Picking out sv% from individual games without context is useless
If you really want to cite sv% tho, I suggest you take a look where Andersen stands in the league. He’s been awful for almost two years now. It’s not an injury. His play is just falling off. It sucks, but it is what it is.
Campbell is the better goalie today. So you start him. That simple.
I agree that you need context.
I also feel you really need to have watched a lot of the games as well, to get a feel for how the defence played in front of the goalie, which is really difficult to discern from even the best advanced statistics. And Andy has just been falling off steadily going by eye test . . . it hasn't been dramatic, but the decline definitely became steeper this year.
Making things more complicated was that with a hot Campbell in net, you realised that our D was actually playing really well, we just weren't getting those consistent saves you need from any good NHL starting goalie.
I think Campbell is our guy - but I would also love to have Andy available, as you just never know.