Olympics: USA Roster Discussion (Roster in post 1)

Xokkeu

Registered User
Apr 5, 2012
6,891
193
Frozen
Every time they showed Granato on screen he always looked clueless and rarely was he saying anything to the guys on the bench. It seemed like he was in over his head. Hopefully they find a better coaching staff for the next Olympic games.

The PP was atrocious and always seemed rushed last night. The only real threat the whole tournament was Donato's spin move from the goal line. If they were going to try and feed Wiz/Bourque/Sanguinetti from the point or the circle they needed to get more traffic in front.

LOL But we had Pierre talking up Granato as a brilliant coach for putting Slater out to take defensive draws!!!!!!
 

Unspecified

¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Apr 29, 2015
6,106
2,980
Amazing that some of these players played/will play in the NHL should give most spares hope they can to reach mediocrity.
 

Xokkeu

Registered User
Apr 5, 2012
6,891
193
Frozen
Amazing that some of these players played/will play in the NHL should give most spares hope they can to reach mediocrity.

Only Terry and Donato have reasonable hopes of future NHL careers. Brian Gionta is the oldest American Olympic athlete so the ancient relic doesn't count. Jim Slater had a good career, he's just 35 now. The rest are has beens or never was. Undrafted: Chad Billins, Brian O'Neill, Broc Little, Bobby Butler, Ryan Gunderson, Mark Arcobello, Matt Gilroy, Ryan Zapolski,


Most of the rest were 4th plus round draft picks. Brandon Maxwell the only drafted goalie. Blum, Stoa, Sanguinetti, Chris Bourque, Noah Welch the only first two round picks. And Welch was drafted in 2001!

Will Borgen basically wasn't on the team so whatever, but honestly if anything this tournament made me question whether Jordan Greenway is a legitimate NHL prospect or not
 

Beltv

Registered User
Apr 13, 2017
441
51
If the NHL decides sooner that their players won't be allowed to participate...Could we roster a better team? If the whole team was college kids do we compete for gold?
 

William H Bonney

Registered User
Feb 27, 2002
24,472
6,299
Colorado
I mean didn't Arcobello just lead the Swiss league in points? He's not very good but I would have picked him. I guess Mccarthy is supposed to be a good penalty killer? Jim Slater. Okay whatever maybe they are useful pieces. Now Bobby Butler, Broc Little, Garrett Roe?? Did those guys kill a penalty or do ANYTHING? I think they had two goals. That said I don't think they were even the worst line.

Pretty sure that the Bourque, Gionta, Greenway line had 3 points. TOTAL. And two of those were Bourque assists on the powerplay. I mean HOLY *********** that line had one even strength goal and no assists in five games.

IF you take out all goals that involve Donato and Terry, the US scores 3 goals in 5 games...... WOW

Meanwhile Dan Sexton is 7th in the KHL in scoring.

I mean I'm not even going to get into Gaudette and the NCAA guys but how do guys who are scoring MORE than guys in in the same league than guys that got picked??? O'Neill has 28 points in 42 KHL games this year. Stoa has 29. Sexton has 46. Did he say no????

I’m not implying that I would have left Arcobello home, but when you don’t take your highly skilled players, you end up playing a guy like Arcobello a lot and relying on him in the make-or-break shootout.

The fact that Granato stopped tinkering with his lines given what you pointed out is peak USAH coaching.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Xokkeu

Northerner

Registered User
Feb 23, 2017
1,641
374
If the NHL decides sooner that their players won't be allowed to participate...Could we roster a better team? If the whole team was college kids do we compete for gold?


The USA should always be a threat to medal. I don't care what anyone says. Using journeymen, superstars, college or otherwise. There is no excuse to not be a threat to medal always.


Our style of hockey is the problem; the coaching, if you will. They didn't look inspired. They looked tired, and yes, they didn't play as good as they should have.


But if you watch the Canada game this morning - THAT is hockey. Well-coached, hard working, or whatever it was, but they were cutting off pucks, hitting when they needed to hit. The played inspired.


Canada shouldn't have been miles ahead of USA in their performance, but they were. It was evident if you watched both teams play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: William H Bonney

Xokkeu

Registered User
Apr 5, 2012
6,891
193
Frozen
If the NHL decides sooner that their players won't be allowed to participate...Could we roster a better team? If the whole team was college kids do we compete for gold?

A full college team no but a better mix and a decent college class maybe
 

William H Bonney

Registered User
Feb 27, 2002
24,472
6,299
Colorado
The USA should always be a threat to medal. I don't care what anyone says. Using journeymen, superstars, college or otherwise. There is no excuse to not be a threat to medal always.


Our style of hockey is the problem; the coaching, if you will. They didn't look inspired. They looked tired, and yes, they didn't play as good as they should have.

Did anyone just see Granato’s intermission interview? Basically reiterates your point. He was downright giddy for a participation medal. Too many folks at the highest levels of USAH leadership (management and coaches) are just happy to participate. They don’t expect to win and they prepare accordingly. It’s an embarrassment.
 

