Proposal: Trade Proposal Thread (Part III)

[Bacchus1]

Because we need to make room for the slew of RDs that are coming Juulsen, Fleury, Brook could all be ready next year. Why wait for Petry to lose value before trading him?

Do you disagree that he will lose value? He already only has one point in 9 games. Weber is taking away his offensive opportinities and Petry isnt the best defensively, so where is his value if he doesnt produce ?

Makes sense. If it gets us something really good, especially a young #1 left D, then it would be worth it.

 

[40 STANLEYCUPS NOT24]

If Matthews and Marner get to July 1st they will get a lot more,they will both get offer sheets.

The LAFFS better sign them soon, because, if I am a GM from another team, then I attempt to dismantle them right to the ground, with a massive offer sheet on July 1st, which they could not possibly match...LOL. It would be FUN!!

 

[40 STANLEYCUPS NOT24]

What hole is Petry filling ?

2nd pair RD ? Fleury, Juulsen, Brook can fill that up.

That is an excellent plan. Thumbs up!

 

[Mrb1p]

Makes sense. If it gets us something really good, especially a young #1 left D, then it would be worth it.

I doubt we get a good #1 LD. We'd need to give a lot to get that, but we might be able to draft one, with the 1st round pick Petry will get us.

 

[Mrb1p]

That is an excellent plan. Thumbs up!

Sarcasm ?

The Habs will have to make room for the younger players to play sooner or later, why not sooner, while Petry is worth more, while the Habs are losing, while the Habs are rebuilding and while the pick were going to get back from Petry is going to be the same age as the competition window ?

 

[40 STANLEYCUPS NOT24]

Sarcasm ?

The Habs will have to make room for the younger players to play sooner or later, why not sooner, while Petry is worth more, while the Habs are losing, while the Habs are rebuilding and while the pick were going to get back from Petry is going to be the same age as the competition window ?

Absolutely not. Petry is part of the 5 MAJOR "P" problems of the past 5 to 10 years, that the team has experienced. They have gotten rid of P.K., Pacioretty, and Plekanec, and it's time to do the same with Petry, and Price. All good riddance, and the sooner the other two bums go, the better.

 

[Kimota]

No effing way and I don't think Koko Puffs will be #1 centerman.

Here's the thing though, I think just putting him with the Habs would do a lot, it changes the whole picture of his team, a big talented center would do a lot for this team.

 

[Bacchus1]

I doubt we get a good #1 LD. We'd need to give a lot to get that, but we might be able to draft one, with the 1st round pick Petry will get us.

I don’t see the point it trading Petry for only a 1st. I also doubt that Bergie will sacrifice this year for the hope of winning in 3-4 years. If Petey is traded it is for help on the D this year.

 

[Mrb1p]

I don’t see the point it trading Petry for only a 1st. I also doubt that Bergie will sacrifice this year for the hope of winning in 3-4 years. If Petey is traded it is for help on the D this year.

It's not going to happen. At best, we get a Pacioretty type of deal.

 

[Scriptor]

I don’t see the point it trading Petry for only a 1st. I also doubt that Bergie will sacrifice this year for the hope of winning in 3-4 years. If Petey is traded it is for help on the D this year.

It depends on how good the younger D would be? If Petry is traded to a contender for a blue chip D prospect, I don't think that the GM will have trouble selling that to a relatively young team looking to truly compete in a few years. Petry for Sandin, from Toronto, and a pick (ideally 1st, but likely 2nd) wouldn't be a bad trade, IMO.

 

[The Great Weal]

It's not going to happen. At best, we get a Pacioretty type of deal.

Grade a prospect, top 6 forward and a 2nd? Sign me up.

 

[Kriss E]

I don’t see the point it trading Petry for only a 1st. I also doubt that Bergie will sacrifice this year for the hope of winning in 3-4 years. If Petey is traded it is for help on the D this year.

