Voting Record - blogofmike, TheGeneral, The Macho Man

[quoipourquoi]

Voter	Rank	Player	Points		1		2
blogofmike	1	Wayne Gretzky	120	1	Wayne Gretzky	1	Bobby Hull
blogofmike	2	Gordie Howe	119	2	Gordie Howe	2	Patrick Roy
blogofmike	3	Bobby Orr	118	3	Mario Lemieux	3	Ray Bourque
blogofmike	4	Mario Lemieux	117	4	Bobby Orr	4	Maurice Richard
blogofmike	5	Bobby Hull	116	5	Bobby Hull	5	Dominik Hasek
blogofmike	6	Jean Beliveau	115	6	Jean Beliveau	6	Sidney Crosby
blogofmike	7	Patrick Roy	114	7	Patrick Roy	7	Jean Beliveau
blogofmike	8	Maurice Richard	113	8	Maurice Richard	8	Eddie Shore
blogofmike	9	Mark Messier	112	9	Ray Bourque	9	Howie Morenz
blogofmike	10	Ray Bourque	111	10	Doug Harvey	10	Doug Harvey
blogofmike	11	Dominik Hasek	110		3		4
blogofmike	12	Jaromir Jagr	109	1	Mark Messier	1	Mark Messier
blogofmike	13	Jacques Plante	108	2	Ray Bourque	2	Jaromir Jagr
blogofmike	14	Stan Mikita	107	3	Jaromir Jagr	3	Jacques Plante
blogofmike	15	Eddie Shore	106	4	Dominik Hasek	4	Denis Potvin
blogofmike	16	Phil Esposito	105	5	Jacques Plante	5	Phil Esposito
blogofmike	17	Howie Morenz	104	6	Howie Morenz	6	Frank Nighbor
blogofmike	18	Martin Brodeur	103	7	Sidney Crosby	7	Nicklas Lidstrom
blogofmike	19	Sidney Crosby	102	8	Denis Potvin	8	Red Kelly
blogofmike	20	Joe Sakic	101	9	Eddie Shore	9	Stan Mikita
blogofmike	21	Bobby Clarke	100	10	Alex Ovechkin	10	Alex Ovechkin
blogofmike	22	Alex Ovechkin	99		5		6
blogofmike	23	Frank Nighbor	98	1	Mark Messier	1	Phil Esposito
blogofmike	24	Guy Lafleur	97	2	Martin Brodeur	2	Martin Brodeur
blogofmike	25	Cyclone Taylor	96	3	Phil Esposito	3	Viacheslav Fetisov
blogofmike	26	Newsy Lalonde	95	4	Frank Nighbor	4	Sergei Makarov
blogofmike	27	Nicklas Lidstrom	94	5	Glenn Hall	5	Cyclone Taylor
blogofmike	28	Doug Harvey	93	6	Stan Mikita	6	Joe Sakic
blogofmike	29	Viacheslav Fetisov	92	7	Alex Ovechkin	7	Glenn Hall
blogofmike	30	Denis Potvin	91	8	Viacheslav Fetisov	8	Bryan Trottier
blogofmike	31	Mike Bossy	90	9	Bobby Clarke	9	Mike Bossy
blogofmike	32	Red Kelly	89	10	Guy Lafleur	10	Terry Sawchuk
blogofmike	33	Steve Yzerman	88		7		8
blogofmike	34	Larry Robinson	87	1	Martin Brodeur	1	Steve Yzerman
blogofmike	35	Bryan Trottier	86	2	Joe Sakic	2	Mike Bossy
blogofmike	36	Sergei Makarov	85	3	Cyclone Taylor	3	Larry Robinson
blogofmike	37	Terry Sawchuk	84	4	Mike Bossy	4	Terry Sawchuk
blogofmike	38	Vladislav Tretiak	83	5	Steve Yzerman	5	Chris Chelios
blogofmike	39	Ken Dryden	82	6	Bryan Trottier	6	Ken Dryden
blogofmike	40	Paul Coffey	81	7	Terry Sawchuk	7	Newsy Lalonde
blogofmike	41	Glenn Hall	80	8	Bill Cook	8	Ted Lindsay
blogofmike	42	Al MacInnis	79	9	Newsy Lalonde	9	Paul Coffey
blogofmike	43	Scott Stevens	78	10	Larry Robinson	10	Brad Park
blogofmike	44	Chris Pronger	77		9		10
blogofmike	45	Bill Durnan	76	1	Chris Chelios	1	Paul Coffey
blogofmike	46	Peter Forsberg	75	2	Vladislav Tretiak	2	Peter Forsberg
