A first pairing Dman or a third pairing Dman? Difficult question but i'll take the first pairing guy.
Weber for me. Ask me a year ago, and I'd have said Vlasic. Both are overpaid, but Weber is a better two way player and currently a better foundational piece. Vlasic is not himself. He needs to get it together or I'd happily ship him out. Can't believe I've said that, as one of his biggest fans the last 5 years.
Weber was better for a long period of time, Weber declined notably around 2015-2016 and Vlasic had the edge, but Vlasic has recently fallen off a cliff and Weber is currently much better.
A first pairing Dman or a third pairing Dman? Difficult question but i'll take the first pairing guy.