they should get some recogniton
I know several historians who believe Carnegie should be in the Hall, though of course a few NHL players demanding it happen won't make it happen.i wish some of black NHLers demand the HHOF to include herb carnegie...even though he never played in the NHL...
Because there's a very wide gulf between what these men accomplished and what Carnegie did? Based on Carnegie's performance in the leagues he did play in, he wouldn't have been one of the best in the NHL had he played there; he would have been a good player. Fred Taylor was the dominant scorer in the PCHA for many years, when that league was the NHA/NHL's equal. They're not in the same class.if someone like cyclone taylor or anatoli tarasov, who did not play or coach in the NHL, gets into the HHOF...why not carnegie?