blogofmike	47	Brett Hull	74	3	Paul Coffey	3	Vladislav Tretiak
blogofmike	48	Ted Lindsay	73	4	Valeri Kharlamov	4	Bernie Geoffrion
blogofmike	49	Ted Kennedy	72	5	Ken Dryden	5	Ken Dryden
blogofmike	50	King Clancy	71	6	King Clancy	6	Syl Apps
blogofmike	51	Marcel Dionne	70	7	Frank Boucher	7	Henri Richard
blogofmike	52	Chris Chelios	69	8	Syl Apps	8	Charlie Conacher
blogofmike	53	Henri Richard	68	9	Pierre Pilote	9	Milt Schmidt
blogofmike	54	Frank Boucher	67	10	Henri Richard	10	Pierre Pilote
blogofmike	55	Sprague Cleghorn	66		11		12
blogofmike	56	Bernie Geoffrion	65	1	Vladislav Tretiak	1	Chris Pronger
blogofmike	57	Bill Cook	64	2	Peter Forsberg	2	Ted Kennedy
blogofmike	58	Pierre Pilote	63	3	Bernie Geoffrion	3	Marcel Dionne
blogofmike	59	Dit Clapper	62	4	Evgeni Malkin	4	Bernie Geoffrion
blogofmike	60	Nels Stewart	61	5	Marcel Dionne	5	Charlie Conacher
blogofmike	61	Sergei Fedorov	60	6	Frank Brimsek	6	Frank Brimsek
blogofmike	62	Milt Schmidt	59	7	Charlie Conacher	7	Frank Mahovlich
blogofmike	63	Frank Brimsek	58	8	Milt Schmidt	8	Sprague Cleghorn
blogofmike	64	Brad Park	57	9	Pierre Pilote	9	Earl Seibert
blogofmike	65	Jari Kurri	56	10	Earl Seibert	10	Tim Horton
blogofmike	66	Earl Seibert	55
blogofmike	67	Georges Vezina	54
blogofmike	68	Andy Bathgate	53
blogofmike	69	Frank Mahovlich	52
blogofmike	70	Teemu Selanne	51
blogofmike	71	Sid Abel	50
blogofmike	72	Tim Horton	49
blogofmike	73	Valeri Kharlamov	48
blogofmike	74	Charlie Conacher	47
blogofmike	75	Joe Malone	46
blogofmike	76	Syl Apps	45
blogofmike	77	Duncan Keith	44		15		16
blogofmike	78	Peter Stastny	43	1	Brett Hull	1	Jari Kurri
blogofmike	79	Jarome Iginla	42	2	Jari Kurri	2	Brett Hull
blogofmike	80	Clint Benedict	41	3	Bill Durnan	3	Bill Durnan
blogofmike	81	Mark Howe	40	4	Clint Benedict	4	Turk Broda
blogofmike	82	Patrick Kane	39	5	Turk Broda	5	Sergei Fedorov
blogofmike	83	Aurele Joliat	38	6	Joe Malone	6	Boris Mikhailov
blogofmike	84	Eric Lindros	37	7	Cy Denneny	7	Charlie Gardiner
blogofmike	85	Jean Ratelle	36	8	Frank Mahovlich	8	Cy Denneny
blogofmike	86	Martin St. Louis	35	9	Dit Clapper	9	Max Bentley
blogofmike	87	Brian Leetch	34	10	Anatoli Firsov	10	Aurele Joliat
blogofmike	88	Max Bentley	33		17		18
blogofmike	89	Joe Thornton	32	1	Brett Hull	1	Sergei Fedorov
blogofmike	90	Bill Cowley	31	2	Bill Durnan	2	Boris Mikhailov
blogofmike	91	Gilbert Perreault	30	3	Turk Broda	3	Duncan Keith
blogofmike	92	Turk Broda	29	4	Sergei Fedorov	4	Zdeno Chara
blogofmike	93	Jonathan Toews	28	5	Elmer Lach	5	Brian Leetch
blogofmike	94	Grant Fuhr	27	6	Brian Leetch	6	Eric Lindros
blogofmike	95	Billy Smith	26	7	Borje Salming	7	Bill Cowley
blogofmike	96	Doug Gilmour	25	8	Boris Mikhailov	8	Nels Stewart
blogofmike	97	Johnny Bower	24	9	Nels Stewart	9	Ed Belfour
blogofmike	98	Henrik Lundqvist	23	10	Bill Gadsby	10	Martin St. Louis
blogofmike	99	Erik Karlsson	22		19
blogofmike	100	Toe Blake	21	1	Joe Thornton	10
