So trading say the 27th pick and 6th to move up to get Berniers wouldn't be worth it? If I was Jarmo I'd make that trade to get any of the top guys I really wanted.
Sure, if you think Beniers is going to be a #1C, and have him in a higher tier than whoever you expect to be there at #6, then trade up.
I watched about 10-20 minutes of video on each of the Michigan guys and I came to the tentative conclusion that Power is a tier ahead of everyone else, and Beniers is just okay. I can see why a lot of folks just expect him to be a #2C. In that case you'd be better off just taking whichever of Beniers, Guenther, Clarke, Edvinsson, or Hughes that make it to #6.
I currently have #6 at the end of the second tier, and being at the end of a tier is where you want to sit.
I’d make that trade. I don’t know how far the 27th pick moves you.
I think there is a gap somewhere before the 6th spot. I don’t know where it is though. Is is between 2 and 3 after Power and Beniers? Is it after 5 (Powers, Beniers, Edvinsson, Hughes, Guenther)?
If the draft goes something like Powers, Guenther, Edvinsson and the team at 4 is eyeing Wallstedt but thinks he’ll still be there later, they might trade back to 6 and then maybe even trade back again say if someone wants to move up to 6 to get Johnson or Clarke. Always dangerous to take a goalie so high so maybe they can trade 4 for 6 and 6 for 10.
So there are scenarios that get us Beniers for 4 and 27, but I doubt it.
I still haven't seen all of these guys, but I like Clarke. Seems like an RH Werenski. I'd have him in the second tier.
Power LD
Edvinsson LD
Clarke RD
Hughes LD
Beniers C
Guenther W
There's also a good chance one of the goalies (Wallstedt, Cossa) or one of the next wingers (Eklund, Johnson) is taken before my second tier is all gone, so I feel pretty safe sitting at #6. It might even be Beniers at #6.