Voting Record - Batis, seventieslord, MXD

Discussion in 'The History of Hockey' started by quoipourquoi, Apr 23, 2019.

  1. It's phishing season. Members should beware of an email informing them their password is about to expire. You should delete it. This is a scam to steal passwords.
    Dismiss Notice
  1. quoipourquoi Goaltender

    Joined:
    Jan 26, 2009
    Messages:
    10,045
    Likes Received:
    3,962
    Trophy Points:
    201
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Location:
    Hockeytown, MI
    VoterRankPlayerPoints12
    Batis1Wayne Gretzky1201Wayne Gretzky1Jean Beliveau
    Batis2Bobby Orr1192Gordie Howe2Bobby Hull
    Batis3Gordie Howe1183Bobby Orr3Dominik Hasek
    Batis4Mario Lemieux1174Mario Lemieux4Sidney Crosby
    Batis5Dominik Hasek1165Jean Beliveau5Doug Harvey
    Batis6Jean Beliveau1156Bobby Hull6Patrick Roy
    Batis7Bobby Hull1147Doug Harvey7Maurice Richard
    Batis8Jaromir Jagr1138Maurice Richard8Ray Bourque
    Batis9Doug Harvey1129Patrick Roy9Howie Morenz
    Batis10Sidney Crosby11110Ray Bourque10Eddie Shore
    Batis11Maurice Richard11034
    Batis12Patrick Roy1091Dominik Hasek1Jaromir Jagr
    Batis13Ray Bourque1082Sidney Crosby2Nicklas Lidstrom
    Batis14Sergei Makarov1073Jaromir Jagr3Jacques Plante
    Batis15Howie Morenz1064Ray Bourque4Alex Ovechkin
    Batis16Nicklas Lidstrom1055Howie Morenz5Stan Mikita
    Batis17Jacques Plante1046Nicklas Lidstrom6Red Kelly
    Batis18Eddie Shore1037Eddie Shore7Frank Nighbor
    Batis19Viacheslav Fetisov1028Jacques Plante8Denis Potvin
    Batis20Alex Ovechkin1019Stan Mikita9Phil Esposito
    Batis21Stan Mikita10010Alex Ovechkin10Guy Lafleur
    Batis22Red Kelly9956
    Batis23Denis Potvin981Alex Ovechkin1Sergei Makarov
    Batis24Frank Nighbor972Stan Mikita2Viacheslav Fetisov
    Batis25Bobby Clarke963Viacheslav Fetisov3Phil Esposito
    Batis26Guy Lafleur954Frank Nighbor4Glenn Hall
    Batis27Phil Esposito945Phil Esposito5Bobby Clarke
    Batis28Mark Messier936Guy Lafleur6Cyclone Taylor
    Batis29Glenn Hall927Mark Messier7Joe Sakic
    Batis30Terry Sawchuk918Bobby Clarke8Martin Brodeur
    Batis31Cyclone Taylor909Glenn Hall9Bryan Trottier
    Batis32Joe Sakic8910Martin Brodeur10Terry Sawchuk
    Batis33Bill Cook8878
    Batis34Bryan Trottier871Cyclone Taylor1Newsy Lalonde
    Batis35Martin Brodeur862Bill Cook2Terry Sawchuk
    Batis36Newsy Lalonde853Martin Brodeur3Ted Lindsay
    Batis37Steve Yzerman844Joe Sakic4Mike Bossy
    Batis38Mike Bossy835Newsy Lalonde5Steve Yzerman
    Batis39Ted Lindsay826Bryan Trottier6Chris Chelios
    Batis40Syl Apps817Terry Sawchuk7Larry Robinson
    Batis41Larry Robinson808Mike Bossy8Paul Coffey
    Batis42Chris Chelios799Ted Lindsay9Ken Dryden
    Batis43Anatoli Firsov7810Steve Yzerman10Brad Park
    Batis44Valeri Kharlamov77910
    Batis45Evgeni Malkin761Chris Chelios1Syl Apps
    Batis46Frank Boucher752Syl Apps2Vladislav Tretiak
    Batis47Ken Dryden743Valeri Kharlamov3Peter Forsberg
    Batis48Charlie Conacher734Frank Boucher4Paul Coffey
    Batis49Bernie Geoffrion725Vladislav Tretiak5Ken Dryden
    Batis50Vladislav Tretiak716Paul Coffey6Charlie Conacher
    Batis51Brad Park707King Clancy7Bernie Geoffrion
