HabsWhiteKnightLOL
Registered User
I mean that entire line had a great season above any expectation , not sure if they would do the same all together again.
Even Domi hitting 70 points was a first in his career.
Proposal: Trade Proposal Thread XXV
- Thread starter sandviper
- Start date
- Status
Even Domi hitting 70 points was a first in his career.
Kudo Shinichi
Registered User
- Apr 20, 2012
- 20,510
- 26,524
If the avs offer that yea, but I don't see the avs including both Timmins and Jost.
1st + Timmins/Jost + B piece is what I expect the avs to offer
Thats around that same value Ottawa got for Stone
I don't think the Avs are shopping Byram, I think they really want Hall. They might be willing to part with him for some other potential high impact player as well. Kind of like some Habs fans are willing to deal the team's 1st rounder or Cole Caufield or some other higher end prospect for a high impact player.Gotta start somewhere.
Seen rumors connecting Byram to Hall but really who knows.
I don't think Bergevin would bring Galchenyuk back. Julien didn't like him (or at least the way he played) and would probably stick him on the 4th line again if he came back. I like the ideal though. I was thinking along the lines of a Byron for Wennberg (Columbus fans seem to want to get rid of him) or for Niederreiter (Canes might not want to deal with Habs after the offer sheet to Aho though). I seen some suggestions for Jenner from Columbus though as well. Doubt the Jackets would do a straight up Byron for Jenner deal though. They might not even do a 1 for 1 with Wennberg.
- Jun 24, 2012
- 83,638
- 150,401
Same can be said of Subban and Pacioretty -- not suggesting any of them should be back but they were all dispatched with some real or rumored personal irritant involving the GM. Safe to say none of them will ever have anything to do with the Habs as long as this GM remains in place. Probably for the better.
26Mats
Registered User
- Jun 23, 2018
- 32,088
- 24,565
yeah I don't think MB would either. But I remember Chucky's last year here, he said after a rough start to the season, he felt he gained Julien's trust at the end of the season.
Ultimately, many say Chucky is just too big of a defensive liability. Personally, since we need offensive depth, given we don't have elite first liners, I would see if Chucky can keep learning from Julien defensively, if he's available at the low price of Byron's contract.
Habs Icing
Formerly Onice
to
Tomas Tatar (50 % Retain salary till end of the season)
Christian Folin
to
1st pick Oilers
Puuljarvi
Brandon Manning (cap dump)
Josh ArchiBald (cap dump)
I never want to read a post where you criticize MB's trades.
Habs Icing
Formerly Onice
Peohling and maybe even KK are not our centers. Not centers to replace Domi anyway.
Habs Icing
Formerly Onice
A big hesitant yes but Avs won't. And we better hope that KK or Poehling can do the job but I have reservations.
people like to Shit on Domi and he's not having a great year, but the issue is habs lack of depth and talent up front. he's been playing with a rookie and plug all year. at least with Shaw he had a guy who created chaos on his line, who also happened to be a puck-winner. he has neither right now. Habs have a solid possession line - which 'acts' as a no.1 - and then 9 guys in various combos, made worse by 3 injuries. blame bergevin, not domi
DAChampion
Registered User
- May 28, 2011
- 29,794
- 20,951
Why, what is wrong with that trade? Puljujarvi may never be an impact player, but their 1st for Tatar and Folin still sounds alright. If Puljujarvi becomes something useful, it would be a home run.
Then, we will also suck this year, and get a much higher draft pick .... shitty year to be a Habs fan, though.
Just to be clear: I am not advocating for this trade, just wondering why you don't like it.
DangerDave
Mete's Shot
Tatar fetched a 1st, 2nd and 3rd when he only had 28 points in 62 games. He's got 3 points less than that total in half as many games and he's coming off a 25 goal year. A 60+ point play driver on a good contract can fetch a lot more than a late first and a reclamation project at the deadline. You could easily add in a 2nd and Samoroukov.
blarneylad
Registered User
- Feb 1, 2009
- 8,203
- 4,517
If Tatar would fetch that kind of return and Habs are out of playoffs come deadline he needs to be shopped
JuJu Mobb
Registered User
- Dec 9, 2009
- 2,812
- 2,988
Habs Icing
Formerly Onice
1) Edmonton is on the rise. Right now they're 8th overall. I think they'll finish higher but let's say they stay at 8th. That's a 23rd OA pick. Can you tell me the last time Timmins connected on a late first round pick? And yes the jury on Poehling is still out. I'll answer the question for you. In 07 with Patches. That will be 13 drafts ago. He has even fumbled with our early 1st round picks.
2) he has us taking two salary dumps. In the off season taking on salary dumps are worth more than the magic beans he's asking for.
3) As a few others mentioned, Tatar was traded for a 1st, 2nd and 3rd when he was in a season-long slump. Now, that Tatar is a bonafide winger you want just a 1st and a couple of salary dumps.
4) Poolparty is not worth taking a chance on. More magic beans
5) That was a Houle level trade proposal.
If they want Tatar and dump two salaries on our payroll, They better pony up more than a late !st round pick. I haven't kept track of him but Samoroukov looked good last year. If not him than someone else. Better yet forget about the picks and scraps. They want Tatar, they give us Nurse. If you look at the team stats we're 5th in the league in goals for and 30th in goals against. We need defensemen. Pronto.
Last edited:
Serious pass on galchenyuk, let him bounce around the league. They don’t need that type of player.
DangerDave
Mete's Shot
I meant to say a 2nd OR Samoroukov but yeah. Puuljarvi isn't worth much at all with Edmonton even wanting to trade him for Lehky and Ouellet. Giving up a guy like Tatar for basically a late first isn't enough imo. Just look at what Dzingel got.
26Mats
Registered User
- Jun 23, 2018
- 32,088
- 24,565
I’d be surprised if he could get that same package again. LV seriously over paid. But, hey, I’d take that package if we are out of the playoffs.
But, I would easily take a flyer on Puljujarvi for a 3rd. I’d even consider a 2nd. (I would watch him closely, but Ive heatd that he is doing well). So, aside from the cap dump, the deal isn’t far off.
if a team needed a cap dump for Tatar, I would ask for a top prospect, too.
anyway, all very unlikely.
- Status