blogofmike	101	Jiri Holecek	20	2	Duncan Keith	9
blogofmike	102	Pavel Bure	19	3	Eddie Gerard	8
blogofmike	103	Elmer Lach	18	4	Brian Leetch	7
blogofmike	104	Bernie Parent	17	5	Patrick Kane	6
blogofmike	105	Anze Kopitar	16	6	Erik Karlsson	5
blogofmike	106	Dave Keon	15	7	Mark Howe	4
blogofmike	107	Ed Belfour	14	8	Eric Lindros	3
blogofmike	108	Tony Esposito	13	9	Nels Stewart	2
blogofmike	109	Scott Niedermayer	12	10	Sid Abel	1
blogofmike	110	Evgeni Malkin	11		21
blogofmike	111	Serge Savard	10	1	Russell Bowie
blogofmike	112	Steven Stamkos	9	2	Doug Gilmour
blogofmike	113	Boris Mikhailov	8	3	Bernie Parent
blogofmike	114	Charlie Gardiner	7	4	Erik Karlsson
blogofmike	115	Borje Salming	6	5	Sid Abel
blogofmike	116	Valeri Vasiliev	5	6	Jarome Iginla
blogofmike	117	Cy Denneny	4	7	Alexander Maltsev
blogofmike	118	Roy Worters	3	8	Peter Stastny
blogofmike	119	Drew Doughty	2	9	Vladimir Martinec
blogofmike	120	Dickie Moore	1	10	Johnny Bower
Voter	Rank	Player	Points		1		2
TheGeneral	1	Wayne Gretzky	120	1	Wayne Gretzky	1	Bobby Hull
TheGeneral	2	Mario Lemieux	119	2	Mario Lemieux	2	Dominik Hasek
TheGeneral	3	Gordie Howe	118	3	Gordie Howe	3	Jean Beliveau
TheGeneral	4	Bobby Orr	117	4	Bobby Orr	4	Patrick Roy
TheGeneral	5	Bobby Hull	116	5	Bobby Hull	5	Ray Bourque
TheGeneral	6	Jean Beliveau	115	6	Jean Beliveau	6	Maurice Richard
TheGeneral	7	Mark Messier	114	7	Ray Bourque	7	Howie Morenz
TheGeneral	8	Jaromir Jagr	113	8	Patrick Roy	8	Eddie Shore
TheGeneral	9	Ray Bourque	112	9	Maurice Richard	9	Doug Harvey
TheGeneral	10	Patrick Roy	111	10	Doug Harvey	10	Sidney Crosby
TheGeneral	11	Alex Ovechkin	110
TheGeneral	12	Dominik Hasek	109
TheGeneral	13	Maurice Richard	108
TheGeneral	14	Nicklas Lidstrom	107
TheGeneral	15	Martin Brodeur	106
TheGeneral	16	Stan Mikita	105
TheGeneral	17	Phil Esposito	104
TheGeneral	18	Mike Bossy	103
TheGeneral	19	Howie Morenz	102
TheGeneral	20	Doug Harvey	101
TheGeneral	21	Denis Potvin	100
TheGeneral	22	Bobby Clarke	99		5
TheGeneral	23	Frank Nighbor	98	1	Mark Messier
TheGeneral	24	Steve Yzerman	97	2	Martin Brodeur
TheGeneral	25	Joe Sakic	96	3	Alex Ovechkin
TheGeneral	26	Sergei Makarov	95	4	Frank Nighbor
TheGeneral	27	Guy Lafleur	94	5	Stan Mikita
TheGeneral	28	Terry Sawchuk	93	6	Guy Lafleur
TheGeneral	29	Eddie Shore	92	7	Phil Esposito
TheGeneral	30	Viacheslav Fetisov	91	8	Bobby Clarke
TheGeneral	31	Larry Robinson	90	9	Viacheslav Fetisov
TheGeneral	32	Cyclone Taylor	89	10	Terry Sawchuk
TheGeneral	33	Ken Dryden	88		7
TheGeneral	34	Newsy Lalonde	87	1	Martin Brodeur
TheGeneral	35	Jacques Plante	86	2	Steve Yzerman
TheGeneral	36	Red Kelly	85	3	Joe Sakic
TheGeneral	37	Bryan Trottier	84	4	Mike Bossy
TheGeneral	38	Sergei Fedorov	83	5	Larry Robinson
TheGeneral	39	Paul Coffey	82	6	Bryan Trottier
TheGeneral	40	Ted Lindsay	81	7	Cyclone Taylor
TheGeneral	41	Glenn Hall	80	8	Terry Sawchuk
TheGeneral	42	King Clancy	79	9	Ted Lindsay
