Is this seriously a thread questioning JT? With all of the problems we currently have, he's the last guy that should be looked at. Especially when he's producing.
scott99 is being misunderstood here. He's not suggesting JT isn't playing well or is having a bad season. The key point that he's trying to put forth is that it's AMAZING that Tavares is 2nd in league scoring considering he hasn't even played close to HIS BEST this season.
And I agree with him.
Tavares hasn't played even close to HIS BEST. I think he was at his best in 2011-12, even better than last year's "Hart-nomination" year. That first line sucked last year but Tavares was outstanding, he still carried that team for the first half and the line the whole year (the line sucked in the stretch run).
Tavares hasn't put together a hot streak this year, and he'll definitely go on one of those runs sooner than later. He hasn't slumped at all, which he's done in the past, but has had 2-3 "bad games" - by his standards. Games where he didn't get much done, had some giveaways, took long shifts, forced passes through sticks and low percentage shots. Yet, he's managed some points in those games.
The "beast mode" that is commonly referred to on these boards - well, we haven't seen that, YET.
But I'd say he's been excellent this year. His ability to create offensive opportunities is as good as anyone in hockey.
And I still think he's got terrible linemates that don't complement his game. I'd say Nelson is the closest he's had since he's been an Islander - but he's too inexperienced and raw at the NHL level.
Better linemates would get him more points, but he's still a superstar, whether he gets the extra 10-15pts or not.
Crosby plays with Dupuis and Kunitz and they aren't big names and aren't offensively talented (Kunitz is pretty good but certainly not elite) but they complement Sid's game nicely. JT would do better with those two than he does with KO-Moulson. With Vanek, well, it remains to be seen.
I also think
TricycleDriveBy makes a great point. Sometimes we look at box scores and highlights of other players and think "oh, why can't Tavares have games like that"? - which is unfair. Because even Datsyuk, Toews, Crosby, Malkin, Giroux, Sedins, Kessel - they all go through games where they are ineffective.
And I watch a lot of hockey and other teams - I'd say JT is among the most consistent "superstars" out there. The best being, in my opinion, Crosby, Datsyuk, Toews, Bergeron and Tavares. These guys tend to stand out even when they aren't getting points. Tavares is one of the few who can often get points even though he doesn't stand out though.