    Batis52Peter Forsberg698Ken Dryden8Henri Richard
    Batis53Henri Richard689Charlie Conacher9Milt Schmidt
    Batis54Milt Schmidt6710Henri Richard10Brad Park
    Batis55Frank Brimsek661112
    Batis56Paul Coffey651Vladislav Tretiak1Charlie Conacher
    Batis57King Clancy642Evgeni Malkin2Bernie Geoffrion
    Batis58Pierre Pilote633Peter Forsberg3Frank Brimsek
    Batis59Marcel Dionne624Charlie Conacher4Chris Pronger
    Batis60Georges Vezina615Bernie Geoffrion5Andy Bathgate
    Batis61Andy Bathgate606Frank Brimsek6Marcel Dionne
    Batis62Sprague Cleghorn597Milt Schmidt7Sprague Cleghorn
    Batis63Bill Durnan588Pierre Pilote8Ted Kennedy
    Batis64Charlie Gardiner579Marcel Dionne9Tim Horton
    Batis65Earl Seibert5610Earl Seibert10Earl Seibert
    Batis66Tim Horton551314
    Batis67Ted Kennedy541Bernie Geoffrion1Georges Vezina
    Batis68Clint Benedict532Georges Vezina2Tim Horton
    Batis69Teemu Selanne523Andy Bathgate3Clint Benedict
    Batis70Jiri Holecek514Marcel Dionne4Bill Durnan
    Batis71Scott Stevens505Tim Horton5Teemu Selanne
    Batis72Frank Mahovlich496Earl Seibert6Al MacInnis
    Batis73Cy Denneny487Scott Stevens7Joe Malone
    Batis74Joe Malone478Teemu Selanne8Dickie Moore
    Batis75Brett Hull469Al MacInnis9Cy Denneny
    Batis76Dickie Moore4510Frank Mahovlich10Dit Clapper
    Batis77Max Bentley441516
    Batis78Turk Broda431Anatoli Firsov1Charlie Gardiner
    Batis79Chris Pronger422Clint Benedict2Bill Durnan
    Batis80Aurele Joliat413Bill Durnan3Max Bentley
    Batis81Joe Thornton404Brett Hull4Brett Hull
    Batis82Patrick Kane395Joe Malone5Cy Denneny
    Batis83Al MacInnis386Cy Denneny6Aurele Joliat
    Batis84Martin St. Louis377Turk Broda7Turk Broda
    Batis85Elmer Lach368Dit Clapper8Jari Kurri
    Batis86Alexander Maltsev359Frank Mahovlich9Boris Mikhailov
    Batis87Jarome Iginla3410Jari Kurri10Sergei Fedorov
    Batis88Vladimir Martinec331718
    Batis89Boris Mikhailov321Bill Durnan1Bill Cowley
    Batis90Brian Leetch312Brett Hull2Zdeno Chara
    Batis91Sergei Fedorov303Turk Broda3Martin St. Louis
    Batis92Duncan Keith294Elmer Lach4Duncan Keith
    Batis93Bill Cowley285Borje Salming5Ed Belfour
    Batis94Bill Gadsby276Nels Stewart6Nels Stewart
    Batis95Norm Ullman267Boris Mikhailov7Boris Mikhailov
    Batis96Jari Kurri258Sergei Fedorov8Brian Leetch
    Batis97Ed Belfour249Brian Leetch9Bill Gadsby
    Batis98Borje Salming2310Bill Gadsby10Sergei Fedorov
    Batis99Valeri Vasiliev221920
    Batis100Nels Stewart211Patrick Kane1Jiri Holecek
    Batis101Peter Stastny202Joe Thornton2Martin St. Louis
    Batis102Pavel Bure193Martin St. Louis3Brian Leetch
    Batis103Vladimir Krutov184Duncan Keith4Jarome Iginla
    Batis104Jan Suchy175Nels Stewart5Erik Karlsson
    Batis105Erik Karlsson166Bill Gadsby6Norm Ullman
    Batis106Sid Abel157Brian Leetch7Valeri Vasiliev
    Batis107Russell Bowie148Jarome Iginla8Mark Howe
    Batis108Drew Doughty139Norm Ullman9Russell Bowie
    Batis109Dit Clapper1210Valeri Vasiliev10Peter Stastny
    Batis110Toe Blake1121
    Batis111Eddie Gerard101Alexander Maltsev
    Batis112Tony Esposito92Vladimir Martinec
    Batis113Busher Jackson83Jiri Holecek
    Batis114Mark Howe74Jarome Iginla