TheGeneral	43	Chris Pronger	78	10	Newsy Lalonde
TheGeneral	44	Teemu Selanne	77		9
TheGeneral	45	Chris Chelios	76	1	Paul Coffey
TheGeneral	46	Al MacInnis	75	2	Chris Chelios
TheGeneral	47	Brett Hull	74	3	Vladislav Tretiak
TheGeneral	48	Sidney Crosby	73	4	Ken Dryden
TheGeneral	49	Doug Gilmour	72	5	Henri Richard
TheGeneral	50	Scott Stevens	71	6	Brad Park
TheGeneral	51	Peter Forsberg	70	7	Pierre Pilote
TheGeneral	52	Vladislav Tretiak	69	8	Frank Boucher
TheGeneral	53	Scott Niedermayer	68	9	Charlie Conacher
TheGeneral	54	Frank Brimsek	67	10	Syl Apps
TheGeneral	55	Marcel Dionne	66
TheGeneral	56	Frank Boucher	65
TheGeneral	57	Duncan Keith	64
TheGeneral	58	Milt Schmidt	63
TheGeneral	59	Henri Richard	62
TheGeneral	60	Ted Kennedy	61
TheGeneral	61	Joe Malone	60
TheGeneral	62	Joe Thornton	59
TheGeneral	63	Peter Stastny	58
TheGeneral	64	Ron Francis	57
TheGeneral	65	Pavel Datsyuk	56
TheGeneral	66	Evgeni Malkin	55
TheGeneral	67	Erik Karlsson	54
TheGeneral	68	Ed Belfour	53
TheGeneral	69	Bill Cook	52
TheGeneral	70	Charlie Conacher	51
TheGeneral	71	Martin St. Louis	50
TheGeneral	72	Jari Kurri	49
TheGeneral	73	Alex Delvecchio	48
TheGeneral	74	Eric Lindros	47
TheGeneral	75	Bernie Geoffrion	46
TheGeneral	76	Valeri Kharlamov	45
TheGeneral	77	Dickie Moore	44
TheGeneral	78	Adam Oates	43
TheGeneral	79	Andy Bathgate	42
TheGeneral	80	Johnny Bower	41
TheGeneral	81	Tim Horton	40
TheGeneral	82	Dale Hawerchuk	39
TheGeneral	83	Frank Mahovlich	38
TheGeneral	84	Turk Broda	37
TheGeneral	85	Georges Vezina	36
TheGeneral	86	Cy Denneny	35
TheGeneral	87	Tony Esposito	34
TheGeneral	88	Patrick Kane	33
TheGeneral	89	Mike Modano	32
TheGeneral	90	Brad Park	31
TheGeneral	91	Gilbert Perreault	30
TheGeneral	92	Jean Ratelle	29
TheGeneral	93	Jarome Iginla	28
TheGeneral	94	Pavel Bure	27
TheGeneral	95	Sprague Cleghorn	26
TheGeneral	96	Jonathan Toews	25
TheGeneral	97	Denis Savard	24
TheGeneral	98	Brian Leetch	23
TheGeneral	99	Nels Stewart	22
TheGeneral	100	Clint Benedict	21
TheGeneral	101	Henrik Zetterberg	20
TheGeneral	102	Billy Smith	19
TheGeneral	103	Grant Fuhr	18
TheGeneral	104	Pierre Pilote	17
TheGeneral	105	Dit Clapper	16
TheGeneral	106	Henrik Lundqvist	15
TheGeneral	107	Earl Seibert	14
TheGeneral	108	Mark Howe	13
TheGeneral	109	Bernie Parent	12
TheGeneral	110	Luc Robitaille	11
TheGeneral	111	Rod Langway	10
TheGeneral	112	Serge Savard	9
TheGeneral	113	Russell Bowie	8
TheGeneral	114	Valeri Vasiliev	7
TheGeneral	115	Zdeno Chara	6
TheGeneral	116	Syl Apps	5
TheGeneral	117	Vladimir Petrov	4
TheGeneral	118	Bill Gadsby	3
TheGeneral	119	Shea Weber	2
TheGeneral	120	Pat LaFontaine	1
Voter	Rank	Player	Points		1		2
The Macho Man	1	Wayne Gretzky	120	1	Wayne Gretzky	1	Bobby Hull
The Macho Man	2	Bobby Orr	119	2	Bobby Orr	2	Jean Beliveau
The Macho Man	3	Gordie Howe	118	3	Gordie Howe	3	Ray Bourque
The Macho Man	4	Mario Lemieux	117	4	Mario Lemieux	4	Patrick Roy
The Macho Man	5	Maurice Richard	116	5	Doug Harvey	5	Doug Harvey
