Top-100 Hockey Players of All-Time - Aggregate List

[quoipourquoi]

Rank	Player	Lists	Points	Highest	Highest	Lowest	Lowest	Median	Eligibility	Final Ranking
1	Wayne Gretzky	32	3826	1		6	Canadiens1958	1	1-4 (10 Players)	1
2	Bobby Orr	32	3803	1		4		2	1-4 (10 Players)	3 (-1)
3	Gordie Howe	32	3782	2		4		3	1-4 (10 Players)	2 (+1)
4	Mario Lemieux	32	3752	2		5		4	1-4 (10 Players)	4
5	Jean Beliveau	32	3661	3	Canadiens1958	14	VanIslander	6	1-4 (10 Players)	6 (-1)
6	Bobby Hull	32	3634	5		13	steve141	7	1-4 (10 Players)	5 (+1)
7	Doug Harvey	32	3592	4	Canadiens1958	28	blogofmike	7.5	1-4 (10 Players)	8 (-1)
8	Maurice Richard	32	3588	4	BenchBrawl	20	Mike Farkas	8	1-4 (10 Players)	9 (-1)
9	Patrick Roy	32	3515	5		24	Canadiens1958	10	1-4 (10 Players)	7 (+2)
10	Ray Bourque	32	3487	7	kruezer	21	Sentinel	11.5	1-4 (10 Players)	10
11	Dominik Hasek	32	3431	5		34	Canadiens1958	12	5-9 (10 Players)	13 (-2)
12	Howie Morenz	32	3429	7	pappyline	22	ImporterExporter	15	5-9 (10 Players)	11 (+1)
13	Eddie Shore	32	3402	7	Dennis Bonvie	29	TheGeneral	13	5-9 (10 Players)	14 (-1)
14	Sidney Crosby	32	3385	5	bobholly39	48	TheGeneral	12	5-9 (10 Players)	12 (+2)
15	Jaromir Jagr	32	3336	7	Art of Sedinery	49	Canadiens1958	15	10-14 (12 Players)	16 (-1)
16	Nicklas Lidstrom	32	3273	9	Mike Farkas	35	quoipourquoi	17	10-14 (12 Players)	15 (+1)
17	Stan Mikita	32	3250	9	tony d	43	ChiTownPhilly	18	10-14 (12 Players)	24 (-7)
18	Jacques Plante	32	3248	10	Johnny Engine	37	Sentinel	17	10-14 (12 Players)	19 (-1)
19	Denis Potvin	32	3207	13	Mike Farkas	35	Sentinel	20.5	10-14 (12 Players)	18 (+1)
20	Alex Ovechkin	32	3202	11	TheGeneral	59	Canadiens1958	20	10-14 (12 Players)	22 (-2)
21	Mark Messier	32	3176	7	TheGeneral	34	DannyGallivan	21	10-14 (12 Players)	21
22	Guy Lafleur	32	3167	6	DannyGallivan	31		23	15-19 (11 Players)	23 (-1)
23	Red Kelly	32	3165	10	Mike Farkas	36	TheGeneral	21.5	15-19 (11 Players)	17 (+6)
24	Frank Nighbor	32	3071	7	ehhedler	77	JoseTheodore2002	23	15-19 (11 Players)	20 (+4)
25	Phil Esposito	32	3059	12	VanIslander	40	ted1971	24.5	15-19 (11 Players)	27 (-2)
26	Bobby Clarke	32	3040	15	ted1971	51	ChiTownPhilly	24	20-24 (11 Players)	29 (-3)
27	Viacheslav Fetisov	32	2907	12	Mike Farkas	68	quoipourquoi	29.5	20-24 (11 Players)	25 (+2)
28	Glenn Hall	32	2904	14	kruezer	58	tony d	27.5	20-24 (11 Players)	28
29	Martin Brodeur	32	2859	15		74	pappyline	30	20-24 (11 Players)	30 (-1)
30	Terry Sawchuk	32	2846	14	Canadiens1958	54	Hockey Outsider	30.5	20-24 (11 Players)	35 (-5)
31	Sergei Makarov	32	2823	10	Sentinel	81	The Macho Man	27	25-29 (11 Players)	26 (+5)
32	Joe Sakic	32	2818	20	blogofmike	46	pappyline	32.5	25-29 (11 Players)	32
