    Retired
    Location:
    Lake Memphremagog, QC.

    TDMM is the biggest Marty Barry booster.
     
  11. Bear of Bad News HFBoards Escape Goat

    Joined:
    Sep 27, 2005
    Messages:
    7,341
    Likes Received:
    4,829
    Trophy Points:
    201
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Location:
    Windsor
    Awards:
    That doesn't really answer my question.
     
  12. ChiTownPhilly Not Too Soft

    Joined:
    Feb 23, 2010
    Messages:
    1,564
    Likes Received:
    849
    Trophy Points:
    139
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Occupation:
    Private Sector wk ethic trapped in Govt Mgr career
    Location:
    NOT under a sofa
    I understand your feelings-- but I think that's a little over-glib. If someone lobbies successfully- providing argumentative support for their positions- and that resonates with The Panel, there's nothing mysterious about it. I agree with you that he's on the short-list of most influential posters (no points for who the other main one was)... but, as I intimated before, it's not like he was an "Unmoved Mover." He, too, tweaked his positions in response to arguments.

    That said, influence, even among long-standing, knowledgeable contributors, has its limits. Sometimes All The King's Horses and All the King's Men... (e.g.: Ullman).
     
    TheDevilMadeMe likes this.
  13. MXD Original #4

    Joined:
    Oct 27, 2005
    Messages:
    42,561
    Likes Received:
    6,017
    Trophy Points:
    231
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Occupation:
    Dead
    Gardiner leapfrogged the field because he was already overdue by the time he came available for voting, because he's exactly the type of player that may have been omitted in Round 1, despite being the answer to two trivia questions (Who's the first European-born player to capitain an NHL team to the Stanley Cup? Who's the lone goaltender to capitain an NHL team to the Stanley Cup?)
     
    TheDevilMadeMe likes this.
  14. sr edler whom

    Joined:
    Mar 20, 2010
    Messages:
    9,787
    Likes Received:
    3,845
    Trophy Points:
    171
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    I can make up random trivia questions too. Who was the first Australian born player to appear in the SCFs? Which SC winning hockey player wore a fez in Egypt with a big smile on his face during WWI?
     
  15. sr edler whom

    Joined:
    Mar 20, 2010
    Messages:
    9,787
    Likes Received:
    3,845
    Trophy Points:
    171
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    You have to tell me, because I have no idea who you're alluding to regarding "the other" one. In a PM if you don't want to "write it out in the open".
     
  16. sr edler whom

    Joined:
    Mar 20, 2010
    Messages:
    9,787
    Likes Received:
    3,845
    Trophy Points:
    171
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    The irony here is that C58s list also was predictable, because he ranked Gretzky 6th or 7th and was high on Lemaire, et cetera, already during the last project.
     
    TheDevilMadeMe likes this.
  17. Dennis Bonvie Registered User

    Joined:
    Dec 29, 2007
    Messages:
    19,204
    Likes Received:
    5,398
    Trophy Points:
    186
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Gender:
    Male
    Occupation:
    Retired
    Location:
    Connecticut
    Yes, TDMM is an excellent salesman.

    He's very well read its well known.

    So when he opens a thread with, "well, blah blah blah is an easy #1 this round", its a big influence.
     

Share This Page

Presented in Association with the Society for International Hockey Research
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice
monitoring_string = "358c248ada348a047a4b9bb27a146148"