    Batis115Bill Quackenbush65Erik Karlsson
    Batis116Dave Keon56Norm Ullman
    Batis117Doug Bentley47Valeri Vasiliev
    Batis118Zdeno Chara38Russell Bowie
    Batis119Roy Worters29Peter Stastny
    Batis120Henrik Lundqvist110Sid Abel
    VoterRankPlayerPoints12
    seventieslord1Wayne Gretzky1201Wayne Gretzky1Patrick Roy
    seventieslord2Gordie Howe1192Gordie Howe2Jean Beliveau
    seventieslord3Bobby Orr1183Bobby Orr3Doug Harvey
    seventieslord4Mario Lemieux1174Mario Lemieux4Ray Bourque
    seventieslord5Doug Harvey1165Doug Harvey5Bobby Hull
    seventieslord6Jean Beliveau1156Jean Beliveau6Sidney Crosby
    seventieslord7Patrick Roy1147Bobby Hull7Eddie Shore
    seventieslord8Ray Bourque1138Patrick Roy8Howie Morenz
    seventieslord9Sidney Crosby1129Ray Bourque9Maurice Richard
    seventieslord10Eddie Shore11110Maurice Richard10Dominik Hasek
    seventieslord11Bobby Hull11034
    seventieslord12Dominik Hasek1091Ray Bourque1Jacques Plante
    seventieslord13Jacques Plante1082Sidney Crosby2Stan Mikita
    seventieslord14Maurice Richard1073Eddie Shore3Frank Nighbor
    seventieslord15Jaromir Jagr1064Stan Mikita4Mark Messier
    seventieslord16Nicklas Lidstrom1055Howie Morenz5Jaromir Jagr
    seventieslord17Stan Mikita1046Jacques Plante6Nicklas Lidstrom
    seventieslord18Guy Lafleur1037Jaromir Jagr7Red Kelly
    seventieslord19Howie Morenz1028Dominik Hasek8Guy Lafleur
    seventieslord20Frank Nighbor1019Mark Messier9Denis Potvin
    seventieslord21Mark Messier10010Nicklas Lidstrom10Alex Ovechkin
    seventieslord22Alex Ovechkin9956
    seventieslord23Red Kelly981Frank Nighbor1Bobby Clarke
    seventieslord24Bobby Clarke972Mark Messier2Glenn Hall
    seventieslord25Joe Sakic963Stan Mikita3Sergei Makarov
    seventieslord26Sergei Makarov954Guy Lafleur4Viacheslav Fetisov
    seventieslord27Bill Cook945Bobby Clarke5Martin Brodeur
    seventieslord28Denis Potvin936Viacheslav Fetisov6Joe Sakic
    seventieslord29Glenn Hall927Glenn Hall7Phil Esposito
    seventieslord30Viacheslav Fetisov918Alex Ovechkin8Terry Sawchuk
    seventieslord31Phil Esposito909Martin Brodeur9Bryan Trottier
    seventieslord32Cyclone Taylor8910Phil Esposito10Cyclone Taylor
    seventieslord33Bryan Trottier8878
    seventieslord34Larry Robinson871Bill Cook1Terry Sawchuk
    seventieslord35Mike Bossy862Joe Sakic2Newsy Lalonde
    seventieslord36Chris Chelios853Martin Brodeur3Mike Bossy
    seventieslord37Martin Brodeur844Terry Sawchuk4Larry Robinson
    seventieslord38Brad Park835Bryan Trottier5Chris Chelios
    seventieslord39Newsy Lalonde826Newsy Lalonde6Steve Yzerman
    seventieslord40Frank Boucher817Larry Robinson7Brad Park
    seventieslord41King Clancy808Mike Bossy8Ted Lindsay
    seventieslord42Terry Sawchuk799Cyclone Taylor9Ken Dryden
    seventieslord43Steve Yzerman7810Steve Yzerman10Paul Coffey
    seventieslord44Henri Richard77910
    seventieslord45Paul Coffey761Chris Chelios1Brad Park
    seventieslord46Sprague Cleghorn752Frank Boucher2Henri Richard
    seventieslord47Ted Lindsay743King Clancy3Ken Dryden
    seventieslord48Charlie Conacher734Brad Park4Syl Apps
    seventieslord49Pierre Pilote725Henri Richard5Vladislav Tretiak
    seventieslord50Earl Seibert716Ken Dryden6Peter Forsberg