33	Bryan Trottier	32	2812	24	Sentinel	47	bobholly39	33	25-29 (11 Players)	31 (+2)
34	Cyclone Taylor	32	2792	7	VanIslander	52	Mike Farkas	33	25-29 (11 Players)	33 (+1)
35	Mike Bossy	32	2772	13	JoseTheodore2002	48	VanIslander	36	25-29 (11 Players)	36 (-1)
36	Larry Robinson	32	2744	17	Canadiens1958	51	steve141	34.5	30-34 (11 Players)	37 (-1)
37	Newsy Lalonde	32	2643	26	blogofmike	53		39	30-34 (11 Players)	39 (-2)
38	Steve Yzerman	32	2627	20	Sentinel	51	Kyle McMahon	39	30-34 (11 Players)	40 (-2)
39	Ted Lindsay	32	2616	24	tony d	54		39	30-34 (11 Players)	38 (+1)
40	Bill Cook	32	2597	27	seventieslord	69	TheGeneral	38	30-34 (11 Players)	34 (+6)
41	Chris Chelios	32	2545	23	Mike Farkas	61	DannyGallivan	42	35-39 (10 Players)	41
42	Ken Dryden	32	2448	19	Canadiens1958	89	DannyGallivan	44	35-39 (10 Players)	46 (-4)
43	Paul Coffey	32	2309	26	bobholly39	79	ehhedler	48.5	35-39 (10 Players)	48 (-5)
44	Brad Park	32	2305	24	Mike Farkas	90	TheGeneral	46	35-39 (10 Players)	47 (-3)
45	Valeri Kharlamov	32	2251	19	DannyGallivan	88	quoipourquoi	47	40-44 (13 Players)	43 (+2)
46	Pierre Pilote	32	2153	32	Mike Farkas	104	TheGeneral	52.5	40-44 (13 Players)	54 (-8)
47	Syl Apps	32	2142	30	quoipourquoi	116	TheGeneral	49.5	40-44 (13 Players)	45 (+2)
48	Henri Richard	32	2138	33		108	VanIslander	52	40-44 (13 Players)	49 (-1)
49	Frank Boucher	31	2101	37	Kyle McMahon	NR	Sentinel	49.5	40-44 (13 Players)	42 (+7)
49	King Clancy	32	2101	35	MXD	92	bobholly39	54	40-44 (13 Players)	44 (+5)
51	Charlie Conacher	32	2096	37	MXD	91	Mike Farkas	53	40-44 (13 Players)	55 (-4)
52	Vladislav Tretiak	31	2094	29		NR	ehhedler	52.5	40-44 (13 Players)	50 (+2)
53	Bernie Geoffrion	32	2076	28	VanIslander	78	Kyle McMahon	56	45-49 (11 Players)	60 (-7)
54	Peter Forsberg	32	2070	32	ehhedler	85	The Macho Man	54.5	45-49 (11 Players)	51 (+3)
55	Milt Schmidt	32	2053	32	pappyline	95	JoseTheodore2002	56.5	45-49 (11 Players)	53 (+2)
56	Evgeni Malkin	32	1951	33	Sentinel	110	blogofmike	55	50-54 (10 Players)	52 (+4)
57	Marcel Dionne	30	1889	30	VanIslander	NR		56	50-54 (10 Players)	63 (-6)
58	Frank Brimsek	32	1875	38	steve141	114	ehhedler	61	50-54 (10 Players)	56 (+2)
59	Earl Seibert	31	1864	26	VanIslander	NR	Sentinel	61.5	50-54 (10 Players)	61 (-2)
60	Sprague Cleghorn	31	1815	40	ChiTownPhilly	NR	ehhedler	58	55-59 (11 Players)	57 (+3)
61	Andy Bathgate	30	1757	41	pappyline	NR		62	55-59 (11 Players)	62 (-1)
62	Frank Mahovlich	32	1730	40	pappyline	102	bobholly39	68	55-59 (11 Players)	71 (-9)
63	Chris Pronger	32	1721	42	ehhedler	107	pappyline	65.5	55-59 (11 Players)	59 (+4)
64	Tim Horton	32	1684	48	MXD	100	DannyGallivan	66.5	55-59 (11 Players)	65 (-1)
65	Ted Kennedy	32	1674	35	Canadiens1958	116	DannyGallivan	68	55-59 (11 Players)	58 (+7)