The Macho Man	6	Jean Beliveau	115	6	Jean Beliveau	6	Dominik Hasek
The Macho Man	7	Bobby Hull	114	7	Bobby Hull	7	Eddie Shore
The Macho Man	8	Dominik Hasek	113	8	Patrick Roy	8	Howie Morenz
The Macho Man	9	Ray Bourque	112	9	Ray Bourque	9	Sidney Crosby
The Macho Man	10	Doug Harvey	111	10	Maurice Richard	10	Maurice Richard
The Macho Man	11	Howie Morenz	110		3		4
The Macho Man	12	Patrick Roy	109	1	Ray Bourque	1	Denis Potvin
The Macho Man	13	Eddie Shore	108	2	Eddie Shore	2	Nicklas Lidstrom
The Macho Man	14	Stan Mikita	107	3	Dominik Hasek	3	Mark Messier
The Macho Man	15	Denis Potvin	106	4	Sidney Crosby	4	Frank Nighbor
The Macho Man	16	Guy Lafleur	105	5	Howie Morenz	5	Red Kelly
The Macho Man	17	Frank Nighbor	104	6	Denis Potvin	6	Phil Esposito
The Macho Man	18	Jacques Plante	103	7	Mark Messier	7	Guy Lafleur
The Macho Man	19	Red Kelly	102	8	Jacques Plante	8	Jacques Plante
The Macho Man	20	Phil Esposito	101	9	Nicklas Lidstrom	9	Jaromir Jagr
The Macho Man	21	Bobby Clarke	100	10	Jaromir Jagr	10	Stan Mikita
The Macho Man	22	Nicklas Lidstrom	99		5		6
The Macho Man	23	Terry Sawchuk	98	1	Frank Nighbor	1	Phil Esposito
The Macho Man	24	Sidney Crosby	97	2	Phil Esposito	2	Viacheslav Fetisov
The Macho Man	25	Glenn Hall	96	3	Mark Messier	3	Glenn Hall
The Macho Man	26	Viacheslav Fetisov	95	4	Viacheslav Fetisov	4	Bryan Trottier
The Macho Man	27	Bryan Trottier	94	5	Guy Lafleur	5	Bobby Clarke
The Macho Man	28	Alex Ovechkin	93	6	Stan Mikita	6	Cyclone Taylor
The Macho Man	29	Mark Messier	92	7	Glenn Hall	7	Martin Brodeur
The Macho Man	30	Mike Bossy	91	8	Alex Ovechkin	8	Sergei Makarov
The Macho Man	31	Newsy Lalonde	90	9	Martin Brodeur	9	Mike Bossy
The Macho Man	32	Valeri Kharlamov	89	10	Bobby Clarke	10	Joe Sakic
The Macho Man	33	Larry Robinson	88		7		8
The Macho Man	34	Milt Schmidt	87	1	Bryan Trottier	1	Larry Robinson
The Macho Man	35	Pierre Pilote	86	2	Martin Brodeur	2	Mike Bossy
The Macho Man	36	Jaromir Jagr	85	3	Bill Cook	3	Chris Chelios
The Macho Man	37	Martin Brodeur	84	4	Larry Robinson	4	Newsy Lalonde
The Macho Man	38	Joe Sakic	83	5	Cyclone Taylor	5	Terry Sawchuk
The Macho Man	39	Steve Yzerman	82	6	Joe Sakic	6	Steve Yzerman
The Macho Man	40	Brad Park	81	7	Mike Bossy	7	Ted Lindsay
The Macho Man	41	Syl Apps	80	8	Newsy Lalonde	8	Brad Park
The Macho Man	42	Ted Lindsay	79	9	Steve Yzerman	9	Ken Dryden
The Macho Man	43	Cyclone Taylor	78	10	Terry Sawchuk	10	Paul Coffey
The Macho Man	44	Ken Dryden	77		9		10
The Macho Man	45	Chris Chelios	76	1	Chris Chelios	1	Charlie Conacher
The Macho Man	46	Bill Cook	75	2	Valeri Kharlamov	2	Brad Park
The Macho Man	47	Vladislav Tretiak	74	3	King Clancy	3	Pierre Pilote
The Macho Man	48	Bill Durnan	73	4	Frank Boucher	4	Syl Apps
The Macho Man	49	Charlie Conacher	72	5	Charlie Conacher	5	Milt Schmidt
The Macho Man	50	Max Bentley	71	6	Brad Park	6	Ken Dryden
