Ultimate Redraft - Most Valuable Habs #2

[kingdok]

The league is in trouble! Every teams dissolves and a new league appears with 30 new owners. Every teams then proceed to draft any player available. Who, among former habs (current players or prospects) gets picked second ? Contracts carry over.

Carey Price won the first round

1- Carey Price

* change the name of the thread to clarify what I meant by "Valuable"

For this round, I pick PK Subban

Click to read more...

 

[Monctonscout]

My only question is..would contacts carry over or not

 

[PricePkPatch*]

My only question is..would contacts carry over or not

Assume you have to renegotiate everything

 

[KingTux]

Voted Price as #1, Subban as #2.

 

[kingdok]

My only question is..would contacts carry over or not

Good question that I'll put up in the OP. Answer is: Yes. Contract is part of the value of a player.

 

[Ghetto Sangria]

Pretty sure 1,2,3 is going to be Price, Subban, Patch... after that it might get interesting between chuckie, pleks, markov and gally.

 

[Binary Code]

Pretty sure 1,2,3 is going to be Price, Subban, Patch... after that it might get interesting between chuckie, pleks, markov and gally.

I don't know I would put Chuckie as 3rd ..

 

[Monctonscout]

I don't know I would put Chuckie as 3rd ..

Galchenyuk has awesome potential but Pacioretty is already an all-star. Plus h has a sweet deal...1-2-3 are no brainers

 

[Nicko999]

​

I don't know I would put Chuckie as 3rd ..

LOL

Cmon now... any fan with a little bit of knowledge know that 1-2-3 is no brainer. I would put Markov 4th and Plekanec 5th.

 

[Skip Bayless]

PK no question, close the poll.

 

[Natey]

I picked Pacioretty.

Subban is more valuable to the team, but whenever I do a fantasy draft in NHL games, I always try to steal the best players with great contacts. Pacioretty fits in that category. For building a team, I prefer depth all the way through.

 

[Nicko999]

I picked Pacioretty.

Subban is more valuable to the team, but whenever I do a fantasy draft in NHL games, I always try to steal the best players with great contacts. Pacioretty fits in that category. For building a team, I prefer depth all the way through.

Actually I think Patches is more valuable.

If we have no Subban, Markov could do an "OK" job replacing him.

If we have no Patches, we don't score goals.

 

[Natey]

​

LOL

Cmon now... any fan with a little bit of knowledge know that 1-2-3 is no brainer. I would put Markov 4th and Plekanec 5th.

Markov would go pretty low in real life. Think of this as a fantasy draft. Markov is a great piece, but he's a short term piece.

Guys like Gallagher and Galchenyuk are controllable, on great contracts, and are already good NHL players.

 

[jpchabby]

Where's the vote for Scherbak that was there in the first thread?

Seriously though it gotta be Subban... After Price, no one is as important to our team than him.

 

[higgs011]

Suivant next

 

[Jeffrey]

I voted Patches because if Subban is out for the season it's a huge blow but Markov, Beaulieu and Gilbert can cover him up.

If Pacioretty goes down who is going to score goals? Bourque?

 

[Habs 4 Life]

PK Subban

NEXT!

 

[25get]

28 years old Markov vs 25 years old PK?
20 years old Galchenyuk vs 20 years old Pacioretty?

Some seem to forget that Markov was top-10 d-men in the league for many years.

Next one is between Markov and Galchenyuk who may very well become a ppg player within two years.
Then comes Pacioretty.

 

[Habs 4 Life]

28 years old Markov vs 25 years old PK?
20 years old Galchenyuk vs 20 years old Pacioretty?

Some seem to forget that Markov was top-10 d-men in the league for many years.

Next one is between Markov and Galchenyuk who may very well become a ppg player within two years.
Then comes Pacioretty.

I think Pacioretty comes before Galchenyuk, but I totally agree with you on Markov. Take him off the team were fighting for a playoff spot, especially with the rest of the d's

 

[Ezpz]

Patches easily if contracts carry over like the OP states.

 

[ZARTONK]

PK Subban.

 

[ZARTONK]

I think the first 3-4 will be pretty unanimous.

 

[Skip Bayless]

76 votes for P.K., close thread naow.

 

[TT1]

​

LOL

Cmon now... any fan with a little bit of knowledge know that 1-2-3 is no brainer. I would put Markov 4th and Plekanec 5th.

the irony in this post

 

[Team_Spirit]

93-4-1...