As Scriptor said, really depends who you're targeting as a partner. Avs, althought not rushed, could be a very good partner to trade with come deadline. They have a solid team, their biggest area of need is on Defense. I'm sure they'd be interested in Petry.
As Scriptor said Toronto would probably be the most desperate, they have Matthews, Marner and Kapanen that need new contracts next year..I'm sure they want to go all in this spring and they need Ds.

 

[40 STANLEYCUPS NOT24]

Grade a prospect, top 6 forward and a 2nd? Sign me up.

I second the motion. Do that immediately. This time make it a grade A defensive prospect, Who do the Kings have that is a grade A defensive prospect? That prospect, Vilardi(top 6 forward...potentially), and a 2nd round draft pick, for Petry. Do it now ! !

 

[Simarino]

I second the motion. Do that immediately. This time make it a grade A defensive prospect, Who do the Kings have that is a grade A defensive prospect? That prospect, Vilardi(top 6 forward...potentially), and a 2nd round draft pick, for Petry. Do it now ! !

Kings are starting a rebuild, they wont have any interest in a deal like that.

Maybe another deal with Vegas if they are in the playoff picture near the TDL: Petry vs Nicolas Hague+2nd round pick or something like that

 

[The Great Weal]

Kings are starting a rebuild, they wont have any interest in a deal like that.

Maybe another deal with Vegas if they are in the playoff picture near the TDL: Petry vs Nicolas Hague+2nd round pick or something like that

Yup Vegas makes sense to me. Also if the yotes want to make a push, they make sense too.

 

[Shabs]

As Scriptor said, really depends who you're targeting as a partner. Avs, althought not rushed, could be a very good partner to trade with come deadline. They have a solid team, their biggest area of need is on Defense. I'm sure they'd be interested in Petry.
As Scriptor said Toronto would probably be the most desperate, they have Matthews, Marner and Kapanen that need new contracts next year..I'm sure they want to go all in this spring and they need Ds.

Petry for kapanen?

 

[Mrb1p]

Grade a prospect, top 6 forward and a 2nd? Sign me up.

That's the best case.

Something like Hagg+1st+3rd would work for Petry, imo.

Honka+1st+3rd, but we'd have to take some salary back from Dallas.

 

[40 STANLEYCUPS NOT24]

Kings are starting a rebuild, they wont have any interest in a deal like that.

Maybe another deal with Vegas if they are in the playoff picture near the TDL: Petry vs Nicolas Hague+2nd round pick or something like that

Even better. They have Shea Theodore.

 

[The Great Weal]

That's the best case.

Something like Hagg+1st+3rd would work for Petry, imo.

Honka+1st+3rd, but we'd have to take some salary back from Dallas.

Honka is terrible

 

[Simarino]

Even better. They have Shea Theodore.

They need Theodore,if they’re looking to win the cup we’re gonna get prospect and picks, not theyre best d-man

 

[40 STANLEYCUPS NOT24]

They need Theodore,if they’re looking to win the cup we’re gonna get prospect and picks, not theyre best d-man

I mean try to do it now....right now...lol. Think fleece!

 

[Mrb1p]

Honka is terrible

Maybe, but Tatar was terrible too.

 

[Mrb1p]

Kings are starting a rebuild, they wont have any interest in a deal like that.

Maybe another deal with Vegas if they are in the playoff picture near the TDL: Petry vs Nicolas Hague+2nd round pick or something like that

Petry for 2nd and Hague is a dream come true.

Hague is just too good.

I'd most likely do Hague for Petry straight up, but thats mostly because I have a crush on Nic.

 

[Kriss E]

Petry for kapanen?

No, Leafs aren't going to rid themselves of any good roster player. We would have to look at young prospects and picks.

 

[The Great Weal]

Maybe, but Tatar was terrible too.

What? Tatar always had 2nd line stats. Last year was an awful year and he still scored 20 goals. Honka just flat out sucks.