I'll start by saying that the defense in front of Binnington is playing outstanding hockey. They are making it somewhat easy on Jordan.
With that said, it certainly isn't impossible that Binnington may be a top 10 NHL goalie down the road. He has the tools and right now he has the confidence.
I said earlier this year that his career was very similar to Ben Bishop's up to age 25. 3rd round picks that took a long time to develop but slowly figured it out in the AHL. We all know goalies take the longest to develop. This may be another great, late bloomer.
I haven't seen anything that would suggest Binnington is a fluke. He is positionally sound, plays the puck very well, and doesn't get flustered by a bad goal. I think I read his rebound control is statistically strong too, though, that was about 3-4 games ago.
I'm cautiously optimistic! A star? I'm not going that far yet. A good starter? Please! Please! Please!