66	Al MacInnis	31	1520	40	Mike Farkas	NR	Canadiens1958	72.5	60-64 (10 Players)	67 (-1)
67	Teemu Selanne	32	1508	41	Sentinel	105	Kyle McMahon	70.5	60-64 (10 Players)	69 (-2)
68	Scott Stevens	32	1488	43	blogofmike	104	Canadiens1958	73	60-64 (10 Players)	64 (+4)
69	Georges Vezina	29	1450	39	steve141	NR		75.5	60-64 (10 Players)	66 (+3)
70	Dickie Moore	32	1384	47	Canadiens1958	120	blogofmike	77	65-69 (11 Players)	68 (+2)
71	Bill Durnan	28	1366	38	quoipourquoi	NR		72.5	65-69 (11 Players)	82 (-11)
72	Dit Clapper	32	1355	35	Dennis Bonvie	120	MXD	74	65-69 (11 Players)	73 (-1)
73	Joe Malone	30	1340	44	JoseTheodore2002	NR		76.5	65-69 (11 Players)	72 (+1)
74	Cy Denneny	32	1333	51	tony d	117		74.5	65-69 (11 Players)	79 (-5)
75	Clint Benedict	29	1327	48	steve141	NR		78.5	65-69 (11 Players)	74 (+1)
76	Jari Kurri	32	1305	46	Sentinel	115	ResilientBeast	81	70-74 (10 Players)	76
77	Turk Broda	32	1293	52	steve141	118	BenchBrawl	79	70-74 (10 Players)	83 (-6)
78	Brett Hull	31	1281	44	bobholly39	NR	VanIslander	80.5	70-74 (10 Players)	80 (-2)
79	Anatoli Firsov	28	1277	27	Sentinel	NR		85.5	70-74 (10 Players)	70 (+9)
80	Aurele Joliat	31	1253	60	JoseTheodore2002	NR	TheGeneral	80	75-79 (10 Players)	78 (+2)
81	Max Bentley	30	1217	37	pappyline	NR		85	75-79 (10 Players)	77 (+4)
82	Charlie Gardiner	28	1210	43		NR		77.5	75-79 (10 Players)	75 (+7)
83	Boris Mikhailov	30	1160	51	Sentinel	NR		83.5	75-79 (10 Players)	86 (-3)
84	Sergei Fedorov	31	1078	32	Sentinel	NR	VanIslander	91	75-79 (10 Players)	88 (-4)
85	Borje Salming	30	930	64	Mike Farkas	NR		92.5	80-84 (10 Players)	84 (+1)
86	Elmer Lach	29	905	66	Art of Sedinery	NR		93.5	80-84 (10 Players)	81 (+5)
87	Brian Leetch	30	902	47	ehhedler	NR		92	80-84 (10 Players)	97 (-10)
88	Nels Stewart	26	897	59	DannyGallivan	NR		94	80-84 (10 Players)	92 (-4)
89	Bill Gadsby	25	831	57	Art of Sedinery	NR		94	80-84 (10 Players)	90 (-1)
90	Duncan Keith	28	821	57	TheGeneral	NR		97.5	85-89 (11 Players)	94 (-4)
91	Martin St. Louis	30	776	71	TheGeneral	NR		92	85-89 (11 Players)	98 (-7)
92	Zdeno Chara	26	765	60	ImporterExporter	NR		98	85-89 (11 Players)	89 (+3)
93	Ed Belfour	26	748	58	bobholly39	NR		100.5	85-89 (11 Players)	85 (+8)
93	Eric Lindros	24	748	39	Dennis Bonvie	NR		103	85-89 (11 Players)	96 (-3)
95	Bill Cowley	23	742	56	VanIslander	NR		94	85-89 (11 Players)	87 (+8)
96	Dave Keon	27	723	55	ehhedler	NR		106.5	90-94 (20 Players)	99 (-3)
97	Toe Blake	27	707	71	tony d	NR		98.5	90-94 (20 Players)
98	Jarome Iginla	28	703	57	ChiTownPhilly	NR		98.5	90-94 (20 Players)
99	Joe Thornton	27	681	62	TheGeneral	NR		99	90-94 (20 Players)	91 (+8)
100	Serge Savard	24	646	45	Canadiens1958	NR		108.5	90-94 (20 Players)