State of Hockey

Registered User
Oct 9, 2006
13,161
462
Did anyone just see Granato’s intermission interview? Basically reiterates your point. He was downright giddy for a participation medal. Too many folks at the highest levels of USAH leadership (management and coaches) are just happy to participate. They don’t expect to win and they prepare accordingly. It’s an embarrassment.

Exactly. That was embarrassing. It was as if they were happy with the result and didn't think they could better. I nearly laughed when he said the 3-4 NCAA players was the best amount. No, it clearly was way too low, as the NCAA players starred.
 

Xokkeu

Registered User
Apr 5, 2012
6,891
193
Frozen
Exactly. That was embarrassing. It was as if they were happy with the result and didn't think they could better. I nearly laughed when he said the 3-4 NCAA players was the best amount. No, it clearly was way too low, as the NCAA players starred.

And there are NCAA players playing better than Donato and Terry
 

Northerner

Registered User
Feb 23, 2017
1,641
374
Did anyone just see Granato’s intermission interview? Basically reiterates your point. He was downright giddy for a participation medal. Too many folks at the highest levels of USAH leadership (management and coaches) are just happy to participate. They don’t expect to win and they prepare accordingly. It’s an embarrassment.


No I missed it but I don't know what to say.


I don't know a lot about Granato's coaching skill but I do know the squad just didn't perform.
 

AmericanDream

Thank you Elon!
Oct 24, 2005
36,959
26,269
Chicago Manitoba
they got as far as I thought they would..

a few other names like Gaudette, Brickley, Bellows, Lasch, Sexton and this team likely goes further...the road to the Gold wasn't that hard if you ask me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rob

NUhockey

Registered User
Jul 6, 2010
1,889
158
Boston
they got as far as I thought they would..

a few other names like Gaudette, Brickley, Bellows, Lasch, Sexton and this team likely goes further...the road to the Gold wasn't that hard if you ask me.

You'll just have to have American Dreams of Gaudette centering Donato and Terry, and wonder what could've been. :D
 

William H Bonney

Registered User
Feb 27, 2002
24,472
6,299
Colorado
Can we stop saying they did as well as they could have or they couldn’t have done better? Germany made it to the gold medal game. This tournament is an embarrassment for USAH. Three failures in the three most recent big tournaments, plus the never ending charade that is the World Championships.

It’s time to clean house at USAH.
 

Mickey the mouse

Registered User
Jun 30, 2013
1,850
505
Can we stop saying they did as well as they could have or they couldn’t have done better? Germany made it to the gold medal game. This tournament is an embarrassment for USAH. Three failures in the three most recent big tournaments, plus the never ending charade that is the World Championships.

It’s time to clean house at USAH.
Not going to happen.

Is and most likely always will be run by a combo of New England / Wisconsin
 

Engebretson

Thank you, sweet rabbit
Nov 4, 2010
10,550
437
Minnesota
Can we stop saying they did as well as they could have or they couldn’t have done better? Germany made it to the gold medal game. This tournament is an embarrassment for USAH. Three failures in the three most recent big tournaments, plus the never ending charade that is the World Championships.

It’s time to clean house at USAH.

Couldn't agree more. With no current NHLers available, they had an opportunity to get creative with the complexion of this roster and chose the predictable USAH way. This tournament should be a wake up call for USAH.
 

Xokkeu

Registered User
Apr 5, 2012
6,891
193
Frozen
Can we stop saying they did as well as they could have or they couldn’t have done better? Germany made it to the gold medal game. This tournament is an embarrassment for USAH. Three failures in the three most recent big tournaments, plus the never ending charade that is the World Championships.

It’s time to clean house at USAH.

Two parts.


This team as constructed went as far as they could reasonably be expected. Maybe they beat the Czechs and get murdered by fake Russians. But the team sucked and was made worse by bad coaching.

Second part though yeah the brass has clearly shown a cluelessness on the international stage.
 

AmericanDream

Thank you Elon!
Oct 24, 2005
36,959
26,269
Chicago Manitoba
Two parts.


This team as constructed went as far as they could reasonably be expected. Maybe they beat the Czechs and get murdered by fake Russians. But the team sucked and was made worse by bad coaching.

Second part though yeah the brass has clearly shown a cluelessness on the international stage.

I have been saying this for a long time. When we do win Gold at the WJC level, we almost do it in spite of our selection committees. Constantly leaving off names that should be there year in and year out (though last years squad I had very little to complain about). The 2014 Olympic team was just an epic embarrassment and all those involved with that team should never be asked to construct a team again.

This Olympic team really didn't have much to go with, but there clearly were some better names out there that they left off again, especially the kids. It just seems an outdated mindset and thinking when constructing these teams despite this games growth all over the country we still seem to box ourselves into corners.

The other issue is lack of elite coaching. We just do not have enough of it yet IMO. We have plenty of NHL coaches, but nobody you can really call elite in my eyes, and that trickles all the way down to what we have at college and juniors. We need better coaching overall to lead these teams, we did not get that with Granato who like others said seemed happy to get where they got - that is not good.

