Well, so far while icing all 3 of those guys, Plekanec has still been the best of them - in both directions on the ice... even/especially in the playoffs... by far, even.
and? I have a hard time understanding that because it's what the Habs have done in the passed, it should continue to be done in the future. How can so many be ready to move on from Markov, yet you are not alone in your thoughts of the utility of Plekanec.
If MB does exactly what I am most worried about, nothing to address the center position this year, then sure keeping Plekanec will be necessary as the Habs center depth is weak. However signing Markov should be a very important on MB list of things to do this summer. Saving the cap space for some fairy tale deal is stupid. Should that fairy tale come true, Plekanec is an easy drop.
Literally no one was talking about cap space as being an asset before Bergevin botched the Radulov negotiation. Everyone had admitted the premise of the argument that if we lost Radulov without a replacement, we'd be in trouble. Arguing that cap space with nothing to spend it on is an asset is the latest feat of mental gymnastics that Bergevin's mismanagement has made necessary.
I'm with you: the existential purpose of cap space is to be used on players. It should be used on the best players available, and if not used, it's wasted. Even with Markov, we were looking for a top pairing LD to play with Weber to improve our team. Radulov leaving, and Drouin coming in is likely a wash. We're supposed to be happy with losing those two for Hemsky and the prospect of maybe, someday, spending more assets on a mystery box center who even this strategy's proponents admit will not be a top center?
Is anyone really convinced by this reasoning?
It's becoming increasingly difficult to follow a team that chooses to follow a path that I believe to be one of futility. I just don't see this roster on paper and get excited. I feel that the players coming in and the players going out our not a significant upgrade. Some will point out other franchises, but I really don't care about them. I want to see a Habs GM with a clear plan to make this team better. When you listen to him talk and say Galchenyuk isn't a center... Then trades for Drouin, who is not more of a center himself, he's not big, he's not defensively responsible, he hasn't played much center in his life. So we are left with Danault and Plekanec again? I would imagine we see Galchenyuk at center because of the lack of center depth, or maybe Shaw is one of those centers. 3 centers, with a max output of maybe 40 points...
Cap space doesn't help this franchise in any way, unless they want to offer sheet someone. If he isn't offer sheeting, sign Markov ASAP.