101	Mark Howe	27	645	69	Mike Farkas	NR		106.5	90-94 (20 Players)	95 (+6)
102	Norm Ullman	25	608	70	TheDevilMadeMe	NR		103.5	90-94 (20 Players)
103	Eddie Gerard	19	597	55	Mike Farkas	NR		110.5	90-94 (20 Players)
104	Peter Stastny	20	591	63	TheGeneral	NR		113.5	90-94 (20 Players)
105	Sid Abel	24	574	71	blogofmike	NR		106.5	90-94 (20 Players)	100 (+5)
106	Erik Karlsson	23	568	60	seventieslord	NR		107.5	90-94 (20 Players)
107	Valeri Vasiliev	23	562	66	ChiTownPhilly	NR		102	90-94 (20 Players)
108	Tony Esposito	19	552	65	steve141	NR		111.5	90-94 (20 Players)
109	Patrick Kane	21	541	64	ehhedler	NR		108	90-94 (20 Players)	93 (+16)
110	Johnny Bower	18	512	71	Hockey Outsider	NR		115.5	95-99 (20 Players)
111	Bernie Parent	23	506	69	steve141	NR		109.5	95-99 (20 Players)
112	Jiri Holecek	20	502	59	steve141	NR		111	95-99 (20 Players)
113	Russell Bowie	13	475	45	Kyle McMahon	NR		NR	95-99 (20 Players)
114	Pavel Bure	18	470	58		NR		114.5	95-99 (20 Players)
115	Doug Gilmour	17	444	49	TheGeneral	NR		118	100 (20 Players)
116	Alexander Maltsev	15	410	66	VanIslander	NR		NR	100 (20 Players)
117	Vladimir Martinec	16	400	70	Sentinel	NR		NR	100 (20 Players)
118	Ron Francis	14	350	64	TheGeneral	NR		NR	100 (20 Players)
119	Scott Niedermayer	12	334	53	TheGeneral	NR		NR	100 (20 Players)
120	Bill Quackenbush	17	323	70	Art of Sedinery	NR		117.5
121	Pavel Datsyuk	13	320	59	Sentinel	NR		NR
122	Gilbert Perreault	12	292	76	tony d	NR		NR
123	Alex Delvecchio	12	259	73	TheGeneral	NR		NR
124	Busher Jackson	17	240	87	pappyline	NR		120
124	Henrik Lundqvist	10	240	69	bobholly39	NR		NR
126	Roy Worters	12	238	73	steve141	NR		NR
127	Drew Doughty	14	235	85		NR		NR
128	Guy Lapointe	10	209	56	Canadiens1958	NR		NR
129	George Hainsworth	9	198	82	pappyline	NR		NR
130	Tommy Phillips	10	188	70	kruezer	NR		NR
131	Doug Bentley	12	185	88	pappyline	NR		NR
132	Adam Oates	8	178	75	bobholly39	NR		NR
133	Roberto Luongo	6	162	70	bobholly39	NR		NR
134	Jacques Lemaire	5	154	55	Canadiens1958	NR		NR
135	Rod Langway	13	146	96	Dennis Bonvie	NR		NR
136	Hod Stuart	7	136	57	kruezer	NR		NR
137	Frank McGee	5	131	71	kruezer	NR		NR
138	Billy Smith	7	126	92	steve141	NR		NR
138	Vladimir Krutov	6	126	65	Dennis Bonvie	NR		NR
140	Jonathan Toews	6	120	93	blogofmike	NR		NR
141	Johnny Bucyk	5	118	78	tony d	NR		NR
142	Hugh Lehman	7	116	95	steve141	NR		NR
143	Dale Hawerchuk	3	111	82	TheGeneral	NR		NR
144	Jack Stewart	11	110	94	ResilientBeast	NR		NR
145	Tiny Thompson	7	109	86	steve141	NR		NR
146	Jan Suchy	6	108	68	ChiTownPhilly	NR		NR
147	Mike Modano	6	104	86	ehhedler	NR		NR
148	Hap Holmes	2	101	54	ehhedler	NR		NR
149	Grant Fuhr	7	95	94	blogofmike	NR		NR