The Macho Man	51	Paul Coffey	70	7	Pierre Pilote	7	Vladislav Tretiak
The Macho Man	52	Marcel Dionne	69	8	Syl Apps	8	Bernie Geoffrion
The Macho Man	53	Frank Mahovlich	68	9	Ken Dryden	9	Henri Richard
The Macho Man	54	Joe Malone	67	10	Vladislav Tretiak	10	Paul Coffey
The Macho Man	55	Dit Clapper	66		11		12
The Macho Man	56	King Clancy	65	1	Charlie Conacher	1	Charlie Conacher
The Macho Man	57	Andy Bathgate	64	2	Pierre Pilote	2	Sprague Cleghorn
The Macho Man	58	Evgeni Malkin	63	3	Evgeni Malkin	3	Frank Brimsek
The Macho Man	59	Henri Richard	62	4	Milt Schmidt	4	Bernie Geoffrion
The Macho Man	60	Frank Brimsek	61	5	Vladislav Tretiak	5	Andy Bathgate
The Macho Man	61	Tim Horton	60	6	Bernie Geoffrion	6	Chris Pronger
The Macho Man	62	Frank Boucher	59	7	Peter Forsberg	7	Earl Seibert
The Macho Man	63	Turk Broda	58	8	Frank Brimsek	8	Ted Kennedy
The Macho Man	64	Earl Seibert	57	9	Earl Seibert	9	Tim Horton
The Macho Man	65	Jari Kurri	56	10	Marcel Dionne	10	Marcel Dionne
The Macho Man	66	Bernie Geoffrion	55
The Macho Man	67	Al MacInnis	54
The Macho Man	68	Cy Denneny	53
The Macho Man	69	Nels Stewart	52
The Macho Man	70	Peter Stastny	51
The Macho Man	71	Brett Hull	50
The Macho Man	72	Boris Mikhailov	49
The Macho Man	73	Sprague Cleghorn	48
The Macho Man	74	Aurele Joliat	47
The Macho Man	75	Erik Karlsson	46
The Macho Man	76	Ted Kennedy	45
The Macho Man	77	Chris Pronger	44
The Macho Man	78	Scott Niedermayer	43
The Macho Man	79	Johnny Bower	42
The Macho Man	80	Mark Howe	41
The Macho Man	81	Sergei Makarov	40
The Macho Man	82	Bill Cowley	39
The Macho Man	83	Toe Blake	38
The Macho Man	84	Sergei Fedorov	37
The Macho Man	85	Peter Forsberg	36
The Macho Man	86	Georges Vezina	35
The Macho Man	87	George Hainsworth	34
The Macho Man	88	Borje Salming	33
The Macho Man	89	Bill Gadsby	32
The Macho Man	90	Anatoli Firsov	31
The Macho Man	91	Gilbert Perreault	30
The Macho Man	92	Teemu Selanne	29
The Macho Man	93	Martin St. Louis	28
The Macho Man	94	Serge Savard	27
The Macho Man	95	Dickie Moore	26
The Macho Man	96	Scott Stevens	25
The Macho Man	97	Dave Keon	24
The Macho Man	98	Jarome Iginla	23
The Macho Man	99	Charlie Gardiner	22
The Macho Man	100	Ron Francis	21
The Macho Man	101	Alex Delvecchio	20
The Macho Man	102	Valeri Vasiliev	19
The Macho Man	103	Norm Ullman	18
The Macho Man	104	Brian Leetch	17
The Macho Man	105	Elmer Lach	16
The Macho Man	106	Zdeno Chara	15
The Macho Man	107	Eric Lindros	14
The Macho Man	108	Henrik Lundqvist	13
The Macho Man	109	Johnny Bucyk	12
The Macho Man	110	Joe Thornton	11
The Macho Man	111	Adam Oates	10
The Macho Man	112	Jiri Holecek	9
The Macho Man	113	Mike Modano	8
The Macho Man	114	Rod Langway	7
The Macho Man	115	Vladimir Martinec	6
The Macho Man	116	Rob Blake	5
The Macho Man	117	Drew Doughty	4
The Macho Man	118	Ed Belfour	3
The Macho Man	119	Jacques Lemaire	2
The Macho Man	120	Roberto Luongo	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

