Right now I'm only playing NHL games and want to expand. Any suggestions? The themes can be anything, as long as it's a good game.
Still rocking the 360.
I have such a love/hate with the NHL series. Especially when the questionable AI suddenly becomes super human and dances around my defense as my goalie behaves like he belongs in the Special Olympics.
I too am on the 360, until someone gives me a reason to upgrade.
I've enjoyed:
The Fallout Series, especially 3
The Elder Scroll Series
The Batman Arkham Series
Red Dead Redemption
LA Noire
The Grand Theft Auto Series
NCAA Football
Madden
Midnight Club LA
Bioshock
WWE 2K14
Ghostbusters
The Dragon Age series
The Mass Effect Series
The Fable Series
Pirates! (actually a PC port releases for the orig. Xbox)
Civilization Revolution
It really depends on what you're into.
Do you want to lose yourself in an open world?
Are you into an epic story arch?
Do you want a diversion you can pick up and put down?
Do you want a long term investment?
Etc.