As for our World Championships year in and year out- many of us have been saying this but it seems as if it will never happen - keep accountability and punish those that decline. It is a simple system, you play when you are called upon and not when it seems to fit your schedule or deemed a big enough stage. Once we start letting players know if they decline this tournament and put a system in place, if and when a World Cup/Olympics comes along they will be in danger of not making the squad vs someone who has answered the call. I am fine with that 100% even if it means we take a less talented squad at times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: William H Bonney

William H Bonney

Registered User
Feb 27, 2002
24,472
6,299
Colorado
Not going to happen.

Is and most likely always will be run by a combo of New England / Wisconsin

I don't expect it to happen, but it should.

Two parts.

This team as constructed went as far as they could reasonably be expected. Maybe they beat the Czechs and get murdered by fake Russians. But the team sucked and was made worse by bad coaching.

I don't buy it. I 100% agree that the construction of the team significantly hampered the likelihood of this team having success here, but outside of Russia, none of these teams have any of their top-end players. Team USA was not unique in its challenges here, and leaving this tournament without a medal (let alone without playing for one) is a failure.

It's even bigger than the lack of a medal. It's the fact that other countries continuously do more with less. Most teams here "sucked" and most had a lot less talent than Team USA. And yet, we lost to Slovenia! Germany has 4 wins in this tournament and is in the gold medal game. Germany!

When teams that barely qualify for the top tier tournaments beat you or are playing for a medal and you're not, you certainly didn't do as well as you could have and you certainly could have done better.

I don't say that in any way to absolve USAH management from their continual boneheaded roster decisions or the fact that our last 2 Olympic head coaches played not to lose rather than to win. But most of the rosters here were ugly, and yet, here we are, again on the outside looking in.
 

AmericanDream

Thank you Elon!
Oct 24, 2005
36,959
26,269
Chicago Manitoba
another player I forgot about who I would have loved to see on this team - Steve Moses

he played in the AHL this year but went to the KHL - maybe thats why they didn't bring him..I dont know.
 

adsfan

#164303
May 31, 2008
12,621
3,665
Milwaukee
this goalie Zapolski has put up really good stats at every level he has played especially in his last season in the ECHL which was his last season in North America when he was only 26, how come he has never been given a chance in the AHL/NHL?

Ryan Zapolski hockey statistics and profile at hockeydb.com

He was the emergency (third) playoff goalie for the Milwaukee Admirals several years ago, but he never dressed for a game to the best of my knowledge. So nobody else saw him in the AHL. Then he went to Europe for the last 5 years.
 

adsfan

#164303
May 31, 2008
12,621
3,665
Milwaukee
another player I forgot about who I would have loved to see on this team - Steve Moses

he played in the AHL this year but went to the KHL - maybe thats why they didn't bring him..I dont know.

Moses was a big star in the KHL. He scored 36 goals for Jokerit in 60 games in 2014-15. Nashville signed him and he came to Milwaukee and scored 2 goals in 16 games, which is not what the Preds expected of him. They released him. I thought that he quit on the team in Milwaukee. He went to St Petersburg and scored 10 goals in 21 games in the rest of 2015-16. The next year he scores 3 goals in 24 games for St Petersburg. Then he goes to Rochester for 17-18 and scores 7 goals in 29 games. I think he was released or suspended and he goes back to Jokerit.

Either he does not like playing in North America or he is a head case. How else do you explain his playing on two good to above average AHL teams and not finishing either season? As a Milwaukee fan, I assumed that he would get 8 to 10 games here and then move up to Nashville. I never dreamed that he would flame out. I think his career is over. All of this happened after his best season as a pro! I don't get it. He is 28, not 38.
 

adsfan

#164303
May 31, 2008
12,621
3,665
Milwaukee
Only Terry and Donato have reasonable hopes of future NHL careers. Brian Gionta is the oldest American Olympic athlete so the ancient relic doesn't count. Jim Slater had a good career, he's just 35 now. The rest are has beens or never was. Undrafted: Chad Billins, Brian O'Neill, Broc Little, Bobby Butler, Ryan Gunderson, Mark Arcobello, Matt Gilroy, Ryan Zapolski,


Most of the rest were 4th plus round draft picks. Brandon Maxwell the only drafted goalie. Blum, Stoa, Sanguinetti, Chris Bourque, Noah Welch the only first two round picks. And Welch was drafted in 2001!

Will Borgen basically wasn't on the team so whatever, but honestly if anything this tournament made me question whether Jordan Greenway is a legitimate NHL prospect or not

Gionta was on the team to give it some experience and leadership. He just retired last year after 15 NHL seasons. Bobby Butler has 130 NHL games and is a PK specialist who can score. He has 21 goals in 36 games for Milwaukee so far this season. Blum, who also played in Milwaukee from 2008-13 is not who I would have picked for this team, but he played okay. Arcobello played 139 NHL games, but after Edmonton, he was a journeyman. Some of the fans in Nashville liked him, but he only played 3 or 4 games before going to Pittsburgh in another trade by Poile.

You can't just slap a team together at the last minute. If it wasn't for Zapolski, this team would have been winless.

I predicted 5th place for the US and they didn't make the Medal Round. I sure didn't pick Germany to be playing for the Gold!
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->