Click to read more...

 

[VanIslander]

I'd never heard of these guys before, except for The Macho Man (so no belly aching about Roy Worters or Pat Lafontaine at the tail end).

TMM's list looks reasonable, except Jagr is so far down it he's almost at Syl Apps.

I like the nod to a couple of Czechoslovakians in the also-ran conversation-potential 100-120 range.

 

[DannyGallivan]

I kinda like Macho's list as well. I'd be curious if Blog of Mike could explain how Orr dropped behind Mario in the first voting round.

 

[sr edler]

Can't find a common theme in TheGeneral's list, a lot of it feels kinda random. May he stray by to explain the thought process?

 

[The Macho King]

I'd never heard of these guys before, except for The Macho Man (so no belly aching about Roy Worters or Pat Lafontaine at the tail end).

TMM's list looks reasonable, except Jagr is so far down it he's almost at Syl Apps.

I like the nod to a couple of Czechoslovakians in the also-ran conversation-potential 100-120 range.

I am really low on Jagr (probably too low, I've acknowledged). I wouldn't have him so low if I made the list again, but alas.

I don't think my list is particularly good - the past year I've studied a lot more and would have definitely placed some guys differently (more love for pre WW2 players, less love for DPE and early expansion era players, probably a push on original six and modern players).

 

[GlitchMarner]

I am really low on Jagr (probably too low, I've acknowledged). I wouldn't have him so low if I made the list again, but alas.

I don't think my list is particularly good - the past year I've studied a lot more and would have definitely placed some guys differently (more love for pre WW2 players, less love for DPE and early expansion era players, probably a push on original six and modern players).

Richard at fifth?? I thought you weren't that high on him...

 

[GlitchMarner]

Can't find a common theme in TheGeneral's list, a lot of it feels kinda random. May he stray by to explain the thought process?

Does he even post? I don't recall ever seeing a post by that member.

 

[The Macho King]

Richard at fifth?? I thought you weren't that high on him...

That was one of the big changes I'd make. My initial list, especially the top end, I just kind of went with my gut at the time. It was between the initial list and voting that I started diving deeper into some of the more obvious names.

 

[GlitchMarner]

Well, the main boards makes fun of the fact that the NHL included Toews on the Top 100 Players list it released in 2017, but two of these three participants in this project put him in the top 100.

@blogofmike: I am curious as to why you included Toews and Kopitar but not Datsyuk. It also seems weird that you included both Toews and Stamkos as they're basically total opposites. One guy is there primarily (if not entirely) because of his playoff resume and the other is there because of his regular season peak/best seasons and has an awful playoff track record compared to the greatest players of all time. Also, Malkin isn't in the top 100?

 

[Nadal On Clay]

Crosby at 48 on the 2nd list?

Malkin behind Anze Kopitar and Jonathan Toews for the 1st list (out of top 100)?

I guess that I could have participated after all.

 

[Nick Hansen]

The Macho Man with Selanne at 92:

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

I wanted to call these lists eclectic, but I don't think that's right.

Orr at 4, Messier at 7 and Jagr at 8. The General is killin' it!

 

[VMBM]

I might be wrong but it just looks that The Macho Macho Man (sorry, couldn't resist) had HOH's 2008 Top 100 list as a sort of guidance at least when ranking the Russian players. Makarov's placement below Mikhailov and well below Fetisov and Kharlamov just sticks out (negatively) on the list like a sore thumb, I'm afraid.

Makarov's huge rise in stature in the past ten years is an interesting 'phenomenon', though (as I've pointed out many times before).

 

[ChiTownPhilly]

I kinda like Macho's list as well. I'd be curious if Blog of Mike could explain how Orr dropped behind Mario in the first voting round.

I wouldn't presume to speak for the man- but when this became a topic, here was my try at a distilled reduction of the Lemieux>Orr argument:

Orr versus Lemieux in Three Acts:

Act I- ages 18 to 21-22: they're comparable. I got Orr with the edge in two years- Lemieux with the edge in two years. If ya wanna say (for the sake of argument) Orr has a slight edge (cuz his advantages are wider than Lemieux's, e.g.: playing age 21) I won't argue strenuously. Still- I'll call it comparable.

Act II- ages 21-22 to 26: it's Orr with the edge- there's daylight between them- but Lemieux is doing some historically significant things during that time, too. Also, let's not lose sight of the fact that, from age 18 to this point, Orr's building his legacy with considerably more teammate-help than Lemieux.

Act III- Orr did not provide us with an Act III. To the extent that Lemieux's career continues, he is competing against a virtually blank sheet of paper. After playing age 26, Lemieux scored 709 points. Orr scored 45.

Lemieux from age 27 onwards: 2 Harts/Pearsons (Lindsays), 3 Art Ross, 4 All-Star Teams (3x 1st). My case is- Lemieux's advantage in Act III more than offsets any disadvantages in the first two Acts.​

This argument didn't gain traction with most- but maybe it gained traction with some. I still maintain that it's a reasonable way to look at the matter.

 

[bobholly39]

BlogofMike has Malkin 110 and Dionne 55 and Brimsek 63 in round 1 - yet in the first round 2 they all 3 became eligible, he ends up voting Malkin ahead of both. Is this just a case of vastly underestimating Malkin in round 1? It's a bit surprising to come across that - because the current and more modern players are the ones we generally are most familiar with so less prone to underestimate vs just purposefully rank low, so curious about your thought process there.

I still think the distance between Ovechkin (11) and Crosby 48) in round 1 for The General is one of the worst showings in this project. I get that some people had current player biases and could buy both being low, and i get that some prefer ovechkin to Crosby so could buy a gap of 10-15 guys between them maybe - but this still makes absolutely no sense. And barring the poster actually defending his position, it just seems like it's based on an intentional dislike of one player.