150	Paul Kariya	6	91	98	Mike Farkas	NR		NR
150	Vladimir Petrov	4	91	62	Sentinel	NR		NR
152	Ching Johnson	7	90	79	Mike Farkas	NR		NR
153	Jean Ratelle	5	83	85	blogofmike	NR		NR
154	Connor McDavid	3	82	84	Dennis Bonvie	NR		NR
155	Harry Cameron	2	79	49	ehhedler	NR		NR
156	Henrik Zetterberg	3	75	72	ehhedler	NR		NR
157	Syd Howe	5	71	84	VanIslander	NR		NR
158	Jack Walker	1	70	51	ehhedler	NR		NR
159	Alexander Yakushev	3	62	74	Sentinel	NR		NR
160	Luc Robitaille	5	61	101	Sentinel	NR		NR
161	Sweeney Schriner	4	58	92	tony d	NR		NR
162	Anze Kopitar	3	56	87	ehhedler	NR		NR
163	Moose Johnson	3	55	83	ehhedler	NR		NR
164	Denis Savard	2	52	93	DannyGallivan	NR		NR
164	Patrice Bergeron	5	52	95	ehhedler	NR		NR
166	Ebbie Goodfellow	3	49	94	Art of Sedinery	NR		NR
166	Frantisek Pospisil	2	49	82	ChiTownPhilly	NR		NR
168	Mark Recchi	2	38	96	bobholly39	NR		NR
169	Georges Boucher	2	33	102	BenchBrawl	NR		NR
170	Frank Foyston	2	31	97	ehhedler	NR		NR
171	Vsevolod Bobrov	3	28	102	kruezer	NR		NR
172	Babe Siebert	3	26	108	ted1971	NR		NR
173	Dan Bain	1	25	96	kruezer	NR		NR
173	Vyacheslav Starshinov	1	25	96	Sentinel	NR		NR
175	Alexei Kasatonov	1	24	97	Dr John Carlson	NR		NR
175	Hooley Smith	1	24	97	tony d	NR		NR
175	Mats Sundin	2	24	100	ehhedler	NR		NR
178	Igor Larionov	2	22	103	Sentinel	NR		NR
179	Yvan Cournoyer	2	19	109	tony d	NR		NR
180	Curtis Joseph	2	18	105	quoipourquoi	NR		NR
180	Marian Hossa	2	18	109	Mike Farkas	NR		NR
182	Bob Gainey	2	17	110	Canadiens1958	NR		NR
182	JC Tremblay	2	17	108	Mike Farkas	NR		NR
184	Vladimir Zabrodsky	2	16	111	Kyle McMahon	NR		NR
185	Gump Worsley	2	13	110	steve141	NR		NR
185	Pat LaFontaine	2	13	109	ehhedler	NR		NR
187	Marty Barry	1	9	112	TheDevilMadeMe	NR		NR
187	Mickey MacKay	1	9	112	ehhedler	NR		NR
187	Steven Stamkos	1	9	112	blogofmike	NR		NR
190	Roy Conacher	1	8	113	pappyline	NR		NR
190	Vaclav Nedomansky	1	8	113	Sentinel	NR		NR
192	Shea Weber	2	7	116	bobholly39	NR		NR
193	Babe Dye	2	5	118	ted1971	NR		NR
193	Rob Blake	1	5	116	The Macho Man	NR		NR
193	Sven Tumba	1	5	116	Kyle McMahon	NR		NR
193	Tom Barrasso	1	5	116	steve141	NR		NR
197	Jacques Laperriere	1	4	117	Art of Sedinery	NR		NR
198	Lionel Conacher	1	3	118	Johnny Engine	NR		NR
198	Nikolai Sologubov	1	3	118	Canadiens1958	NR		NR
198	Paul Thompson	1	3	118	pappyline	NR		NR
201	Brendan Shanahan	1	1	120	JoseTheodore2002	NR		NR
201	Bryan Hextall	1	1	120	Dr John Carlson	NR		NR
201	Carey Price	1	1	120	bobholly39	NR		NR
201	Eddie Litzenberger	1	1	120	pappyline	NR		NR
201	George Armstrong	1	1	120	Mike Farkas	NR		NR
201	Hakan Loob	1	1	120	ehhedler	NR		NR
201	Hayley Wickenheiser	1	1	120	quoipourquoi	NR		NR
201	Marcel Pronovost	1	1	120	VanIslander	NR		NR

