They’re literally below Toronto in points percentage. They also missed the playoffs last year and they may as well have missed in the year before when they got swept in the first round by the ****ing Ducks.
Their starting goaltender is an unproven 26 year old with less than 40 starts at the NHL level who posted an .889 SV% in 12 AHL games and their backup is Mike Smith.
They’re not even top-10 in 5V5 GF/60, they’re not top ten in 5V5 GA/60, they’re not top-10 in PP%, and they’re not top-10 in PK%. And given what I mentioned above, they’re lucky as hell that they’re not bottom-10 in save percentage, but they probably will be by the end of the season.
The one thing that brings them into this elite class is that they’re 1st in the NHL with 157 power play opportunities. They do nothing else at an elite level. And while they do have some solid **** disturbers like Gaudreau and Tkachuk, who draw penalties quite well, I don’t think that they’re going to sustain those 157 power play opportunities.
Outside of the PP opportunities, they’re a pretty solid Swiss Army knife of a team - not bad in any category (though I suspect goaltending will be by the end of the season), but not great at anything. That’s not really a winning formula.