Chili said:
My opinion is always based on what I actually saw of the player. Fetisov was a heckuva player at both ends of the ice, a true hall of famer. Krutov got his chance in the NHL but literally ate himself out of the league.
Makarov had a fine career and deserves to be in the IIHF hall of fame (if he isn't there all ready). What I saw of him personally though, he didn't reach the level of domination against the best. That is not to knock him, there are alot of very good players not in the hall. I'm sure he has other supporters, I just don't rate him with the best I have seen play.
On the others you mentioned, Clark Gillies was a surprise selection for me. His team's success was obviously a big factor in what got him there. Federko was a borderline choice but he played in the shadows of the great centers of his era. I saw alot of Mullen so I am biased for him. He seemed to be able to raise the level of his game when it mattered most (i.e. he had great playoffs to help two different teams win their first cups).
A guy like Pete Mahovlich was one of my favorite players but he'll never make the hall. He was dominant but for a short period of time. The players who make it usually have a level of excellent play over several years.
Mullen, Gillies and Federko where never dominant players.
Krutov and Makarov like Fetisov wouldn't be inducted for their play in the NHL, but what they did on the world stage.
If you have the ability to go back and watch games from the 1987 Canada Cup, i'd highly recomend it. IMO it's the best hockey that's ever been played, with the Soviets led by Fetisov, Makarov and Krutov extending Canada to the brink.
1987 Canada Cup Leading Scorers
Wayne Gretzky Canada 9 3 18 21
Mario Lemieux Canada 9 11 7 18
Sergei Makarov USSR 9 7 8 15
Vladimir Krutov USSR 9 7 7 14
All Star Team
G - Grant Fuhr, CAN
D - Ray Bourque, CAN
D - Viacheslav Fetisov, USSR
F - Wayne Gretzky, CAN
F - Mario Lemieux, CAN
F - Vladimir Krutov, USSR
1984 Canada Cup All Star Team
G - Vladimir Myshkin, USSR
D - Paul Coffey, Can
D - Rod Langway, USA
F - Wayne Gretzky, CAN
F - Sergei Makarov, USSR
F - John Tonelli, CAN
1981 Canada Cup Scoring Leaders
Wayne Gretzky Canada 7 5 7 12
Mike Bossy Canada 7 8 3 11
Bryan Trottier Canada 7 3 8 11
Guy Lafleur Canada 7 2 9 11
Alexei Kasatonov USSR 7 1 10 11
Gilbert Perreault Canada 4 3 6 9
Sergei Makarov USSR 7 3 6 9
Sergei Shepelev USSR 7 6 2 8
Vladimir Krutov USSR 7 4 4 8
Viacheslav Fetisov USSR 7 1 7 8
Sergei Makarov
http://www.russianrocket.de/Welcome/welcome.html
Lead the Soviet League in scoring 9 times
First team all-star at the Worlds 8 times