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

Click to read more...

 

[Captain Bowie]

Interesting...

Gretzky at 6 eh @Canadiens1958

 

[BenchBrawl]

The worst NR is Frank Boucher.Maybe he was simply overlooked.

@Sentinel ?

 

[Dingo]

Interesting...

Gretzky at 6 eh @Canadiens1958

And Lemaire ahead Ovechkin

 

[MXD]

Got highest vote for Clancy, Conacher and Horton.

Leafs fans....

 

[GlitchMarner]

Who is TheGeneral? I don't recall ever seeing a post by this person, so just wondering.

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

The worst NR is Frank Boucher.Maybe he was simply overlooked.

@Sentinel ?

Doubtful it was an accident. When my list was reviewed, they noticed I was missing Frank Mahovlich, and I quickly told them it was a mistake and told them where to insert him. I never got confirmation that QPQ used my corrected list, but obviously he did (as Mahovlich has no NRs).

Best player with multiple NRs - I expected it to be Charlie Gardiner, but seems Vezina got hit by multiple NRs too. Those damn goalies.

 

[BenchBrawl]

Doubtful it was an accident. When my list was reviewed, they noticed I was missing Frank Mahovlich, and I quickly told them it was a mistake and told them where to insert him. I never got confirmation that QPQ used my corrected list, but obviously he did (as Mahovlich has no NRs).

Best player with multiple NRs - I expected it to be Charlie Gardiner, but seems Vezina got hit by multiple NRs too. Those damn goalies.

The same happened to me and I corrected it too, but maybe Sentinel wasn't reading his PMs as quickly as us.

If he deliberately excluded Boucher, I find it pretty funny considering he had Sergei Fedorov in the 30s.

 

[ChiTownPhilly]

I gotta guess that blanks in the fields mean more than one person had that player in the indicated spot.
Would it be possible to populate those fields using abbreviations (e.g.: TG, TDMM, C1958, TMM, CTP etc.)?

The skinny on me: highest on: Cleghorn (my bad), Iginla (no surprise), Vasiliev (over @Sentinel), Suchý, Pospíšil. Lowest on: Mikita, Clarke. I come out of the discussion considering Mikita somewhat higher than I did before, [Mikita had a bit of help with those serial playoff failures], and slightly higher on Clarke.

Somebody (somebodies?) had Parent and Krutov higher than I did.
Somebody (somebodies?) had Crosby and H. Richard lower than I did.

 

[bobholly39]

Speaking of Crosby i like how TheGeneral had Crosby 48th and Ovechkin 11th lol

 

[Michael Farkas]

Ooh, I was pretty close to "winning" I think...my name is up there ~20ish times...

 

[kruezer]

I'm not surprised that I was highest on McGee, Stuart, Bain, Bobrov and Phillips (though Kyle M. you got me on Bowie) but I am a bit surprised I was highest on Bourque and Hall (who I definitely cooled on during the voting). I also somehow didn't get a single lowest voter.

