Taylor Hall vs. Tyler Seguin

[Strong Hearts]

The 1st and 2nd overall picks from the 2010 NHL Draft. The pair, at one point, were considered elite forwards. Now, partway through the 2021–22 season, both players have been struggling offensively thus far. Who is the better player at the moment?

Click to read more...

 

[Kcb12345]

I would be shocked if Hall is as bad or worse than Seguin right now.

Seguin can't skate, can't make plays, can't handle the puck well, etc. Somehow has lucked his way into 7 goals (and I mean some serious luck)

He's not on the 3rd/4th line for no reason. Sad to see how much injuries have derailed his career

 

[OKR]

Seguin should just retire tbh. Already made enough money to be set for rest of his life, and he has his cup already, just enjoy life while you can still walk without the added pain.

 

[Mulletman]

I would be shocked if Hall is as bad or worse than Seguin right now.

Seguin can't skate, can't make plays, can't handle the puck well, etc. Somehow has lucked his way into 7 goals (and I mean some serious luck)

He's not on the 3rd/4th line for no reason. Sad to see how much injuries have derailed his career

Seguin is still the top dog in Dalllas with the most icetime per game of all forwards this season!

 

[The Tourist]

Seguin is about the 7th best forward in Dallas at the moment. Maybe not even that high. I can't imagine Hall is worse. As stated above, he has 7 goals but I'm not sure if he's actually shot any of them in. Most have just hit off his butt or leg and bounced in. The guy is just a shell of himself and it's sad to see. I'm hopeful a year from now he will look different but who knows. He might be done.

 

[Xspyrit]

Damn Seguin still has 5 years left at 9.85 AAV

Yes injuries can certainly derail a career

 

[surixon]

Seguin should just retire tbh. Already made enough money to be set for rest of his life, and he has his cup already, just enjoy life while you can still walk without the added pain.

Did that surgery he have really knock his game down that much?

 

[wintersej]

Hall has Charlie Coyle on a pace to destroy his career high in goals. Hall is fine, he just has replaced Krejci as the "1st liner on the Bruins second line that is surrounded by bottom 6 players" guy.

 

[Regal]

Hall is still a good player, he’s just not an elite player, and not in a position to put up his best numbers. Seguin meanwhile looks pretty close to being washed unless he can make big strides back to where he was.

 

[Miro4Norris]

Seguin just quit after his 10m x 8 contract

 

[AveryStar4Eva]

After Seguin’s injuries and surgeries he isn’t even half the player he used to be. He’s an LTIR case waiting to happen

 

[Boreal01]

It's been Hall since 2017

 

[Pi]

They both suck now.

 

[elitepete]

Neither?

 

[banks]

I don't have much faith left in Seguin. But Hall I just can't forgive the dismal performance of Hall with the Sabres. He was a disgrace.

Voted for Seguin.