woof
The point is unless you have a ringside seat in Poile's office we don't know what he tried to do. We don't know the calls that were made and we don't know what the response from those calls may have been. I don't claim to know specifics but I do know that he didn't just sit at his desk playing Angry Birds on his phone. The Weber negotiations tied his hands to a certain extent, if that could have been worked out things may have been different.
The results speak for themselves. Trying doesn't count.
If Weber was tying his hands, then he should have traded him to acquire an asset of equal value and then moved on to Suter/Rinne.