Proposal: Van - Mtl

[Hockey Stick]

Only way I consider giving up Gaudette is if Montreal gives us Drouin or Juulsen.

Only way I consider giving up Drouin of Juulsen is if Vancouver gives us Boeser, Horvat, Pettersson and a 1st

 

[M2Beezy]

vanvouver : -} Karl Alzner D and scherbak . Montreal :} Loui eriksson and gaudette. Both have 4 years on theirs contract. Eriksson had his best year under claude julien. Alzner is from BC.

Not a chance in hell. Gaudette aint available, unless its for Kotkaniemi then we can begin the discussion

 

[HabsWhiteKnightLOL]

Not a chance in hell. Gaudette aint available, unless its for Kotkaniemi then we can begin the discussion

lets trade a future 3rd liner for a 1st liner

makes a lot of sense

 

[Nucklehead Supreme]

Not a chance in hell. Gaudette aint available, unless its for Kotkaniemi then we can begin the discussion

I love Gaudette, but wow that is overvaluing him.

 

[Nucklehead Supreme]

Only way I consider giving up Drouin of Juulsen is if Vancouver gives us Boeser, Horvat, Pettersson and a 1st

I hope it's been made clear that the user you quoted in no way represents Canucks fans.

 

[Hockey Stick]

I hope it's been made clear that the user you quoted in no way represents Canucks fans.

I'm aware, thank you dearly. It was more directed at their dumb suggestion as opposed to nucks fans

 

[BannedFromCDC]

vanvouver : -} Karl Alzner D and scherbak . Montreal :} Loui eriksson and gaudette. Both have 4 years on theirs contract. Eriksson had his best year under claude julien. Alzner is from BC.

Fake News. Julien never coached in Dallas.

 

[Baksfamous112]

Not a chance in hell. Gaudette aint available, unless its for Kotkaniemi’s jocks strap then we can begin the discussion

Fixed it for ya.

 

[M2Beezy]

Fixed it for ya.

Fake news

 

[elitepete]

Montreal shouldn’t do that trade imo. Poehling put up better numbers in college than Mittlestadt despite being younger, he lacks some of Mittlestadt’s skill but makes up for it by being a better two way player. Poehling has a higher ceiling than Gaudette, he’s less likely to get there but at this point it’s not worth risking it from the habs side.

Poehling doesn’t hold a candle to Gaudette.

 

[elitepete]

lets trade a future 3rd liner for a 1st liner

makes a lot of sense

Just because your stupid gm took him 3rd overall doesn’t make him a 1st liner.

 

[elitepete]

Only way I consider giving up Drouin of Juulsen is if Vancouver gives us Boeser, Horvat, Pettersson and a 1st

Pettersson > Every player in Montreal

 

[Hostile Offer]

Just because your stupid gm took him 3rd overall doesn’t make him a 1st liner.

He sure as hell looks like a good pick and a future 1st liner so far.

 

[OVO16]

Kotkaniemi looks real good. I dont where the hate is coming from

 

[sharks9]

Poehling doesn’t hold a candle to Gaudette.

Just because your stupid gm took him 3rd overall doesn’t make him a 1st liner.

Pettersson > Every player in Montreal

I get that Canucks fans don't want to give up Gaudette, but statements like these are just ridiculous

 

[biturbo19]

It makes a rough sort of sense if you take Gaudette out of the equation. An overpaid bottom-pairing sort of defenceman, for an overpaid Top-9 sort of winger. But i don't think Scherbak is even enough for it to make sense for Vancouver. He'd be another in an already oversized collection of Canucks wingers who need sheltering and don't have a lot of versatility. Alzner may be cheaper than Eriksson, but it's not by nearly enough to offset the difference, and another Alzner is the last sort of defenceman the Canucks need.

 

[Todd Parchment]

Alzner :} is :] going :> nowhere :~}

 

[Dominator13]

Kotkaniemi looks real good. I dont where the hate is coming from

Ignorance.

That's where it's coming from.

 

[jfhabs]

Ignorance.

That's where it's coming from.

This guy has to be the biggest homer on HF
Hopefully for him, he's 14 and this is just a phase...

 

[jfhabs]

It makes a rough sort of sense if you take Gaudette out of the equation. An overpaid bottom-pairing sort of defenceman, for an overpaid Top-9 sort of winger. But i don't think Scherbak is even enough for it to make sense for Vancouver. He'd be another in an already oversized collection of Canucks wingers who need sheltering and don't have a lot of versatility. Alzner may be cheaper than Eriksson, but it's not by nearly enough to offset the difference, and another Alzner is the last sort of defenceman the Canucks need.

Eriksson would only take the ice time of a younger and most probably equivalent (now) winger. The extra cap and years would equal the difference between Scherbak and Gaudette imo, but I wouldn't touch it as a habs fan. I understand why you would want to give a try to Gaudette and keep him too. Both teams are rebuilding, I could see a swap of Virtanen vs Sherbak if Virtanen doesn't show any signs of improvement. Other then that, most trade won't make sense because we are both looking for the same things.

Edit : For the Virtanen swap, would mean Sherbak hasn't found is way onto our line up.

 

[Nucklehead Supreme]

Just because your stupid gm took him 3rd overall doesn’t make him a 1st liner.

Just because your too ignorant to research or watch the kid play don't make ridiculous comments like this, remember people said the same crap
about Kopitar, saying LA drafted him too high, look how he turned out, this could easily be similar and no chance in hell Gaudette gets us
anywhere close to getting him.

 

[ole ole]

Just because your stupid gm took him 3rd overall doesn’t make him a 1st liner.

Oh he's a first liner all right.Anyone with a half of brain can see that.

 

[TeddyBare]

Only way I consider giving up Gaudette is if Montreal gives us Drouin or Juulsen.

Drastically different players value wise.

 

[Horse McHindu]

Oh he's a first liner all right.Anyone with a half of brain can see that.

First liner on an AHL team perhaps.

 

[RandV]

Gaudette doesn't have the defensive acumen to beat out Sutter. We're developing him for now. And Gaudette doesn't have the offensive acumen to beat out Pettersson. Whereas Montreal's view on centers is known league wide.
24 games does not make him a better prospect, nor do i think their ceilings are different. They're very similar prospects. Gaudette will be fine. There's no rush.

Danault, Kotkaniemie, Domi, and Peca... would Gaudette really beat out any of those guys on Montreal?

I mean I like Gaudette but after his initial pro-start and first training camp I'd think we need to dial back the expectations a bit until he shows something at the pro level.