Maatta was actually quite terrible for stretches, where he made a lot of questionable decisions with the puck and was constantly getting burned and making wrong decisions for pinches. But overall, things that would be fine if he ever evolved his game to adjust to his lack of speed.
But he still makes wrong choices pinching and still plays like he isn't slow when he is.
I was willing to listen to the fact that he never had a proper off season in his entire career until this past summer to work on things. He didn't get faster. He looks like the same player from last season. More annoying is the people that seem to want to back up Olli without seeing him and these warts in a league that is pushing forward with speed and a player that can't seem to figure out how to fix that part of his game 5+ years in.
I like Olli, the guy has been through a ton and still keeps at it. His preparation for the game was 2nd to Crosby, but when you know he's a serious guy with his training and you don't see him work on his most glaring flaw....it's like, how much time are you going to waste defending someone that isn't going to get better in that regard?
While some of what you said has merit (like his pinches and underestimating his ability to recover when he pushes), I think you're focusing too much on his lack of speed and taking for granted what he does more easily/effectively than some of our other D.
- He pins guys on the boards and neutralizes cycle plays.
- He dispossesses good players in board battles without a fuss.
- Makes a good breakout pass.
- He doesn't take penalties...which is something people have always criminally undervalued. A guy like Subban had 82 PIMs last year. Maatta had 28. He doesn't handicap us that way.
- Good gap control when opponents are weaving to gain the blue line. Active stick swipes it out of harm's way.
- Excellent defensive awareness. He doesn't get caught chasing guys behind the net and abandoning his man in the slot like Letang did plenty last year and Johnson did this year. He stays glued to his man right in front of our net and breaks up the one-timer attempt.
- Maatta's just smart. He simply doesn't get scored on that much. +27 in 67 games in 2015-16. +17 the following year in 55 games. Last year he got paired with some of our struggling D, and thus didn't do as well in that regard. If his speed was really that harmful to our team, wouldn't he have gotten lit up more? Obviously he's finding ways to compensate.
Yes, he's been trash this year. Utter trash. But to say this is the same level as he played at last year? NO. That's just nonsense. He will improve. There'll come a point in the season where people will wait 5 games for him to goof up again, and try to paint the picture that he costs us every game like that. That's how it's always been with Maatta and the fan base. People see his lack of speed, label him worthless and turn the blinders on when he helps us win. Not saying you're exactly like those people, but I've seen that a lot over the years.
There's a good reason why he got offered that contract and why he's been trusted on the 1st pairing in the past. He's reliable.
Please have the capacity to not assume you're right about everything, and that other fans may see aspects of the game differently. I have been watching hockey for over 2 decades now.