Surprised MachoMan has no votes past round 12 - i thought you were still around most of the project, if less active. Cant criticize round 1 too much if you admit it was a best effort and you learned a lot throughout round 2 and would likely make changes now if you redid the list. Probably quite comparable to me overall in that sense.

 

[ImporterExporter]

I would have absolutely thrown out The Generals list.

There is zero justification for having Ovechkin at 11, Mike Bossy at 18 and Crosby 48th, behind Brett f***ing Hull....

Harvey 20th?

And then no posts that I'm aware of to argue the defense of such rankings.

 

[GlitchMarner]

For a great low rate you can get online, go to The General and save some time!

 

[VanIslander]

Were any lists thrown out?

I imagined at least one Hfboarder would've included Toews, McDavid or Price.

 

[GlitchMarner]

Were any lists thrown out?

I imagined at least one Hfboarder would've included Toews, McDavid or Price.

blogofmike and The General both included Toews.

 

[ChiTownPhilly]

Were any lists thrown out?

I imagined at least one Hfboarder would've included Toews, McDavid or Price.

The answer, of course, is in the Aggy-List... a lineup that includes well over 200 players. Toews got six mentions. McDavid got three. Carey Price got the one lonely mention at 120, which puts him in the category with Ms. Wickenheiser.

Check out this 'hit' for how relevant that is:

One drop of water added to a 95% full four-gallon container.

Ratio=1:232320.

This, gentle readers, is the value of your individual 120th selection in Round One.

I didn't have Toews in my 120... but I believe the Aggy-List has an absolute minimum of 2-dozen-plus lesser lights clearly inferior to him.

 

[Johnny Engine]

I think some of you are still misunderstanding why lists get screened.
Errors, omissions, and incomplete work. Not stupid opinions. For that purpose, trying to prove that individual participants' opinions are stupid and wrong has no bearing on the screening process.

 

[DannyGallivan]

I think some of you are still misunderstanding why lists get screened.
Errors, omissions, and incomplete work. Not stupid opinions. For that purpose, trying to prove that individual participants' opinions are stupid and wrong has no bearing on the screening process.

Omissions... not additions. But dare I say if someone had Guy Lafleur as high as sixth or Gretzky as low as sixth... or Crosby at 48, those lists are left in all their glory.

What would an error be that wasn't an omission or incompletion? Perhaps listing the same player twice.

 

[bobholly39]

Were any lists thrown out?

I imagined at least one Hfboarder would've included Toews, McDavid or Price.

I included Price at 120

I did it on purpose though. I value his peak more than most and think he may not get enough recognition all time when the time comes. Probably a bit of a biased pick but i always intended my #120 to be fully biased and meaningful 'didn't figure slot 120 would have a big effect on results one way or another. Id like to think that outside of that pick i didnt show any biases based on me liking a player better

I would have absolutely thrown out The Generals list.

There is zero justification for having Ovechkin at 11, Mike Bossy at 18 and Crosby 48th, behind Brett ****ing Hull....

Harvey 20th?

And then no posts that I'm aware of to argue the defense of such rankings.

The only one of those that makes no sense is Crosby at 48.

Im ok with all the other placements. Ovechkin, Harvey, Bossy, Hull. I even would have been ok with Crosby at 48 if Ovechkin (current player also) was slotted past 30, hence showing an active player bias.

I think the 11 vs 48 is the issue. Ovechkin at 11 in itself is fine.

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

Were any lists thrown out?

I imagined at least one Hfboarder would've included Toews, McDavid or Price.

Every list should have included McDavid.

 

[MXD]

I couldn't have guessed any of these posters.

BlogofMike's list irked me quite a bit, up until I realized it might have been rushed due to the amount of positionnal/logical clusters (I jokingly said that Kennedy and Lindsay were back to back because both were named Ted; you also have lots of D's between 27 and 32, with a string of 4 goalies separated by one skater; all players between 37 and 45 were G's and D's, and there was 4 forwards between 27 and 45, with the Top-26 being really forward-heavy). Harvey and Lidstrom rankings felt outrageous then and feel outrageous now. But otherwise, no one was missing and all areas were fairly represented. In the grand scheme of things, it's okay, but I would've been pissed if the final list ended up being so clustered.

TheGeneral actually had Crosby lower than 48th.

TheMachoMan's list? I noticed that Benedict was missing (Benedict missing with Hainsworth on the list makes no sense - it would be like, I don't know... having Shea Weber but not Zdeno Chara). Makarov was way too low in round 1, but there appears to have been a correction in round 2. I'm disappointed that this one left, considering how much shuffling there was between R1 and R2.