    seventieslord51Tim Horton707Syl Apps7Charlie Conacher
    seventieslord52Bernie Geoffrion698Vladislav Tretiak8Milt Schmidt
    seventieslord53Scott Stevens689Charlie Conacher9Paul Coffey
    seventieslord54Syl Apps6710Paul Coffey10Pierre Pilote
    seventieslord55Milt Schmidt661112
    seventieslord56Ken Dryden651Vladislav Tretiak1Frank Brimsek
    seventieslord57Chris Pronger642Frank Brimsek2Sprague Cleghorn
    seventieslord58Al MacInnis633Peter Forsberg3Charlie Conacher
    seventieslord59Frank Brimsek624Charlie Conacher4Earl Seibert
    seventieslord60Erik Karlsson615Milt Schmidt5Tim Horton
    seventieslord61Valeri Kharlamov606Pierre Pilote6Ted Kennedy
    seventieslord62Andy Bathgate597Evgeni Malkin7Chris Pronger
    seventieslord63Marcel Dionne588Earl Seibert8Marcel Dionne
    seventieslord64Peter Forsberg579Marcel Dionne9Bernie Geoffrion
    seventieslord65Ted Kennedy5610Bernie Geoffrion10Andy Bathgate
    seventieslord66Evgeni Malkin551314
    seventieslord67Bill Gadsby541Earl Seibert1Tim Horton
    seventieslord68Borje Salming532Scott Stevens2Georges Vezina
    seventieslord69Dit Clapper523Tim Horton3Al MacInnis
    seventieslord70Vladislav Tretiak514Al MacInnis4Clint Benedict
    seventieslord71Teemu Selanne505Marcel Dionne5Cy Denneny
    seventieslord72Frank Mahovlich496Georges Vezina6Dickie Moore
    seventieslord73Cy Denneny487Bernie Geoffrion7Dit Clapper
    seventieslord74Norm Ullman478Andy Bathgate8Frank Mahovlich
    seventieslord75Elmer Lach469Frank Mahovlich9Joe Malone
    seventieslord76Bill Cowley4510Teemu Selanne10Teemu Selanne
    seventieslord77Nels Stewart441516
    seventieslord78Dickie Moore431Clint Benedict1Cy Denneny
    seventieslord79Georges Vezina422Cy Denneny2Charlie Gardiner
    seventieslord80Bill Quackenbush413Anatoli Firsov3Jari Kurri
    seventieslord81Clint Benedict404Frank Mahovlich4Brett Hull
    seventieslord82Charlie Gardiner395Dit Clapper5Max Bentley
    seventieslord83Aurele Joliat386Joe Malone6Aurele Joliat
    seventieslord84Roy Worters377Jari Kurri7Sergei Fedorov
    seventieslord85Valeri Vasiliev368Brett Hull8Boris Mikhailov
    seventieslord86Mark Howe359Turk Broda9Turk Broda
    seventieslord87Joe Thornton3410Bill Durnan10Bill Durnan
    seventieslord88Joe Malone331718
    seventieslord89Max Bentley321Brett Hull1Nels Stewart
    seventieslord90Jari Kurri312Borje Salming2Bill Cowley
    seventieslord91Duncan Keith303Nels Stewart3Ed Belfour
    seventieslord92Brian Leetch294Sergei Fedorov4Zdeno Chara
    seventieslord93Eddie Gerard285Elmer Lach5Sergei Fedorov
    seventieslord94Doug Gilmour276Boris Mikhailov6Boris Mikhailov
    seventieslord95Sergei Fedorov267Bill Gadsby7Bill Gadsby
    seventieslord96Boris Mikhailov258Turk Broda8Brian Leetch
    seventieslord97Zdeno Chara249Bill Durnan9Duncan Keith
    seventieslord98Drew Doughty2310Brian Leetch10Martin St. Louis
    seventieslord99Brett Hull22
    seventieslord100Serge Savard21
    seventieslord101Jarome Iginla20
    seventieslord102Ed Belfour19
    seventieslord103Tony Esposito18
    seventieslord104Toe Blake17
    seventieslord105Guy Lapointe16
    seventieslord106Bill Durnan15
    seventieslord107Anatoli Firsov14
