Tim Thomas or Jonathan Bernier

[JaeTM]

Topic says it all. Thomas had a strong game in game 1, then got lit up game 2. But, he is a two time Vezina winner, even at his age. Bernier looks like he can be an elite goalie in the future, a very good goalie at worst, but is splitting time with Reimer for the time being.

Who would you choose?

Click to read more...

 

[kamosko]

bernier

 

[Kane One]

Keeper league: Easily Bernier
Non-Keeper League: Still Bernier, but taking a risk on Thomas won't be a horrible move, IMO.

 

[JaeTM]

It's a keeper league, but we only get to keep 3 players each year so Bernier will most likely not be one of them unless he somehow has a Vezina like season.

 

[Cappy]

Bernier for me