I don't have time to properly research the examples I need, and evidently all you guys are interested in doing is offering up excuses and saying everything is hunky-dory. Of course some decisions were rational at the time, but it all adds up to a disturbing trend in the way we do things.
If I listened to you guys, I would let AV off the hook for the forwards, the various GM's off the hook for their drafting.....everyone is happy and healthy kumbaya! So I guess we're a model organization?
I don't buy it. We still have a lot of work to do IMO.
You have to look at the decision in the context of what was known at the time. It's the only way to evaluate them. You can't look back and say this was a bad decision because something no one knew about or expected happened.
At the time, it was the right decision to trade Grabner rather than risk letting him go for nothing in October. I would say Gillis gave up a bit too much in the Grabner trade, but it was the right decision to trade him.
Shirokov was probably a mistake in the way he was handled. AV should have been more patient with him. He should have been brought up to play some games at the NHL level to get more of a taste of the NHL game.
We don't know what was going on between the Cody Hodgson camp and the Canucks coaching / front office. Personally, I think we could have really used CoHo in the LA series and if he was on the roster right now, there would be fewer concerns about our 2nd line.
I think Schroeder is being handled well up to this point. If he doesn't get a sniff at the NHL this season then I'll be with you. He played well enough in training camp to make the team. I'll trust what Gillis says at this point about the rest of the season.
I think one of the things that makes it look much worse is that we havn't had a lot of really high draft picks. The only top 10 picks we have had in the last 10 years were Luc Bourdon and Cody Hodgson - and for very different reasons, neither of those players is with us now.
Grabner was a #14 pick - and he ended up turning into Keith Ballard.
Jordan Schroeder was our next highest draft pick at #22.
Gaunce (26) and Jensen (29) are our only other first round picks in the Gillis era.