And I did call that Bowie was 113, I demand some sort of prize

 

[VanIslander]

131 Doug Bentley
157 Syd Howe

*stunned*

Yet Jacques Lemaire 134th?

 

[DannyGallivan]

Dumb question. What's the difference between the rank and the final ranking? My guess... the first "rank" was after everybody handed in their list of 120, and the final ranking was when we voted each group. Do I win a prize?

 

[Kyle McMahon]

I didn't expect I'd be the lowest of all on Yzerman, Geoffrion, or especially Selanne. Or that I'd be only one of two people that NR-ed St. Louis.

I'm not surprised that I was highest on Boucher (whose ranking I stand by) or Bowie (who I overrated significantly).

I'm mildly surprised that I wasn't highest on Gerard (I'd lower him in retrospect) or Abel (I'm still pretty high on him).

Most "wow!" ranking (by somebody that actually participated) for me is seeing Earl Seibert at 26 on a list, and going the other way, Ovechkin at 59 on a list.

Jacques Lemaire and Frank McGee were my two highest that didn't come up for voting.

Erik Karlsson and Doug Gilmour were the highest ranked guys that I didn't give any serious consideration to making my list.

 

[DannyGallivan]

Still ticked that Orr wasn't first overall... but both Bobby and I will survive.

 

[VMBM]

Sentinel certainly 'carried the flag' for non-NHL/some other Europeans and Russians, in most cases ranked higher than even I probably would have.

But good for e.g. Martinec who wouldn't have been discussed otherwise and who then seemed to get some new lift in the final voting.

 

[ted2019]

There are some names that I'm surprised to see.
Steven Stamkos
Shea Weber
Carey Price
Mats Sundin

 

[MXD]

131 Doug Bentley
157 Syd Howe

*stunned*

Yet Jacques Lemaire 134th?

...ehh... Delete. Not worth it.

 

[MXD]

Oh, and I totally assume being the lowest on Dit Clapper as a badge-of-honor thing. There are things to be proud to disagree about, and this is one of them.

 

[MXD]

There are some names that I'm surprised to see.
Steven Stamkos
Shea Weber
Carey Price
Mats Sundin

While I do consider Mike Modano a better player than Mats Sundin, having them some 30 spots apart at the end of the list (due Modano being listed more than Sundin in the first place) seems appropriate.

Marcel Pronovost was litterally one ballot away from not being named at all.

 

[TheEye]

Interesting...

Gretzky at 6 eh @Canadiens1958

Additionally, I think it's significant to note that this participant was highest on twelve players, nine of them being members of the Montreal Canadiens. Combine it all together and take it for what it's worth. I think there's something to be gleaned here, when considering one's clarity and objectivity as it relates to their participation in this voluminous and exhaustive project.

 

[MXD]

Additionally, I think it's significant to note that this participant was highest on twelve players, nine of them being members of the Montreal Canadiens. Combine it all together and take it for what it's worth. I think there's something to be gleaned here, when considering one's clarity and objectivity as it relates to their participation in this voluminous and exhaustive project.

Why aren't you up in arms towards the Maple Leaf fan who was the highest on Clancy, Conacher and Horton instead?
I mean... There is a lot of Hab players who actually deserve to make that list, not so much Maple Leafs (comparatively speaking).

 

[MXD]

Amongst near misses, I suppose I could've give some strong support in the last round to Henrik Lundqvist and Roy Worters (read : they would both have easily topped my last ballot, if not my last two ballots), and some support to Drew Doughty. All three were quite far from making it in the first place. Bill Quackenbush seems much better than the lowest lights from the last round (Niedermayer, Francis, Bure), but he'd probably have barely made my last ballot, if at all.

 

[BenchBrawl]

The most surprising thing in all of this is only Gretzky and Orr got ranked #1 out of 32 lists.

I ended up ranking Howe #1 in Round 2, but I thought for sure some people would have ranked him #1 in Round 1; same with Lemieux.