Proposal: Toronto Vancity Trade

[Amadeus]

Tanev and JVR as a base, I'm okay with.

Kapanen is JVR's replacement and we're not trading 1st rounders.

 

[M2Beezy]

I don't like Kapanen.

2018 1st round pick could be anywhere for all we know, doesn't matter if '18 is perceived as the better draft year. what's the 5th rounder doing there?

You are consistently wrong about everything, I admire you in some ways Bure to Moginly. You are unique and very special indeed.

Whyd u respond seriously after your previous post? lol

Anyways its a gamble for both teams to make that trade cause yeah we DONT know where the pick will be

And i added the 5th cause benning for some strange reason has a great track record in the 5th round lol

 

[scan15*]

Fans of both teams are being extremely unreasonable.

Kapanen + 1st is a good base.

Tanev is worth giving up a good 1st round pick for.

This is a reasonable trade.

 

[Morgs]

Tanev and JVR as a base, I'm okay with.

Kapanen is JVR's replacement and we're not trading 1st rounders.

Agree with all of this.

I'd like Tanev on the Leafs, but I'm not willing to trade basically all our best assets for him.

 

[scan15*]

Agree with all of this.

I'd like Tanev on the Leafs, but I'm not willing to trade basically all our best assets for him.

It doesn't make sense for Vancouver though. They have no use for JVR. If the leafs want a dman like Tanev, they need to give up a lottery 1st round pick. I'm completely ok with that. Tanev is only 26.

 

[Morgs]

It doesn't make sense for Vancouver though. They have no use for JVR. If the leafs want a dman like Tanev, they need to give up a lottery 1st round pick. I'm completely ok with that. Tanev is only 26.

I'm completely aware it doesn't make sense for Vanouver.

I'm also not sold on the fact Tanev is worth JVR + Kapanen + 1st.

 

[scan15*]

I'm completely aware it doesn't make sense for Vanouver.

I'm also not sold on the fact Tanev is worth JVR + Kapanen + 1st.

Thought OPs trade was Kapanen and a 1st. Which is a high price but worth it for Tanev. Adding JVR is a massive overpay, I agree.

 

[Canada4Gold]

Tanev to Leafs threads are always fun.

He's a guy I'd love to target, not sure what I'd be willing to give up, not sure what Vancouver would need to have in return, I'll let Lou sort it all out.

 

[turkulad]

Oh great..

 

[A1LeafNation]

No thanks to Tanev, Leafs gonna go younger route.

 

[LondonKendrick]

What about Andersen, Kapanen and Rychel for Tanev?

I know it's less than what the OP offered but...

 

[turkulad]

What about Andersen, Kapanen and Rychel for Tanev?

I know it's less than what the OP offered but...

Gimme one reason why Vancouver, a bottom-3 team with Markström, UFA-to-be-Miller and Demko would need a godd*mn Andersen?

 

[Alexanderthe89]

Two 1sts for Tanev seems pretty reasonable...

 

[skyo]

I was hoping this Van-Tdot trade would be different....sadly mistaken.

 

[Magic Man]

What Kapanen is doing at his age, in only the first year of his ELC is very impressive. He's quickly playing his way into the unlikely to be moved category. When JVR is moved insert Kasperi Kapanen to the Leafs top-6.

 

[Man Bear Pig]

The Leafs shouldn't trade their first without protection. We should be doing just fine in the 2018 standings but given the luck, or lack thereof of, we can't deal that pick without knowing where it is in the draft before hand.

 

[Man Bear Pig]

I don't like Kapanen.

2018 1st round pick could be anywhere for all we know, doesn't matter if '18 is perceived as the better draft year. what's the 5th rounder doing there?

You are consistently wrong about everything, I admire you in some ways Bure to Moginly. You are unique and very special indeed.

You don't like Kapanen? Why? He's been excellent and would immediately be one of the Canucks best prospects. Great skater who can score. I'd hate to have that guy on my team.

 

[Confucius]

Fans of both teams are being extremely unreasonable.

Kapanen + 1st is a good base.
[Tanev] is worth giving up a good 1st round pick for.

This is a reasonable trade.

not all 1st round picks are equal, if the 1st is 20th to 30th, ok.

 

[Bourne Endeavor]

Tanev and JVR as a base, I'm okay with.

Kapanen is JVR's replacement and we're not trading 1st rounders.

Vancouver is rebuilding, yet takes a 27 year old winger who will be out of his prime by the time they're competitive again. And to top it all off, JVR is only signed to two years. What a useless trade that would be.

 

[LondonKendrick]

Gimme one reason why Vancouver, a bottom-3 team with Markström, UFA-to-be-Miller and Demko would need a godd*mn Andersen?

Just making the point that Van fans would think it's laughable that Tanev be degraded with a package that landed Kessel with retention because clearly Tanev >> Kessel. Both Hall of Famers.

Why would a bottom three team with ownership not interested in rebuilding want a young affordable starting goaltender who very well one day be a Vezina candidate? I mean they have Miller for the rest of the whole year and he can't be traded.

 

[Liferleafer]

What about Andersen, Kapanen and Rychel for Tanev?

I know it's less than what the OP offered but...

Andersen? Why are we targeting a D by trading our starting goalie? This one is weird.

 

[LondonKendrick]

Andersen? Why are we targeting a D by trading our starting goalie? This one is weird.

Pretend instead of Andersen it's a conditional 1st round pick that turns into a 18 1st if the Leafs miss the playoffs then a 19 2nd round pick if the Leafs miss the playoffs again next year.

 

[Liferleafer]

Pretend instead of Andersen it's a conditional 1st round pick that turns into a 18 1st if the Leafs miss the playoffs then a 19 2nd round pick if the Leafs miss the playoffs again next year.

That's a condition Van wouldn't do. Top 5 protected? Maybe...but playoff protected? No.

 

[LondonKendrick]

That's a condition Van wouldn't do. Top 5 protected? Maybe...but playoff protected? No.

Sigh... you don't get it.

 

[Liferleafer]

Sigh... you don't get it.

I guess i don't. If it has something to do with the Kessel trade, why would Van care about that? Confused...