    seventieslord108Patrick Kane13
    seventieslord109Martin St. Louis12
    seventieslord110Sid Abel1121
    seventieslord111Dave Keon101Norm Ullman
    seventieslord112Rod Langway92Doug Gilmour
    seventieslord113Turk Broda83Jarome Iginla
    seventieslord114Tommy Phillips74Tony Esposito
    seventieslord115Busher Jackson65Erik Karlsson
    seventieslord116Bernie Parent56Vladimir Martinec
    seventieslord117Ching Johnson47Alexander Maltsev
    seventieslord118Doug Bentley38Sid Abel
    seventieslord119Jack Stewart29Serge Savard
    seventieslord120Syd Howe110Toe Blake
    VoterRankPlayerPoints12
    MXD1Wayne Gretzky1201Wayne Gretzky1Patrick Roy
    MXD2Bobby Orr1192Bobby Orr2Doug Harvey
    MXD3Gordie Howe1183Gordie Howe3Jean Beliveau
    MXD4Mario Lemieux1174Mario Lemieux4Bobby Hull
    MXD5Doug Harvey1165Doug Harvey5Maurice Richard
    MXD6Jean Beliveau1156Jean Beliveau6Dominik Hasek
    MXD7Patrick Roy1147Patrick Roy7Ray Bourque
    MXD8Bobby Hull1138Bobby Hull8Sidney Crosby
    MXD9Maurice Richard1129Maurice Richard9Howie Morenz
    MXD10Dominik Hasek11110Ray Bourque10Eddie Shore
    MXD11Jacques Plante11034
    MXD12Sidney Crosby1091Dominik Hasek1Jacques Plante
    MXD13Ray Bourque1082Ray Bourque2Nicklas Lidstrom
    MXD14Nicklas Lidstrom1073Sidney Crosby3Denis Potvin
    MXD15Jaromir Jagr1064Howie Morenz4Jaromir Jagr
    MXD16Howie Morenz1055Jacques Plante5Mark Messier
    MXD17Martin Brodeur1046Nicklas Lidstrom6Red Kelly
    MXD18Denis Potvin1037Eddie Shore7Alex Ovechkin
    MXD19Mark Messier1028Denis Potvin8Stan Mikita
    MXD20Sergei Makarov1019Jaromir Jagr9Frank Nighbor
    MXD21Red Kelly10010Mark Messier10Guy Lafleur
    MXD22Alex Ovechkin9956
    MXD23Glenn Hall981Martin Brodeur1Martin Brodeur
    MXD24Eddie Shore972Glenn Hall2Sergei Makarov
    MXD25Stan Mikita963Mark Messier3Glenn Hall
    MXD26Bobby Clarke954Stan Mikita4Bobby Clarke
    MXD27Guy Lafleur945Alex Ovechkin5Viacheslav Fetisov
    MXD28Larry Robinson936Bobby Clarke6Mike Bossy
    MXD29Ken Dryden927Frank Nighbor7Joe Sakic
    MXD30Viacheslav Fetisov918Guy Lafleur8Phil Esposito
    MXD31Frank Nighbor909Viacheslav Fetisov9Bryan Trottier
    MXD32Bill Cook8910Phil Esposito10Terry Sawchuk
    MXD33Chris Chelios8878
    MXD34Mike Bossy871Martin Brodeur1Ken Dryden
    MXD35King Clancy862Larry Robinson2Larry Robinson
    MXD36Joe Sakic853Bill Cook3Mike Bossy
    MXD37Charlie Conacher844Mike Bossy4Chris Chelios
    MXD38Phil Esposito835Joe Sakic5Ted Lindsay
    MXD39Ted Lindsay826Bryan Trottier6Newsy Lalonde
    MXD40Bryan Trottier817Ted Lindsay7Terry Sawchuk
    MXD41Terry Sawchuk808Newsy Lalonde8Steve Yzerman
    MXD42Newsy Lalonde799Cyclone Taylor9Brad Park
    MXD43Charlie Gardiner7810Steve Yzerman10Paul Coffey
    MXD44Steve Yzerman77910
    MXD45Pierre Pilote761Ken Dryden1Ken Dryden
    MXD46Cyclone Taylor752Chris Chelios2Charlie Conacher
    MXD47Georges Vezina743King Clancy3Pierre Pilote
    MXD48Tim Horton734Charlie Conacher4Brad Park
    MXD49Frank Boucher725Frank Boucher5Henri Richard
    MXD50Clint Benedict716Pierre Pilote6Syl Apps
    MXD51Brad Park707Henri Richard7Bernie Geoffrion
    MXD52Henri Richard698Brad Park8Milt Schmidt
    MXD53Frank Brimsek689Syl Apps9Paul Coffey
    MXD54Anatoli Firsov6710Valeri Kharlamov10Peter Forsberg
    MXD55Evgeni Malkin661112
    MXD56Bernie Geoffrion651Charlie Conacher1Charlie Conacher
    MXD57Sprague Cleghorn642Frank Brimsek2Frank Brimsek
    MXD58Bill Durnan633Pierre Pilote3Tim Horton
    MXD59Syl Apps624Evgeni Malkin4Sprague Cleghorn
    MXD60Valeri Kharlamov615Milt Schmidt5Bernie Geoffrion
    MXD61Andy Bathgate606Bernie Geoffrion6Earl Seibert
    MXD62Turk Broda597Earl Seibert7Chris Pronger
    MXD63Earl Seibert588Marcel Dionne8Andy Bathgate
    MXD64Duncan Keith579Peter Forsberg9Ted Kennedy
    MXD65Ed Belfour5610Vladislav Tretiak10Frank Mahovlich
    MXD66Milt Schmidt551314
    MXD67Al MacInnis541Georges Vezina1Georges Vezina
    MXD68Frank Mahovlich532Tim Horton2Clint Benedict
    MXD69Paul Coffey523Bernie Geoffrion3Tim Horton
    MXD70Tony Esposito514Earl Seibert4Al MacInnis
    MXD71Marcel Dionne505Andy Bathgate5Bill Durnan
    MXD72Teemu Selanne496Al MacInnis6Teemu Selanne
    MXD73Henrik Lundqvist487Scott Stevens7Dickie Moore
    MXD74Peter Forsberg478Marcel Dionne8Frank Mahovlich
    MXD75Dickie Moore469Frank Mahovlich9Cy Denneny
    MXD76Roy Worters4510Teemu Selanne10Joe Malone
    MXD77Cy Denneny441516
    MXD78Vladislav Tretiak431Clint Benedict1Charlie Gardiner
    MXD79Jiri Holecek422Anatoli Firsov2Bill Durnan
    MXD80Aurele Joliat413Bill Durnan3Turk Broda
    MXD81Ted Kennedy404Turk Broda4Aurele Joliat
    MXD82Martin St. Louis395Frank Mahovlich5Max Bentley
    MXD83Roberto Luongo386Cy Denneny6Cy Denneny
    MXD84Borje Salming377Jari Kurri7Jari Kurri
    MXD85Chris Pronger368Brett Hull8Brett Hull
    MXD86Russell Bowie359Joe Malone9Boris Mikhailov
    MXD87Zdeno Chara3410Dit Clapper10Sergei Fedorov
    MXD88Bernie Parent331718
    MXD89Joe Thornton321Bill Durnan1Duncan Keith
    MXD90Boris Mikhailov312Turk Broda2Ed Belfour
    MXD91Scott Stevens303Borje Salming3Martin St. Louis
    MXD92Johnny Bower294Brett Hull4Zdeno Chara
    MXD93Patrick Kane285Boris Mikhailov5Boris Mikhailov
    MXD94Mark Howe276Elmer Lach6Bill Gadsby
    MXD95Jari Kurri267Bill Gadsby7Bill Cowley
    MXD96Brett Hull258Sergei Fedorov8Eric Lindros
    MXD97Elmer Lach249Nels Stewart9Sergei Fedorov
    MXD98Valeri Vasiliev2310Brian Leetch10Nels Stewart
    MXD99Bill Gadsby221920
    MXD100Eddie Gerard211Duncan Keith1Martin St. Louis
    MXD101Max Bentley202Martin St. Louis2Mark Howe
    MXD102Alexander Maltsev193Mark Howe3Jiri Holecek
    MXD103Hugh Lehman184Patrick Kane4Russell Bowie
    MXD104Norm Ullman175Joe Thornton5Tony Esposito
    MXD105Drew Doughty166Tony Esposito6Erik Karlsson
    MXD106Erik Karlsson157Erik Karlsson7Serge Savard
    MXD107Joe Malone148Serge Savard8Eddie Gerard
    MXD108Toe Blake139Eddie Gerard9Sid Abel
    MXD109Vladimir Martinec1210Sid Abel10Norm Ullman
    MXD110Bill Quackenbush1121
    MXD111Bill Cowley101Jiri Holecek
    MXD112Guy Lapointe92Russell Bowie
    MXD113Sid Abel83Tony Esposito
    MXD114Serge Savard74Vladimir Martinec
    MXD115Jarome Iginla65Erik Karlsson
    MXD116Sergei Fedorov56Serge Savard
    MXD117Doug Gilmour47Eddie Gerard
    MXD118Nels Stewart38Sid Abel
    MXD119Dave Keon29Norm Ullman
    MXD120Dit Clapper110Toe Blake
     
    Bear of Bad News likes this.
  2. Dirt 101 Dirt, the famous Nevada railway cat

    Joined:
    Sep 4, 2004
    Messages:
    32,268
    Likes Received:
    4,863
    Trophy Points:
    232
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Occupation:
    Teacher
    Hall before Fetisov, Esposito and Taylor?

    Dang, I value Glenn Hall highly, but ahead of those guys in hockey history? That would be one interesting hockey book to read.
     
  3. MXD Original #4

    Joined:
    Oct 27, 2005
    Messages:
    42,561
    Likes Received:
    6,017
    Trophy Points:
    231
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Occupation:
    Dead
    1 - Are you replying to me or to Seventieslord? We both had Hall ahead of Fetisov, Esposito and Taylor.

    2 - Fetisov, Esposito and Taylor were ranked, respectively, 25th, 27th and 33rd. Hall was ranked 28th. Since they were close, Hall was bound to be ranked ahead of Fetisov and Esposito by a more than just a few participants, and Hall actually ended up AHEAD of Taylor.
     
    seventieslord likes this.
  4. sr edler whom

    Joined:
    Mar 20, 2010
    Messages:
    9,787
    Likes Received:
    3,845
    Trophy Points:
    171
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Those are solid/safe/boring lists (yeah, boring is kinda a compliment in this context, depending on sub-context).

    @seventieslord Karlsson at 60 and in front of Forsberg?
     
  5. MXD Original #4

    Joined:
    Oct 27, 2005
    Messages:
    42,561
    Likes Received:
    6,017
    Trophy Points:
    231
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Occupation:
    Dead
    I had a hunch @Batis was the author of that list and @seventieslord was a likely author of that one.

    My comments were "Great" and "Boring".

    As for my list, well, I was surprised having a "HIGH RANK" at all, and had I been told I was the highest on three players, I would've guessed something like Charlie Gardiner, Duncan Keith and one of Georges Vezina/Henrik Lundqvist.

    Certainly not on a Maple Leafs Trifecta.

    Also featured one of the most embarassing "omission", as Aurele Joliat was conpicuously missing.
     
    Last edited: Apr 23, 2019
  6. seventieslord Student Of The Game

    Joined:
    Mar 16, 2006
    Messages:
    33,764
    Likes Received:
    3,045
    Trophy Points:
    186
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Location:
    Regina, SK
    Yeah, later on in the project I realized that I greatly over shot on Karlsson. I actually don't know what was going through my head there. I do recall in a recent ATD somebody took him around that spot and actually did a great job of defending the pick and I started to really believe he belongs up in that tier, but in the end when it came down to comparisons to other players I just couldn't justify it.
     
  7. DannyGallivan Your world frightens and confuses me

    Joined:
    Aug 25, 2017
    Messages:
    5,274
    Likes Received:
    4,712
    Trophy Points:
    111
    SB Cash:
    $ 50,000
    Location:
    Melonville
    You mentioned that MXD the forum member was not that high on my list. Yet, I see that we're not far off at all on a lot of key players (Guy Lafleur aside...:) )

    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Apr 23, 2019

Share This Page

Presented in Association with the Society for International Hockey Research
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice
monitoring_string = "358c248ada348a047a4b9bb27a146148"